I found my favorite pizza place! I would definitely, recommend Papa Gio's pizza on, 419 Chuluota Rd. on E. Colonial in Bithlo Fl., for an awesome pie, I'm originally from New England and since Of been down here in Fl. It's been hard to find a good pizza, with good price and quality, but Papa Gios has it. Thank you P.G's Awesome pizza. Great deals on Monday's & Tuesdays. I still have to try the subs, but I have to get over the pizza rush first!!
I used to only think of Papa Gio's when I wanted Italian but today I order a Bacon Cheese burger and a Philly Cheese steak sub. Both were over the top delicious! Can't say enough how much we've enjoyed the quality and taste of all the food we've ever been served. I hope they stay in the neighborhood forever!
Best pizza in town PERIOD! Great service. On Friday I ordered 9 boxes of pizzas to be delivered for my daughter's 4th birthday party that was on Saturday. Not only they delivered it exactly in time. Literally everyone of our guests complimented the pizza. Every slice gone! Thank you Papa Gio's for make my daughter's birthday a success!
Wow! Tuesday special, large for only $9.99 with no sacrifice on taste! Pizza was really good and their garlic knots with cheese. From the service to the food overall really good and right in thru neighborhood.
Amaury Ernesto Maldonado Maracallo
+5
I was born in the Bronx, that was my second time eating at this restaurant, and believe me: the taste of the dishes I have eaten títere, bring back memories of my childhood eating in the little Italy of my hometown.
These guys are a class act. There was an issue with our food and it was resolved before we even knew about it and the good part of the damaged pizza was brought to us at no charge, to eat while we waited for another pizza to come out. Felipe served us and was very kind. Will definitely be back!
Art By Solar - Theresa
+5
Always friendly staff that makes great pizza. My favorite is the white pizza. These guys are always kind and are doing their part keeping the restaurant clean and moving efficiently. Definitely worth visiting for lunch!
Amazing food! I ordered Sicilian pepperoni slices, and garlic knots, and they were amazing. It was first time here, and I definitely will be back. I recommend you get the cheesecake as well. I promise you will love it as much as I did.
Visited for lunch. Had a gyro which was huge in size and tasted fine. Meat was a bit crunchy and the lettuce was not as fresh as I like. The pitta bread was toasty. Had the gyro before and it was great, not sure if they had different cook. Decent portion of good fries. Will visit again, services is great and their pizza and garlic nuts are great. I guess I will go to a Greek place for a Gyro next time.
Best meatball subs and only $6.99 on weekdays before 4. I love this place!!!
Who would have thought a primarily take-out restaurant would have food this good? Lasagna delicious and well, balanced. Not acidic, flavorful, Good quality meat. Garlic knots set a high standard unmatched in the best tablecloth restaurants.. Killer good.
Update July 2023
Last time was so good, I hesitated to write this review.
Gnocci was overcooked into mush, prosciutto and asparagus were missing.
Great pizza 🍕. We always order pick up. Delivery times are difficult. This restaurant is busy and Delivery times are backed up. Not the restaurants fault. Staff works hard to get the food out. Be kind and leave honest feedback, or don't leave any at all. Go elsewhere. It's your free choice. We love Papa Gio!!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Orlando
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes