Best Restaurants in Old Lyme

⭐ Top

★ 100 /100

View →

Surface Shack

💬 11 reviews

📍 83 Hartford Ave

🍴

⭐ Top

★ 97 /100

View →

La Scarpettas Pizzeria Italiana

💬 208 reviews

📍 163 Boston Post Rd

⭐ Top

★ 95 /100

View →

South Lyme Scoop Shop

💬 46 reviews

📍 389 Shore Road

📋 Menu ⭐ Top

★ 93 /100

View →

Coffee's Country Market And Catering

American Cafe Deli

💬 202 reviews

📍 169 Boston Post Rd

📋 Menu ⭐ Top

★ 93 /100

View →

Pizza Plus

Italian Pizza

💬 368 reviews

📍 284 Shore Rd

⭐ Top

★ 91 /100

View →

Cafe Flo At The Florence Griswold Musuem

American Cafe

💬 51 reviews

📍 96 Lyme St

📋 Menu ⭐ Top

★ 91 /100

View →

Hangry Goose

💬 364 reviews

📍 11 Halls Rd

🍴

⭐ Top

★ 90 /100

View →

Vecchitto's Italian Ice

💬 75 reviews

📍 80 Hartford Ave

📋 Menu

★ 89 /100

View →

The Chestnut Grille At The Bee And Thistle Inn

Diner

💬 188 reviews

📍 100 Lyme St

★ 89 /100

View →

Old Lyme Seafood

Seafood

💬 77 reviews

📍 117 Shore Rd

📋 Menu

★ 87 /100

View →

Hallmark Ice Cream

💬 315 reviews

📍 113 Shore Rd

📋 Menu

★ 84 /100

View →

Old Lyme Inn

American Bar International

💬 344 reviews

📍 85 Lyme St

★ 84 /100

View →

Old Lyme Ice Cream Shoppe & Cafe

American

💬 281 reviews

📍 34 Lyme St

★ 84 /100

View →

Dock 11 Cafe

American

💬 135 reviews

📍 11 Halls Rd

★ 83 /100

View →

Teddy's Old Lyme Pizza Palace

Pizza Italian

💬 1300 reviews

📍 264 Shore Rd

★ 82 /100

View →

Black Hall Grille

American Bar Pub

💬 229 reviews

📍 100 Shore Rd

★ 82 /100

View →

The Public House

American Bar Pub

💬 95 reviews

📍 90 Halls Rd

📋 Menu

★ 80 /100

View →

Pizzeria Da Vinci

Pizza

💬 158 reviews

📍 19 Halls Rd # 7

★ 80 /100

View →

Hong Kong Ii

Chinese Asian

💬 116 reviews

📍 19 Halls Rd

🍴

★ 80 /100

View →

Redrollins Beach Shanty

💬 1 reviews

📍 83 Hartford Ave