Bagel Boy

Good bagels. Long wait time but well worth it. Wide variety of bagels and other breakfast delights available. I ordered a garlic bagel with jalapeno omelette and it was delicious but very messy. Hot chocolate is good but not great. My wife ordered an everything bagel with eggs and she thought it was tasty. Our order was incorrect but it was minor, and we can tolerate the mistakes. Staff were very busy but attentive to customers. Bathroom was clean.

I wish I could rate them higher because more than half the staff are reasonably friendly, and the food is reasonably good but not spectacular enough to make up for how long an order takes. Sometimes ordering in person can be okay, but usually not... And ordering online is ALWAYS too long a wait. So it's fine if you wake up in the morning to order lunch and figure you may get your food around suppertime. Obviously a bit of sarcasm, but rooted in consistent activity. Plan ahead if you want to get food from here until they invest in a bigger kitchen and more staff.

I just tried this place, wanting to deviate from my regular place closer to home. I honestly haven’t had a bagel this good since I lived in North Jersey well over 10 years ago. As long as I live in this area, this will be my go-to bagel and breakfast place! Bagels are super fresh, airy, and the perfect amount of chewiness. Also, you can order online through their site. Make this place your regular spot and you won’t be disappointed!

This place has steadily declined for the past 10 years. It is quite unfortunate that the owner is ok with how rude management can be to customers and how poor of a job they do at handing you an order you placed that’s 50% accurate at best. I ordered a jalapeno egg and cheese with extra jalapeño, salt pepper ketchup. I was handed a jalapeño egg and cheese with all those things AND Spinach, Raw Onions, no salt or pepper and drowned in ketchup. Fantastic job

Best bagels ever. I used to go to the original Brooklyn location in Sheepshead Bay. But I moved to South Jersey in 2020, when I retired, to be near my kids and grandkids. I missed their bagels but it's a 2+hour drive. So my daughter said let's try their NJ location. It was a little over and hour drive. It saved us over $30 in tolls. So it was like getting our bagels free! But most important, it's the same quality Bagel Boy bagels we were used to and missed so much.