Sluurpy
Reset

There are 9 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Salad in Ocean Beach

There are 9 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Castaway Bar & Grill
83/100 (283 ratings)
Restaurants
Seafood
American
Bar
Seafood
American
Bar
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Lemonade
Samuel Adams Summer Ale
Shrimp
Oysters Rockefeller
Pasta
Salad
Stuffed Mushrooms
Clams
Loco Moco
Oyster
Calamari
Chicken Tacos
Calamares
Jerk Chicken and Rice
Tempura
Tapas
Hamburger
Tacos
Chicken Wings
Pesto
Oyster
Mussel
Macaroni and Cheese
Juice
Filete of Sole with Rice and Vegetables
Mac Au Gratin
Fried Chicken Sandwich with Truffle Fries
Sit down
American
Seafood
Bar
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Takeout
Television
Reservations
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Mid-range
"We saw some negative reviews and were a bit nervous that it would be a letdown. We were pleasantly surprised! It was a rainy day, so many other..."
Samuel Schwiebert
"I hosted a party at Castaway and it greatly exceeded my expectations! The food was so delicious. We had a party of about 20 women and with such a..."
Elizabeth Miller
"We found castaway by accident. We arrived in time for happy hour. Great drinks, great oysters. The Brussels sprouts are out of this world & the wings..."
Madeleine Berg
"Castaway fried rice, as a worker on the island you can get a little lonely sometimes. But when I'm lonely you know what's there for me? Castaway..."
Chris James
"The food was great and the drinks were amazing. Preferred to r popular bay restaurant which I get was..."
Nicole Greco
"Jon and his staff are the best of the best. We held our wedding reception last weekend at Castaway and everything was perfect. Jon was super..."
Ellen Nichols
"Came here for lunch with my family today and had a wonderful time! Staff was very attentive and helpful. Chef was super accommodating to my wife’s..."
Bailey Henderson
"Food was very good.. would go back. Our server seemed like they were..."
Joseph Mastriano
"The food was very good, the service friendly, and the prices..."
Bruce Yablon
"Cool place to hang on Fire Island. Good drinks. Great atmosphere. Casual and beachy! Everyone was friendly. Great..."
Michael Gendron
"Castaway is a great restaurant. They had a loud but not bad band playing live music, good vibe, good drinks, and the food was good. However if you go..."
Paola Soto
"Chicken sandwich was absolutely delicious, great..."
Jesse Natter
Hideaway Restaurant
82/100 (203 ratings)
Restaurants
Seafood
Seafood
American
American
Dinner
Lunch
Salad
Clams
Tuna
Fish
Pork
Fruit
Avocado
BEEF BRISKET
Truffle Fries
Nachos
Buffalo Wings
Lobster Roll
Hideaway Burger
Stuffed Jalapeño Pepper
Pan Seared Shrimp and Lobster Linguini
The Hideway Burger
Shrimp
Pan Seared Monkfish
Lobster
Sit down
Seafood
American
Outdoor Seating
Live Music
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Dinner
Lunch
Fine Dining
"I really love the hideaway. The food and service are exceptional. They have one of the best spots to watch the sunset. Everyone gathered on the deck..."
KA Stazi
"We had a great time, great food & drink & live music!!! Can't wait to go..."
Joann Licci-Rut
"Great place on Fire Island with fantastic views of the water. The food and drinks were made perfectly! Delicious Hideaway burger and Korean..."
Chris Aldrich
"The food is better than most places on Fire Island ! Beautiful views that will make forget about the smell of sewage as you walk through the dining..."
Tyler Anderson
"I highly recommend this place. Absolutely Phenomenal food and a good price. They have great customer service. Big shout out to Sean, he was the best..."
Nicholas Dallas
"The views from this restaurant are absolutely amazing!!! Food was OK nothing special! Service not so good! But overall we made the best of it..."
BellaDona29
"This is Fire Island fine dining. The restaurant inside and out is just beautiful and every dish was so delicious. Its tucked away near the end of..."
JOE VZPHONE
"Loving the new menu at the Hideaway this summer. Crab cakes are a must though nothing disappoints! Great food with the best views in Ocean..."
Caroline Leonard
"Visiting from San Francisco. We had ceviche and fish of the day. One of the best seafood places that I have gone to in the US. Ceviche was served..."
Maryam Veisi
"Zach the chef is outstanding. Food was great. Sunset views are one of a kind in ocean beach. When on the "east end" of Ocean Beach, Pass the other..."
eldon tyrell
"IMHO one the best restaurants in ocean beach. Great place to sit outside, watch sunset over the bay and have a drink. Food has been consistently..."
Pxlz
"This has always been in my opinion the best place to eat in Ocean Beach. However this season when I was there they did not have their liquor license...."
J D
"Great view, good food. Don't even think of asking to change anything on any plate. Not accommodating at all. No one smiles on staff. ..."
ELLIOT METELKA
"A spectacular meal! Still an Ocean Beach..."
Laura Sobel
"Expensive, but so is Fire Island generally. The difference is that here, the food is actually very good compared to the mostly-mediocre alternatives..."
Christopher Adams
"The fish of the day was AMAZING! Great service, beautiful water view. Overall a great..."
mina mahdian
Albatross
81/100 (227 ratings)
Restaurants
Seafood
Bar
American
Pub
Seafood
American
Bar
Pub
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Shrimp
Salad
Calamari
Calamares
Tapas
Fish Taco
Tacos
Steamers
Burrito
Fish
Burger
Sit down
American
Seafood
Bar
Pub
Seating
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Gift Cards Available
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Drinks
Dinner
Late Night
Lunch
Mid-range
"Very pub looking place with a lot of regulars. Food was reasonably priced all of their salads especially the salad specials are exceptional. My..."
darin parker
"Albatross doesn't take reservations, so we went on the early side and had no problem getting a table on Julyv4. The grilled salmon was perfectly..."
Walter M
"Food was delicious and the service nice and friendly. I had steamers and mussels in marinara sauce. It was so good, I went back the next day and..."
Lois Guzofsky
"Best and biggest eggplant parmesan you've ever..."
Adam Davis
"The food really hit the spot after a long hot day at the beach. My son said the fish tacos were awesome. I had the burger, which was really good and..."
Chris Jelley
"Probably one of my favorite places to eat in Ocean Beach. Their wings are amazing and clams on the half shell fresh and on..."
Rick Boyle
"Best fried flounder sandwich! Great beer selection and high octane..."
George Ilchert
"A rare creature - a consistently good restaurant on Fire Island. Service is friendly and prompt. Food is good to great based on your selection. You..."
Neil Millens
"We only ordered seafood dishes. Everything was very fresh and delicious. Clams and steamers are a must. Flounder sandwich was tasty. Clam chowder can..."
Merve Poyraz
"We love the Albatross! Many great menu choices, AND, rotating specials daily. This is not typical in Ocean Beach so we look forward to dining here..."
Karen Warren
"Great food, quick and friendly service and gives you that old school sailor/fisherman's hang out feel. Nostalgic to Fire Island , many beautiful old..."
Megan B
The Island Mermaid
79/100 (834 ratings)
Restaurants
Seafood
Gluten Free Options
Bar
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Seafood
American
Bar
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Brunch
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Shrimp
Crab Cake
Lobster Roll
Steamers
Pasta
Salad
Octopus
Crab
Ceviche
Scallops
Pesto
Clams
Fish
Calamari
Mussels
Tuna
Burger
Calamares
Salmon
Sit down
American
Bar
Seafood
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Live Music
Reservations
Waterfront
Late Night
Lunch
Brunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"I usually don't write reviews, but my experience at the Island Mermaid was outstanding. Between the food, the service, and the view it was..."
Travis D'Arienzo
"The only thing that surpasses the quality of the food is the quality of the service. The staff operates with a level of professionalism not usually..."
Peggy Murphy
"I thought the food was delicious and the service was great. We did have to wait a little but it is a summer Sunday on Fire Island! The steamers and..."
Robin Katz Rabinowitz
"This place was fantastic. Food, service, great. Hostess Victoria Wisdom is a goddess. Entertainment by Miss Caitlin Bell, accompanied by Andy was..."
Douglas Marange
"My favorate on Fire Island. Outstanding view. Always a terrific meal. Broad menu. Excellent crew. Checks all the boxes. You're cheating yourself if..."
John McLoughlin
"Best burger I've ever had. The pomegranate martini was..."
Lorraine LiVigni Kennedy
"Came here for my friends’ birthday and had the most incredible meal. Everything was perfect from the vibes to the service to the tasty food. I..."
abby gardner
"They’ve continued to make improvements to the Mermaid and it shows. Now they have a permanent outdoor tent that would be great for inclement..."
Windows on the Sea
"Had (still having as I’m sitting dockside) an amazing meal. Wonderful food and service. Very kid friendly. Attentive and caring staff. Mussels and..."
Dr. Eric Turk
"We sat on right by the water, which was beautiful. The service was on point, you always felt you were taken care of. We ordered the tuna stack..."
ashley popek
"Food was good. Went on a Monday, Our first two appetizers of choice were not available. Good atmosphere, The salmon and Brussel sprouts were..."
joe balestra
"The service was incredible, unmatched vibes we came here for my birthday dinner and did not regret it. Staff treated us so right, definitely get the..."
Mia Deutsch
"Scott, the owner, took such care of us and all the food was lovely. The bus boy was conversant and conscientious. We loved our server Victoria! She..."
Lynne Sadusky
"Island Mermaid is our Fire Island Favorite, always consistently good. Definitely make a reservation, especially on weekends, they get busy. Great..."
Travis Nicholson
"A group of us came this weekend to celebrate my cousins bachelorette. Everything from the service to the food was perfect. Compliments to the chef..."
Brianna
"Such a great experience! The food was delicious especially their chicken wings. If you’re in fire island you must stop..."
Glenda Cordero
"I have been here a few times now and me and my family have loved it here every time. The service was great and amazing food to match. I will..."
Mark Davis
"The restaurant is amazing!!! Best service and atmosphere if you want an amazing dinner and vibes this is the spot. Good for friends family and just..."
Eliana Mischel
"Had a great time food was good Jesus was very attentive drinks were fun Scott suggested good one bailey's and club soda my fave and Ava and Finn kept..."
mari almond
Flynn's Fire Island
78/100 (682 ratings)
Restaurants
Grill
Grill
Dinner
Lunch
Clams
Ribs
Shrimp
Lobster
Salad
Sit down
Grill
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Buffet
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Always a great crowd and a fun time. Best view of the bay on the island. Sunday is Sunday/funday for good reason don't miss..."
Jeffrey Rubenstein
"The food was really good, service is excellent I love this restaurant I highly recommend this..."
Xinia Vega
"A great place to have lunch or dinner, a great place to grab a drink. The community is very comfy to have a vacation or a daycation. Beaches are..."
John Diprima
"Moon Chaser to Flynns for a great buffet. Courteous staff both on the boat and in the restaurant. Great way to spend a summer..."
Ennalyrrad Avilo
"Great happy hour m thru f 4 to 7 Free food half off drinks and prizes giveaways Can’t wait for the hot body bikini..."
Keith Kobza
"Had a great lunch there. It was a busy Sunday with an outdoor party going on. But the establishment is big and our family of 5 with kids found a..."
Saurav Pandit
"Had a great time at flynn's, food, and drinks a bid pricey but DJ So Dope was fabulous he played all types of music for everyone from young to older..."
Simmons having fun
"Loved the whole experience. From ferry ride to Fire Island. And the buffet was well worth the price. We went with a group of 16 and no complaints. ..."
Pam Kimler
"Had an amazing time seeing some bands and making new friends - thank you for being so..."
Sam Calle
"There is a food choice of menu or buffet. The food was seasoned and cooked to perfection, and an enjoyable value, and included a nice dessert. The..."
Barry Maltese
"We made a reservation for our group of 23 and they were able to seat us at one large table which was great. The staff was exceptional in providing..."
Paul Giglio Jr
"I gave this a 4 but what happened really disturbed me. The food was decent. Music was nice. Looked clean. What disappointed me is that twice I..."
Dina Cafarella
"My family and I dock our boat here and they have electric and water to connect to the boat. It is always so much fun and the other boaters are beyond..."
George George
"Very friendly staff. The girls behind the bar wrestling. I dare you to do that touristy thing and get that drink that everybody on this flip an..."
F G
"Great place to party, always packed and always has a great DJ. The dance floor is much smaller than it looks in photos but its fine for a group that..."
Jon B
"I love Flynns and will definitely be back. The food was delicious. Everything I had was delicious. The ambience was very nice with the lighting and..."
Mel Skeen
"Went to Flynn's on a special during the week offering. We took the Moon Chaser to the restaurant. It was an all round wonderful experience. Boat ride..."
Nest Vipers
"It was fun, but it would be a nice warning to let us non regulars know bring cash a head of time. Staff at the first bar you walk in are really..."
Hey Red
"The buffet and drinks at Flynn’s were fantastic! The sunset the night we were there was amazing! Great staff and atmosphere! Highly..."
Laura Corrigan
"Delicious food, friendly staff and amazing views. Their Watermelon 🍉 drink is super good and..."
Natalie Camargo
Rachel's Restaurant And Bakery
77/100 (432 ratings)
Restaurants
Dessert
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Cafe
American
American
Cafe
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Brunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Eggs Sausage and Home Fries
Pancakes
Chocolate Croissant
Variety of Icecreams
Salad
Apple Turnover
Avocado Toast with Egg
Club Sándwich
Eggs Benedict
French Toast
Breakfast Burrito
Bun
Rachel's Bloody Mary
Omelette
Eggs and Toast and Sausage
Coffee Cake
Raspberry Walnut Tart
Cakes
Strawberry Ice Cream
Avocado Toast and Caprese Omelette
English Muffin
Boozy Iced Coffee
Oatmeal
Bran Pancake
Café
American
Café
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Brunch
Mid-range
"My birthday cake, black magic with cream cheese frosting of course, went from OB to the Grove and finally to me on the mainland. It was the best one..."
Elizabeth Ullman
"This was my first visit to Rachel's. I tried an apple turnover and I was so delicious! I would definitely recommend the baked..."
Laurie Knoechel Mihalko
"Been going there many years never disappoints !!! Love the crumb cake � even with the updates still love it..."
Rose Marrone DePinto
"Loved my omelette! We had great service and will definitely be back..."
Tara Leigh
"I worked in ocean beach in the 80s and loved there baked..."
Will Finamore
"Baked goods are incredibly delicious and dining menu from morning to night will serve any..."
Enza Carone Lent
"Has great food and great service. Very kid friendly and very well..."
Ally
"We were looking for a great brunch spot in Fire Island and were pleasantly surprised with what Rachael has to offer. Hands-down the best bloody..."
Windows on the Sea
"Such a good burger!!! Was very hangry since it was 6pm and i hadn't eaten lunch and this tasted amazing!! Was so full afterwards. The staff was..."
Cloud Berries
"Delicious food. The best on fire island and an amazing restaurant for New York in general. The restaurant is mostly family run. All staff are..."
Darren Hakimi
"Rachel's is amazing. Food, drinks and desserts are..."
Jane Martinez
"Had a very nice dinner. Had the Ocean Beach salad. The acoustic are not that good. Very noisy. Could use some blinds in the windows. The late..."
Anthony Pemberton
"Stopped here for breakfast after bike riding 5+ miles. There was short line to get in, but worth the wait. I had the country egg sandwich, it was the..."
Janine McQueeney
"So happy we found this restaurant on Fire Island. As someone who has Celiac disease and has to eat gluten free to avoid being sick eating out can..."
D Capasso
"This place is really good - the food is on point for breakfast, lunch or dinner. It can get loud sometimes but it's worth it. Shout out and thank you..."
Michele Ogle
"Very nice and quaint spot for breakfast or lunch. We had the country egg sandwich and 2 egg platter, both were delicious, especially the potatoes,..."
Gina Antoine
"The food was the best we had hands down. It has less of a bar atmosphere which is great if you have kids or you’re not into noise. Literally the..."
Nicole Greco
"Excellent service and delicious, generous platters. Modern establishment with beachy vibe. We went for breakfast (eggs benny yum) but will return to..."
Johan Chabrel
"Greatest BLT and Avocado toast. Allergy free....Jen easily the best server on FI. Maggie so sweet. Sandwich was so good I needed to know the cooks..."
Mark Gamble
"The food was so good and the service wa great! Great variety on the menu, especially the omelets. I arrived at 1:55 PM and they still allowed me to..."
Crystal Williamson
"Best food and service on Fire Island by far. The prices are extremely reasonable as well. This is a must visit when in Ocean..."
John Kuitwaard
"The greatest fries! Good drinks and a good magi magi sandwich. Would go..."
missus doe
"We had the most delicious dinner here! We have been coming to Ocean Beach and Kismet for 10+ years and have always struggled to find food that is as..."
Olivia LaFemina
"Best food in Ocean Beach by far! Fresh ingredients and well..."
Julie Schaut
"Rachel's was an excellent dining experience. Portions were worth the price and each member of our party enjoyed all of our meals including pasta,..."
Timothy Sniffin
Maguire's Bayfront Restaurant
71/100 (760 ratings)
Restaurants
Bar
Seafood
Bar
Seafood
American
American
Gluten Free Options
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Steamers
Fish
Paninis
Shrimp
Lobster
Salad
Crab
Clams
Calamari
Mussels
Tuna
Calamares
Salmon
Sandwiches
Burger
Chowder
Sit down
Bar
Seafood
American
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Reservations
Playgrounds
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Gift Cards Available
Full Bar
Dinner
Late Night
Lunch
Mid-range
"Amazing , food, setting and staff! Best place by far on Ocean Beach! View is breath taking.. great family..."
Tish Daniello
"We had dinner outside there this past Saturday for my hisband’s Birthday! The seafood is so delicious!! The view is beautiful and our waiter aka..."
Vanessa Hernandez Cereste
"Delicious food, fantastic service and beautiful views! My husband and I had the salmon and sausage ravioli. Both dishes were..."
Christa Ciccone Johnson
"Our favorite restaurant in Ocean Beach; food is delicious, great atmosphere and the best sunsets on the..."
Jennifer Graffagnino Vormittag
"The best view in fire island and really good food! Had a..."
Safayet Mazumder
"Great place to have a drink and great..."
Clifton Pedrow
"Best place in Ocean Beach to watch the sunset! The food is great..."
Tracey Babroff-Green
"Had a great time. How can you not when it's happy hour, great view and the bartenders were awesome. Good is..."
Terri Troise Nirrengarten
"We go to lobstapolooza every year on our vacation. Great food and fun. We had a party of 17 and everything was great and service was quick and..."
Mary Benz
"Great place on the water. Nice atmosphere outside. Food was really good. Our waiter was attentive and super nice!perfect! Excellent fresh margarita..."
Tamara Foster
"Maguires is a dope Bayfront spot! And as a parent of a little one, the perfect spot to have drinks while the little one plays on the swing set..."
Mikey O
"Macguires is a lively eatery that isn't too expensive, especially if you're a bit low in cash after the ferry ride to Fire Island in the first place...."
Alden Sykora
"Great food, view and our server, Captain Ron was phenomenal. Highly..."
Anna Giallo
"It was my first time visiting Fire Island. My cousin made reservations for 3:15 for 9 of us. We were seated in a timely manner and waited on by..."
Danak D
"5+++ Stars. Rode our bikes specifically to this restaurant from the Fire Island Lighthouse. A trek well worth the reward. Had the roasted Bronzini..."
pd speh
"We stopped here for lunch and enjoyed high quality food and excellent service. Burgers and salads are very good and relatively non expensive given..."
Denis Mantsurov
"The service was ok, server was a little underwhelming. The food was very good overall. The Korean ribs were a little salty and the calamari needed..."
Keisha H
"Lovely ambiance, delicious seafood, interesting specials, and unique cocktails! Would absolutely return. With limited options for dinner on the..."
Marina Melillo
"Food is great. Service was great . Truffle fries are a dont miss. Drinks great fun place. Best lobsters in town. See photos I posted. There pork chop..."
J D
"Friendliest, chillest servers ever. Great outdoor seating. Fish tacos, fried calamari and lobster roll were delicious. They have the best Rocket..."
Natalia Grabczynska
Matthew's Seafood House
70/100 (523 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Seafood
Italian
Central-Italian
American
Seafood
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Salad
Bloody Mary
Crab
Clams
Skirt Steak
Mussels in White Wine Sauce
Filet of Sole
Fish
Spicy Margarita
Fish and Chips
Cornbread
Tostones
lobster tail
Lobster Roll
Margarita Madness
Shrimp
Lobster
Sit down
American
Seafood
Serves Alcohol
Gift Cards Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Delivery
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Reservations
Live Music
Waterfront
Seating
Table Service
Lunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Mid-range
"Fantastic meal to start the summer of 2016. I know I should have had fish but I don't eat fish! I couldn't pass up the Chicken Parm on the menu. One..."
Scott Weinstein
"Wonderful food and service. The view was unbelievably beautiful. We had lunch with Baked Clams Matthew and the Cobb salad with jumbo shrimp and..."
Sue Millwater
"The market fish was halibut last night and we had it Mediterranean style. I was amazed how fresh and perfectly cooked and seasoned. Worth every..."
Becca Bk
"One of the best restaurants in Ocean Beach food and staff are amazing.The music on Wednesdays with Dennis and Ivan is worth the ferry ride over..."
Mike Arena
"Best food on the island.. hands down.. you must experience the food and the beautiful..."
Melissa Luciere
"Excellent atmosphere, food and service Cody was wonderful Would always recommend..."
Ryan Madigan
"Matthews is by far the best place on Fire Island!!! They make the the best Rocket Fuel on the Island. If you don't believe me ask..."
Steve Longo
"The best food and view on fire island. Been going for about 20..."
Dale Long
"Atmosphere is beautiful. Server was excellent. Food and drinks..."
Susan Lee
"Beautiful Sunset Good Food and Entertainment. One of the better restaurants in Ocean Beach Fire..."
Tom Munster
"I had a fantastic time being with my family and loved ones,will be going back in 2..."
Tony Balsamo
"Simply the best Great atmosphere And the service is..."
Claire King Hauth
"Our favorite annual midweek visit to Fire Island. Beautiful dinner. Lovely to see Annie as..."
Am Duross
"How many words can describe fun???? Use them all! Good food, great servers, lovely sunset! Went for lunch, then dinner the next..."
Kristin Signore
"Very Romantic Place!! The food is tasty and the drinks are good. The atmosphere and the beautiful sunset is just..."
Ann Saintilien
"Had been here many years ago and arrived by our small boat and docked right at the restaurant. Eager to have their great clams casino and a..."
Udo Wahn
"Fire Island’s best restaurant with amazing waterfront view and delicious seafood ❤️🌅. Baked clams were sooo good, and so were the calamari,..."
Linh Vu
"Im embarrassed to admit I have been coming to FI for 35 years and this is my first time eating at Matthews -- and it did not disappoint! We had the..."
Carrie Abolafia
"I have been coming out to Fire Island for years…and my annual tradition of my lobster dinner is a treat I look forward to. First time at Matthews...."
Cynthia Charles
"Absolutely the best lunch I've had on Fire Island! The spicy margarita was perfectly balanced - spice, sour, sweet and salt. And, the mussels were..."
Jeffrey Carlisle
"Absolutely beautiful view and great food. All cocktails were great. Nice atmosphere! Very good service 👍🏼. Thank you for staying in..."
Elana S
"The cornbread at Matthew’s literally blew my mind. I do not even remember how the rest of the food tasted. The cornbread was just so good it..."
Mackenzie
"For a Fire Island restaurant, this place is pretty good. The views at sunset are stunning. Many cool drinks to try. My only complaint is that my..."
Wayne Bennett
"Always freshly caught 🐟 fish on the menu. You'll be happy you decided to eat here. Pleasant views of the boats cruising The Great South..."
John Galluzzi
"Beautiful, right on the water, great drinks, less touristy and crowded than other places, great service, the mussels were good too. Go for the sunset..."
Sasha Uzui
"Great spot but when the winds blow the right way the smell of the sewage treatment plant across the street can be overwhelming when seated out in the..."
Frank Zambaras
"One of the better restaurants in Ocean Beach in terms of food selection and quality, not to mention the seating right on the water. Wednesday is..."
Jeremy McCurdy
"Matthew's is our favorite restaurant on FI. The drinks are always on point. Food is always fresh. And it has best view in our opinion. Very friendly..."
Ian Greenberg
"Sat right on the dock after a relaxing beach day. The raw seafood was very fresh and perfectly chilled. Definitely would..."
Rachel Z
"I stopped here for lunch simply because it was the first stop on my trek west from Sailor's Haven. I expected a slightly overpriced meal (and of..."
Steven Wilson
"Sword fish was out of this world. Not often your getting great food at FI. Matthew's nailed it! See you Friday guys...."
Robert Johnson
"Absolutely best spot in Ocean Beach. Seafood super fresh and service was..."
Zenobia Brown
Matthew's Seafood House
70/100 (538 ratings)
Restaurants
Seafood
American
Seafood
American
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Skirt Steak
Salad
Mussels in White Wine Sauce
Crab
Clams
Filet of Sole
Spicy Margarita
Fish
Cornbread
Fish and Chips
lobster tail
Tostones
Lobster Roll
Margarita Madness
Shrimp
Bloody Mary
Lobster
Sit down
American
Seafood
Serves Alcohol
Gift Cards Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Delivery
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Reservations
Television
Live Music
Waterfront
Seating
Table Service
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Fantastic meal to start the summer of 2016. I know I should have had fish but I don't eat fish! I couldn't pass up the Chicken Parm on the menu. One..."
Scott Weinstein
"Wonderful food and service. The view was unbelievably beautiful. We had lunch with Baked Clams Matthew and the Cobb salad with jumbo shrimp and..."
Sue Millwater
"The market fish was halibut last night and we had it Mediterranean style. I was amazed how fresh and perfectly cooked and seasoned. Worth every..."
Becca Bk
"One of the best restaurants in Ocean Beach food and staff are amazing.The music on Wednesdays with Dennis and Ivan is worth the ferry ride over..."
Mike Arena
"Best food on the island.. hands down.. you must experience the food and the beautiful..."
Melissa Luciere
"Excellent atmosphere, food and service Cody was wonderful Would always recommend..."
Ryan Madigan
"Matthews is by far the best place on Fire Island!!! They make the the best Rocket Fuel on the Island. If you don't believe me ask..."
Steve Longo
"The best food and view on fire island. Been going for about 20..."
Dale Long
"Atmosphere is beautiful. Server was excellent. Food and drinks..."
Susan Lee
"Beautiful Sunset Good Food and Entertainment. One of the better restaurants in Ocean Beach Fire..."
Tom Munster
"I had a fantastic time being with my family and loved ones,will be going back in 2..."
Tony Balsamo
"Simply the best Great atmosphere And the service is..."
Claire King Hauth
"Our favorite annual midweek visit to Fire Island. Beautiful dinner. Lovely to see Annie as..."
Am Duross
"How many words can describe fun???? Use them all! Good food, great servers, lovely sunset! Went for lunch, then dinner the next..."
Kristin Signore
"Very Romantic Place!! The food is tasty and the drinks are good. The atmosphere and the beautiful sunset is just..."
Ann Saintilien
"Had been here many years ago and arrived by our small boat and docked right at the restaurant. Eager to have their great clams casino and a..."
Udo Wahn
"Fire Island’s best restaurant with amazing waterfront view and delicious seafood ❤️🌅. Baked clams were sooo good, and so were the calamari,..."
Linh Vu
"Im embarrassed to admit I have been coming to FI for 35 years and this is my first time eating at Matthews -- and it did not disappoint! We had the..."
Carrie Abolafia
"I have been coming out to Fire Island for years…and my annual tradition of my lobster dinner is a treat I look forward to. First time at Matthews...."
Cynthia Charles
"Absolutely the best lunch I've had on Fire Island! The spicy margarita was perfectly balanced - spice, sour, sweet and salt. And, the mussels were..."
Jeffrey Carlisle
"Absolutely beautiful view and great food. All cocktails were great. Nice atmosphere! Very good service 👍🏼. Thank you for staying in..."
Elana S
"The cornbread at Matthew’s literally blew my mind. I do not even remember how the rest of the food tasted. The cornbread was just so good it..."
Mackenzie
"For a Fire Island restaurant, this place is pretty good. The views at sunset are stunning. Many cool drinks to try. My only complaint is that my..."
Wayne Bennett
"Always freshly caught 🐟 fish on the menu. You'll be happy you decided to eat here. Pleasant views of the boats cruising The Great South..."
John Galluzzi
"Beautiful, right on the water, great drinks, less touristy and crowded than other places, great service, the mussels were good too. Go for the sunset..."
Sasha Uzui
"Great spot but when the winds blow the right way the smell of the sewage treatment plant across the street can be overwhelming when seated out in the..."
Frank Zambaras
"One of the better restaurants in Ocean Beach in terms of food selection and quality, not to mention the seating right on the water. Wednesday is..."
Jeremy McCurdy
"Matthew's is our favorite restaurant on FI. The drinks are always on point. Food is always fresh. And it has best view in our opinion. Very friendly..."
Ian Greenberg
"Sat right on the dock after a relaxing beach day. The raw seafood was very fresh and perfectly chilled. Definitely would..."
Rachel Z
"I stopped here for lunch simply because it was the first stop on my trek west from Sailor's Haven. I expected a slightly overpriced meal (and of..."
Steven Wilson
"Sword fish was out of this world. Not often your getting great food at FI. Matthew's nailed it! See you Friday guys...."
Robert Johnson
"Absolutely best spot in Ocean Beach. Seafood super fresh and service was..."
Zenobia Brown
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use