Sluurpy
Reset

There are 8 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Oakdale

There are 8 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Gold Dust Pizza
94/100 (1215 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Café
Italian
Pizza
Wheelchair Accessible
Highchairs Available
Takeout
Seating
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"My families favorite pizza! every friday night - Eureka deal!!! Everyone was very nice and helpful. I also love the drink machine it's the best! Root..."
Erich Boese
"I love the crust #1. I first walked in and was kind of irritated that there was no salad bar. But.... It's actually better that they don't! They..."
Tammy Bengtson
"Best pizza I have had in a long, long time. Each bite was so full of flavor. I was ummm ummming each bite. Differently going..."
Josie Gallegos
"Consistently delicious pizza with an abundance of toppings. Everything we've tried is great! Friendly staff, unique sodas and old pizza parlor..."
Jen David
"Best pizza ever!!! Highly recommend this great establishment! The atmosphere in the restaurant is pleasant, staff are very friendly and the food..."
Matt Torres
"Best pizza in town!!! They have a great happy hour: Monday thru Friday 2-6 PM. They have a new cauliflower crust,..."
Shannon Fuller
"This is our favorite pizza place! Their crust is amazing! Everything is always good. The chicken is always cooked..."
Megan Wann-Robare
"Got full with 1 slice and wings but made it a mission to finish 2 slices 😤 The pizza here is 💣 Hands down one of the top 3 pizza spots in all..."
Yareli Ramirez
"Best Pizza in Stanislaus County. The best pizza, it's parlor style with lots of toppings. Two slices will definitely fill you..."
Ivan Baez
"Always a great experience at this gold does pizza. Gold dust Pizza Oakdale always hooks up their pizza with tons of toppings and let me tell you I..."
Ron
"The most satisfying pizza anywhere. We have traveled all over, and finding a great place isn’t as easy as you think. Gold Dust is Fresh, great menu..."
Mary Fairymaires
"The pizza and breadsticks were the best! The hostess was amazing. She recommended things that were delicious and we will be recommending Gold Dust..."
John Cachu
Chelestie's Italian Kitchen
90/100 (677 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Italian
Sit down
Italian
"Came in for my father’s birthday, everything was excellent!! The food was tasty and full of flavor. Jessica was our server and she was exceptional...."
Louis Arresta
"Nice restaurant with a ton of menu options. Plenty to choose from for all types of diets. Great, comfortable environment. Friendly staff and..."
Paul Mallia
"I am one of those fussy Italian Americans who desire great food, great service, a clean and pleasing ambiance and a well-paced meal. I can say all my..."
Linda Cezanne
"Mannino's was a last minute choice after our original destination was closed due to flooding. The menu had many appealing choices of pasta, steak and..."
CR Walters
"The atmosphere the people working There The best . The waitress Felt like Family waiting on us bottom line the food. There was 6 a bus, not one..."
Lou Coacci
"Everything here is delicious! Best Thai calamari I’ve ever had and their bolognese sauce is top notch. So good that I can eat the sauce as a stand..."
Andy Selden
"Mannino's was a last-minute replacement after our first choice was closed due to flooding. There were plenty tempting spaghetti, steak, and seafood..."
tiffany crespo
"Great service. Excellent food. The waitress Liz was superb. Definitely worth..."
Michael Guerra
"Nice single page menu of favorites and specials were standouts. Service from both waiter and busing people made for a excellent dining experience. ..."
Stephen Wong
"We went for dinner with 6 people, we made reservations ahead of time. Once all of us were there they sat us right away. Everybody had their own..."
Gary L DiClementi
"The Veal Carini tasted unseasoned. I had to put a lot of salt on the mushrooms, sundried tomatoes and brown gravy that smothered the veal. The..."
Deedie Roze
"Visited for Son's birthday. Extremely happy with all facets from Rich our server to the food which was delicious. A little pricey but well worth..."
Chris C
"I have been here many times and I respect the personal attention and service here / the restaurant is extremely consistent and its great-excellent..."
Peter Zorzy
"Here, everything is excellent! Their bolognese sauce is excellent, and their Thai calamari is the best I've ever had. I can eat the sauce by itself..."
abdelkader guendouz
"My husband and I moved to Long Island six years ago and this restaurant is the best Italian food I’ve had on Long Island. If there was a rating..."
Brenda Destephano
"Although the food was nice, it was pricey compared to what we were used to at other restaurants. We waited too long, and our customary spot was..."
Marcial Villanueva
"Went there for a birthday celebration, and we weren't disappointed. Service is top-notch. Our server was Seth, and he was extremely attentive and..."
M Scotto
Mama's Italian Restaurant
88/100 (319 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Dinner
Lunch
Italian
Pizza
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Delivery
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Love this place, our favorite go to for gluten free italian, The staff is outstanding! Always a great dining..."
Laura Anne Bilello
"Always a good meal at Mama's. We have a relation that need to eat gluten free and she loves coming here to dine. The service is excellent as well as..."
Ken Mensing
"Great food and service, also huge selection of gluten free foods. My wife has a gluten intolerance and loved..."
Jim Laird Jr.
"Best pizza, penne ala vodka & linguine with clam sauce! Been coming since it opened. Had our first date here 30 years..."
Adriana Martino Wetzel
"Great food and service. Nice atmosphere to have dinner with family or the loved one. Fresh homemade food and good..."
Dennis Guzman
"Thank you Mama's for catering the gluten free food at our party last night. The food was delicious and the presentation was great! Your attention..."
Pninit Ron Cole
"From the food to the vino, service, and atmosphere...a fully enjoyable evening. Salute a..."
Michael Ballin
"The Brooklyn slice is top notch, and so is the rest of the food there. The owners are also very nice people who make sure you have a great..."
Eddie Casanova
"Mama's is our default place for my niece with Celiac's disease. No worries about cross contamination ever! Everything is..."
Kenny Dyer
"Food delicious,service was very professional and we had a great time.Would highly..."
Maria Carmine Sigmund
"I love the gluten free menu. You aced it!!! Especially the mozzarella..."
Lori Capasso-Newell
"Absolutely awesome from food to service. We had let the waitress know that we were pressured for time as we had a show we were heading to see and she..."
Kathy Alegre
"The food was delicious will recommend it the place was clean, quiet, n the service was..."
Olga Alvarado
"Cosy little place with the Italian vibe you'd expect from a charming Long Island Italian place. It's half traditional slices and half sit down..."
John Siebert
"My wife and I visited yesterday afternoon for their pasta special. We live nearby, but we haven’t been here in years. Friends have told us to give..."
Seagull on a soapbox Poops
"Kyle.was.our server Started us off with 2 glasses of water Bread sticks House Salad Lobster Raviolli in creamy sauce with seafood bits Chicken..."
Patriot The Penguin (Bottlesgonewild)
"Friday night is go out to dinner night...and a treat indeed to find such a gem. Home cooking with no waiting! Cozy and warm, friendly and delicious...."
Glenn
"Pizza was very good, made quickly. Well topped, good attention to details like keeping bubbles under control and topping the pie to the edge of the..."
Benjamin Jolly
"Very delicious food , friendly staff, and a unique dining experience! We love mamas. Best penne ala vodka ever! And great catering..."
Kaley Donovan
"Awesome classic italian restaurant. Food is always top notch ..staff is always super friendly. Highly..."
Vinnie Pinzone
"Christie is very sweet and attentive. We really enjoy the great shrimp marinara and love the spinach cannelloni! Pasta Night specials on Monday and..."
D
"The food here is outstanding! As for Italian food, this is the closest you’re going to get to real homemade food. I’ve never been disappointed...."
Robert Jones
"I came to this place with my wife for dinner, and for 3 days after, we didn't have to buy dinner because their portion sizes are so damn BIG. Prices..."
Simaan Gaffary
"Nice Italian pizzeria/restaurant in Oakdale on Montauk Hwy. Some typical Italian dishes served in the restaurant. Did not try the pizzeria. Very good..."
eldon tyrell
"Christy (spelling?) our waitress was extremely friendly and always smiling. Our food was amazing and we got big portions. Such a nice place and..."
Blood Legion
"Excellent food, great service and fair cost. Will definitely return. My son had a food coma..."
Philip B.
"The food is amazing. The staff very courteous. Great place to take out or dine..."
Maria Dimonda
"Great Food Fast Friendly service. All the people that work there give you friendly service and treat you like family. Not like other Italian..."
Richie Vaz
"Fabulous Food at a Reasonable Price & Superb Service! I'll definitely Return and will recommend Mamma's to family and friends. I was definitely..."
Pam Berg
Original Mama's
83/100 (203 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Seafood
Italian
Seafood
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Italian
Seafood
Pizza
Wheelchair Accessible
Seating
Table Service
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"Cosy little place with the Italian vibe you'd expect from a charming Long Island Italian place. It's half traditional slices and half sit down..."
John Siebert
"My wife and I visited yesterday afternoon for their pasta special. We live nearby, but we haven’t been here in years. Friends have told us to give..."
Seagull on a soapbox Poops
"Kyle.was.our server Started us off with 2 glasses of water Bread sticks House Salad Lobster Raviolli in creamy sauce with seafood bits Chicken..."
Patriot The Penguin (Bottlesgonewild)
"Friday night is go out to dinner night...and a treat indeed to find such a gem. Home cooking with no waiting! Cozy and warm, friendly and delicious...."
Glenn
"Pizza was very good, made quickly. Well topped, good attention to details like keeping bubbles under control and topping the pie to the edge of the..."
Benjamin Jolly
"Very delicious food , friendly staff, and a unique dining experience! We love mamas. Best penne ala vodka ever! And great catering..."
Kaley Donovan
"Awesome classic italian restaurant. Food is always top notch ..staff is always super friendly. Highly..."
Vinnie Pinzone
"Christie is very sweet and attentive. We really enjoy the great shrimp marinara and love the spinach cannelloni! Pasta Night specials on Monday and..."
D
"The food here is outstanding! As for Italian food, this is the closest you’re going to get to real homemade food. I’ve never been disappointed...."
Robert Jones
"I came to this place with my wife for dinner, and for 3 days after, we didn't have to buy dinner because their portion sizes are so damn BIG. Prices..."
Simaan Gaffary
"Nice Italian pizzeria/restaurant in Oakdale on Montauk Hwy. Some typical Italian dishes served in the restaurant. Did not try the pizzeria. Very good..."
eldon tyrell
"Christy (spelling?) our waitress was extremely friendly and always smiling. Our food was amazing and we got big portions. Such a nice place and..."
Blood Legion
"Excellent food, great service and fair cost. Will definitely return. My son had a food coma..."
Philip B.
"The food is amazing. The staff very courteous. Great place to take out or dine..."
Maria Dimonda
"Great Food Fast Friendly service. All the people that work there give you friendly service and treat you like family. Not like other Italian..."
Richie Vaz
"Fabulous Food at a Reasonable Price & Superb Service! I'll definitely Return and will recommend Mamma's to family and friends. I was definitely..."
Pam Berg
Firenze Ristorante
82/100 (706 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Pesto
Shrimp
Pasta
Salad
Sit down
Italian
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Definitely 6/5 stars. 1st time dining here. Stopped by after our trip to Yosemite. Best Italian food we've ever had. Jared was our over attentive..."
Ragni Chand
"The customer service was fantastic. Had a good dinner. Found the soup a little in the bland side. The chicken marsala and chicken piccata were..."
Lisa HD
"Good fresh bread comes before the meal, which is nice. The pasta was good and thee salad was average. It was generally a good experience but..."
Abby Rankila
"I didn't expect much coming into this restaurant but the food and service proved me otherwise! We loved everything we ate. Everything was fresh and..."
Joey K.
"Really really really freaking good!! Great service to boot. Laid back atmosphere with a huge Italian menu to choose from. Wood fire oven to offer..."
Tim Tuomey
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant
81/100 (2791 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Alfredo
Pesto
Pasta
Salad
Sit down
Italian
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Food was great. Timing was quick. Pricing was acceptable. Kids coloring menu was not the right paper material for crayons…not that my son used it...."
Kimberly Kay Urban
"Samantha was our server and she was very friendly! The food was delicious i had Chicken Marsala and it was amazing! Chicken Alfredo was my other..."
darlene cheruto
"Came here with family for mine and my nieces birthday dinner. (June 7, 2022) The manager came out and offered us different seating options so that we..."
Shelley Haynes
"Delicious food, beautiful servers, elegant ambience with an air of old world charm. We have yet to be disappointed at an olive garden restaurant...."
Reuben L Correa
"Same old Olive Garden. Not much difference between location with the exception of the service. Lunch time is a good time to go for best pricing and..."
Csaba Andrasfi
"Great service. Wonderful friendly staff. The grilled chicken Alfredo was soooooo delish! They accommodated me with butter topped bread sticks..."
Cindy Lou Whoo
Bella Bambina's
81/100 (686 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
"Bella Bambina's is the best the lunch special will fill u up at a small price. The pizza is great everyone should try a Crispino pie or slice. The..."
Bob Bachman
"Bella Bambinas food is excellent!! All of the specialty pies are always good and there sauce is always delicious. Used to only go to Savianos but the..."
Chris
"I am a fan of grandma's pizza and I thought that Savanio's made the best grandma pie, UNTIL, I tried Bella Bambinos grandma's pie.!! I will never buy..."
Mary Jones
"Nice ambiance - Good pizza. A really nicely put together pizza place. The decor is great. Food is very good as..."
Thought For Food
"From my very first order I was pleasantly surprised by the quality. More chicken and veggies balanced well with pasta. Soups are full of chunk! Not..."
Kimberly Sabat
"I order the pizza through too good to go, I got a plain cheese pie. It was a good pizza pie I ate all of it in 3 sittings. And all for about $11,..."
Michael Kaiser
"Enjoyed the chicken parmigiana pizza that was good on chicken chunks. I've also had the plain slice. Always hot when served. Love that they're one..."
Trish Goodwin
"Clean and delicious with an excellent crew. Everything from their famous garlic knots to speciality..."
hao nguyen
"So I read so many positive stories about Pizzaiolo that I had to try it. Ordered inside and took it home. I was truly impressed! The pizza is a..."
Joe DeMauro
"Can’t say enough. Bohemia finally found themselves an A+ pizza restaurant. Super friendly staff clean and delicious. Everything from specialty..."
Adam Petry
"Great food Amazing staff Love going there for a weekly..."
Michelle Newberg
"Been here 4 times for takeout and every time the food is..."
Ed Schmitt
"Highly recommend this spot as your regular pizza place. I’ve actually done catering and regular pizza take out from them and the food was..."
Justin Szpilka
"I have to say, this place is honestly the BEST pizza place in the entire bohemia , sayville , Ronkonkoma area. The food is absolutely amazing. The..."
Kay Mazz
"Ordered from this place 3 times . Haven’t had luck with this place getting food delivered. Half the order was missing , We did call and..."
Rob Tarsio
"I'm a Sales Manager at a local dealership and we had food catered by Pizzaiolo. The food was incredible. Everyone in the store was extremely happy..."
jillian hudson
"if you’ve been to the location in commack you should expect the same level of great food and friendliness of the staff. I’m always looking for..."
Michael O'Brien
"Richie and his team are awesome! Food is delicious and staff is very friendly. Also great for catering lunches and events. Great place! 10/10..."
Aimee Gosse
"Pizza is very good. Much better than previous owners. Look for reviews from May 2022 forward. Anything older than that was for previous owners...."
Gary Vaccaro
"Placed an order for Grilled Blackened Chicken and Chicken Franchise dinner with sauteed spinach. OMG! Mouth watering good - and I and a hard..."
Suffolk County Locksmith Inc
"In the LIDL shopping center. Delicious pizza (we had broccoli ricotta & Sicilian), Calzone, rice balls and Zeppole. We went for a couple of slices..."
Nancy Fariello
Mannino's
78/100 (877 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Pesto
Shrimp
Pasta
Salad
Clams
Calamari
Calamares
Sit down
Italian
Valet Parking
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Full Bar
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Came in for my father’s birthday, everything was excellent!! The food was tasty and full of flavor. Jessica was our server and she was exceptional...."
Louis Arresta
"Nice restaurant with a ton of menu options. Plenty to choose from for all types of diets. Great, comfortable environment. Friendly staff and..."
Paul Mallia
"I am one of those fussy Italian Americans who desire great food, great service, a clean and pleasing ambiance and a well-paced meal. I can say all my..."
Linda Cezanne
"Mannino's was a last minute choice after our original destination was closed due to flooding. The menu had many appealing choices of pasta, steak and..."
CR Walters
"The atmosphere the people working There The best . The waitress Felt like Family waiting on us bottom line the food. There was 6 a bus, not one..."
Lou Coacci
"Everything here is delicious! Best Thai calamari I’ve ever had and their bolognese sauce is top notch. So good that I can eat the sauce as a stand..."
Andy Selden
"Mannino's was a last-minute replacement after our first choice was closed due to flooding. There were plenty tempting spaghetti, steak, and seafood..."
tiffany crespo
"Great service. Excellent food. The waitress Liz was superb. Definitely worth..."
Michael Guerra
"Nice single page menu of favorites and specials were standouts. Service from both waiter and busing people made for a excellent dining experience. ..."
Stephen Wong
"We went for dinner with 6 people, we made reservations ahead of time. Once all of us were there they sat us right away. Everybody had their own..."
Gary L DiClementi
"The Veal Carini tasted unseasoned. I had to put a lot of salt on the mushrooms, sundried tomatoes and brown gravy that smothered the veal. The..."
Deedie Roze
"Visited for Son's birthday. Extremely happy with all facets from Rich our server to the food which was delicious. A little pricey but well worth..."
Chris C
"I have been here many times and I respect the personal attention and service here / the restaurant is extremely consistent and its great-excellent..."
Peter Zorzy
"Here, everything is excellent! Their bolognese sauce is excellent, and their Thai calamari is the best I've ever had. I can eat the sauce by itself..."
abdelkader guendouz
"My husband and I moved to Long Island six years ago and this restaurant is the best Italian food I’ve had on Long Island. If there was a rating..."
Brenda Destephano
"Although the food was nice, it was pricey compared to what we were used to at other restaurants. We waited too long, and our customary spot was..."
Marcial Villanueva
"Went there for a birthday celebration, and we weren't disappointed. Service is top-notch. Our server was Seth, and he was extremely attentive and..."
M Scotto
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use