Sluurpy
Reset

There are 2 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best New York Style Pizza in North Myrtle Beach

There are 2 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Basil's Pizza Seafood & Subs
84/100 (1812 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Pizza
Pizza
Italian
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Wings
Meatballs
Lasagne
New York Style Pizza
Pesto
Shrimp
Eggplant
Pasta
Salad
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Accepts Visa
Wheelchair Accessible
Accepts American Express
Accepts Discover
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Highchairs Available
Digital Payments
Accepts Credit Cards
Non-smoking restaurants
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Seating
Table Service
Lunch
Late Night
Dinner
Cheap Eats
"Let me start with I am a Jersey girl and grew up with some amazing pizza, for SC this was a good pizza. I don’t think we will be going back the pie..."
EastSideBlonde Basic
"We had the mozzarella sticks, garlic toast, and meat lovers pizza with the badil sauce. Sauce was a little runny and bland. Mozzarella sticks were..."
Alicia Cahill
"Good is always fresh, hot and cooked to perfection. Staff is very friendly. Eat here every time I visit cherry..."
Tonya Towery
"Visit #1 - Had a meatlover's pie, take out. Delicious. Great fresh ingredients. Awesome staff. Visit #2 - Dined in tonight. We love this place!..."
Marc Jonescu
"Really excellent thin pizza! Ordered take out of a large white cheese with ricotta. Ready in 15 min. Staff was super organized and the lady that took..."
R Boom
"Great place to eat pizza. We have come here for years. Diana made it easy to know where to go for pick up and dine in. She has an organized system...."
Jennifer Faircloth
"Absolutely LOVE this pizza place! We got it multiple times on our trip. The time they were closed we ventured and tried another local pizza place and..."
Braxtyn Kaylor
"The best gluten free pizza I have EVER had! Wonderful flavorful and the crust was the perfect balance of chewy/crispy. Even the non-GF people in our..."
Missy Griffith
"I'm from Wisconsin have family on the beach probably heard of Hewett's A/C if you're from there. Anyways I made the mistake of ordering one pizza. I..."
Tom Hewett
"Delicious pizza!! Definitely one of our favorite stops in North Myrtle, wish we would've tried it earlier in our trip. If you want yummy pizza, go..."
Sharon Langill
"This was a great place to eat. It came recommended from the condo owner. We had the pizza. Amazing crust and sauce. Waited for a table on a Tuesday..."
B L
"The kitchen, cooking and server personnel greeted us all at once when we walked in the door, we were seated immediately, and the pizza was amazing...."
Howard Smith
"Really liked it! I went in the off season so service was a bit slow and my glass was empty for a long while but the prices are good and the portions..."
Laura McCoy
"WOAH, Talk about amazing. This was my first experience with Basil's as I just moved to Longs/Little river area. It was their opening night for the..."
Teague Bush
"I really enjoyed the all meat pizza. It has fantastic flavor and abundant toppings but the crust was a little thinner than I expected. The fries are..."
Steven Bagwell
"Not new york but probably the best tasting different pizza I ever had. Really tasty. Looked like a fake pizza but really great taste! Thank you for..."
Omar Clinton
Geno's New York Style Pizzeria
82/100 (1229 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Salad
New York Style Pizza
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Parking Available
Delivery
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"This pizza is the best pizza south of NYC.  If you are looking for real New York pizza this is for you...so so good!!! highly recommend and look..."
Todd Cecil
"I moved here 24 years ago and 3 months after my arrival I discovered Gino's!! Best NY Style pizza in the area, Italian dishes are homemade and..."
Sandi Bergstrom
"I was born and raised in south Philly. Moved to the beach 16 years ago. Boy did I miss the pizza  you could get on any corner in Philly. Then I..."
Merle.johnson
"I can't say enough about this restaurant! The pizza is true New York style, the Italian food is terrific, the subs are better than a 'sub' place and..."
Rumcq71
"Best pizza in MB!! Huge slices quick delivery and reasonable prices...if u want NY style this is the place! We have ordered here 3 years and loved it..."
Dorrie Collins Dils
"Pinwheels Are Amazing. The Spinach IS..."
Ffkahuna13
"I'm Italian and I'm very impressed. My wife and I came to Myrtle Beach for vacation. Being Italian, I always try to find the best Italian food..."
Chrisalan
"Very good pizza - a little slow though!. Family and I ate pizza here during our summer vacation of 2013. Very good pizza even though it took quite..."
BillPG
"Very reasonable price very good in fact it's the best pizza I've ever had. And very good service...."
Jared
"Excellent pizza. Delicious thin, crispy crust. Try the Margherita pizza for a special..."
Dave S.
"Pizza and sandwiches are awesome!! Large portions. We eat there at least twice on every..."
Gig Smith
"Pizza was awesome. A must if you are in the north myrtle beach..."
Ken Evans
"We ate here for the very first time and simply loved it. Wont find a place like the back home. Pizza and wings are simply out of this world and the..."
Scott Lynch
"Oh Man!. Delicious pizza, great prices! everything i've tried on the menu has been amazing. i could go back every single..."
Anonymous
"Decided to stop in for dinner on our last night in town. Well worth it!!!! Definitely will come back here every time we are in..."
Melissa Kanode Baldwin
"Pretty Good. Very tasty cheese pizza, but not nearly as thin as some of the other reviewers claim. Also, don't try to order cheese bread or you will..."
K L
"Really good sauce and crust. Decent value,..."
Kevin Ross
"You Feel You Are In NEW YORK. Seriously... the best pizza around. Just got back from being in the NYC area for 7 months... and Gino's pizza makes you..."
ReneeP
"I actually crave this pizza. Being a transplanted New Yorker, I understand how hard it is to find NY Style pizza here in the south. Yes, folks, it is..."
NikkieLynn
"Yummy takeout!. The slices of pizza are huge! The strombolli was also enough for two meals (for a pregnant woman) and..."
MelB
"Thin, but size isn't everything. The pizza at Genos is excellent. Reasonably priced and very tastey. It is however possibly the thinnest pizza I have..."
Smudners
"Love the..."
Denver's Mom
"The closet NY style pizza you can get in this..."
Matt
"Big Slices. Geno serves the kind of pizza I like. Large, thin, soft slices with gooey cheese on top! New York Style! A little pricey for pizza but..."
Ben
"The best real NY pizza in north myrtle beach period!! You definitely have to try this place!! Great food bygreat..."
Frank Russo
"Excellent. Fast service, friendly staff...pizza was huge and..."
Leslie'smommy
"The owner is from new york and the pizza is the best. Nice little shop with pretty fast..."
Jock-E
"I only leave a review if the food or service is really bad or exceptionally great. Me and my family ordered the Sicilian, 20" ny cheese and a couple..."
Buzz Killer
"Best pizza I’ve ever had in my life even better than my mothers homemade, which is hard to beat Service was good although that doesn’t matter all..."
Abby W.
"We waited 45 minutes for two slices and wings. I finally got up to ask and our food was sitting on top of the oven but I number had yet to be..."
T S
"We are from NY — always in search of edible pizza while on vacation (we don’t normally have good luck in SC) but this place was worth a try and..."
JC
"Great pizza spot, food was very fresh and tasted great. Pricing was also great for the..."
Ronnie Weston
"Great New York style pizza!! As someone from the Bronx...I know real authentic New York style pizza!! Gino's NY Style Pizzeria is DEFINITELY the..."
Billy Reynolds
"The food was so good. Had lasagna salad and garlic knots. The portion was huge and was just like I had up north. The steak and cheese sub very good..."
Beverly Dettelbach
"Oohhh this was so good! We ordered via the “slice” app and had it delivered. The food arrived piping hot and it was absolutely delicious. We got..."
Blair Scroggs
"I came here 2 to 3 times a week. And had always been good but today I order a Genos caser salad, it came with chicken. Not what a asked for . I..."
Ashley Hill
"As a native New Yorker who just moved from NC to North Myrtle Beach, I'm picky about pizza. I ordered the Margherita pizza from Gino's, because they..."
Oak Island Morkie
"As a native New Yorker I can say their pizza is hands down THE BEST in the area. The staff are lovely as well, especially Carissa and..."
Melissa Tiburcio
"Awesome to find a Gino's here in my travels!! Had to stop for some NY home 🍕1 pie was just a lil doughy, other was perfect!probably cause it was..."
Deborah G
"This pizza is delicious. The crust is browned just right and the sauce is flavorful. The customer service is good, people are friendly and welcoming...."
CHERYL SWAIN
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use