The best Salmon in Newburgh | Sluurpy updated in May

Tin Fish Newburgh

88/100 (1025 ratings)

Quick Bites

Restaurants

Seafood

American

Dinner

Lunch

Swordfish

Burrito

Waffle Fries

Shrimp

Fish & chips

Fish

Salad

Scallops

Oyster

Calamari

Calamares

Salmon

Fish & Chips

Tapas

Fish Taco

Tacos

Cod

Seafood

American

Outdoor Seating

Takeout

Live Music

Seating

Wheelchair Accessible

Serves Alcohol

Parking Available

Highchairs Available

Full Bar

Dinner

Lunch

Mid-range

"Fish wasn't bad, but this place is overpriced and overrated. My wife did love the fish tacos but she's easier to please. Just wasn't worth the money..."

Jonathan W Hodge

"The food is always hot and fresh although I can't rate a place higher than 3.5 for fried fish that's overpriced with styrofoam plates and plastic..."

Steven K

"Had the fried oysters, and corn and crab chowder. The oysters were pretty good. I rarely get fried but seemed like a good idea. My husband got the..."

Dwp

"Best Fish Taco!. Freshly prepared fish that reflects its origins in San Diego, CA. My favorite is the fried cod taco with fries and slaw. But their..."

Bjzimmer1414

"I like this place, but the website really does some false advertising. I've never seen raw oysters or crab legs on there menu. It's irritating for..."

Rebecca Curl

"Great Fish!. The fish at Tin Fish is always fantastic. I have never had a dish there that I did not like. There is a great variety to the menu and..."

Wintra

"We ordered the fish and chips along with the mahi mahi taco and stuffed mushrooms. We were def very impressed. For a hole in the wall place that..."

Kevin James

"Best seafood in the tri state. It is the season of lint, and the fish places are going to be packed on fridays. They told me lunch and dinner are at..."

Shoshamaru

"Visiting from Nashville. After a short three hour drive from Nashville my wife and I were hungry and from recommendation decided on Tin Fish for..."

Matt

"Great food. I decided to try this place after seeing all the great reviews. I knew in advance about the ordering at the counter, plastic forks, etc...."

Lola

"Love the Fried Oysters!. They're always fresh and..."

Gina LuvubuhbyeMayes

"Mixed feelings. First time visiting I decided to try my two favorite seafood dishes, Clam Chowder and Calamari. Calamari was great, felt the portion..."

Trace Duke

"Seriously good seafood. This place is definitely not into frills- you order at a counter, the forks and plates are plastic. But the food makes up for..."

Jessica

"Absolutely the best seafood in the area and great service. They really care..."

Charlie Downs

"Strange layout for a resturant. But it works. Just north of the river , and very nice staff. Had a good fish, shrimp and crabcake. A bit much for..."

Lone Starr

"Good food, reasonable prices, bucket of 5 beers for $15. Not bad. Fries are awesome, crab cakes were good, not the best but..."

Dmitri Krajec

"A hidden treasure. Grilled mahi-mahi taco, fries and coleslaw...It was all yummy. The coleslaw is sweet. If you like sweet, it's great. I do like..."

Kathy Boen Nall

"Favorite spot in Newburgh, not even close! Wife and I both ordered fish tacos w fries and slaw. Couple o beers, bill was $28. If you want a..."

Chris Mullis

"Reminders Of Home. As transplants from Northeastern Wisconsin, we sometimes miss the traditional Friday night fish fry of lake perch, fries, cole..."

Lysentia Jade

"Amazing cod fish tacos! Definetely worth a..."

E. Smith

"Sweet!. This place truly is a gem of Newburgh. Excellent food! A bit pricey but worth..."

Mr Highway

"Great Fish Tacos!. Really enjoy the variety you get with the fish tacos. You can pick from several kinds of fish and have them fried or..."

Jager

"Good food. We try and eat there often. Just bought a BOGO coupon book and TimFish is in there so we will be going some..."

Wpody

"Pricey, but good food. As one is too expect with seafood it is quite pricey. However, all of the dishes I have had here have been very good so far...."

Bryan Faw

"I'll be back.. The grilled Mahi-Mahi Fish Taco was good-n'-messy. All the ingredients tasted fresh and the sauce was hot enough to be good but not..."

Heavyal

"Good food, good service. Tried the Tin Fish for the first time yesterday and really enjoyed it. I tried the fried oyster po' boy with cole slaw. Very..."

Cmallyn

"I guess ok. Food is alright little on the pricey side but good..."

Bigmom10

"Yummy!!! The only place in town with fried oysters and they are..."

Food Lover 812

"Great fish and chips but the price you pay is..."

MAtt

"Good Seafood. I really enjoyed my lunch, however I think the prices are a little high for what you..."

Joe

"Great little seafood spot. Check it..."

Matt Kemp

"It is really good. I had the fish sandwich and my mom had fish taco. Both were freshly prepared and a very good portion. For both meals it was..."

Peggy Darlene

"Absolutely perfect food and service. They treated me and my wife as if we were the only customers in the whole place. The food came out fresh, hot,..."

Lee Halbig

"This was my first time dining here. We were seated & greeted immediately. We caught them during the Sunday brunch, but they also have a few items..."

Melanie J Watkins

"I've been wanting to try 10 fish for about a year now. Was finally able to do so and enjoyed it greatly! The raw oysters where off the hook! Had a..."

Jim Hines

"Staffs were nice and atmosphere was cool! It was clean. The dishes were healthy and fresh. It was good for brunch. Price also was..."

Jennie.B

"Best salmon ever! Portion size was good, too. My husband had the fish sandwich with waffle fries. Both delicious. The only downside was the iced tea...."

Gaye W

"Here, you order at counter and they bring your order to you. Still not use to a service fee, ( 4% ), for paying using a debit card. Not all places..."

Reset

There are 12 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Salmon in Newburgh

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters

Kimberly Crill

Jigar Patel

Dave Barnhart

Stan Bruno

Anon Ymous

Carlos Gonzalez

Dem Pal

Adrianne D

Jonathan W Hodge

Steven K

Dwp

Bjzimmer1414

Rebecca Curl

Wintra

Kevin James

Shoshamaru

Matt

Lola

Gina LuvubuhbyeMayes

Trace Duke

Jessica

Charlie Downs

Lone Starr

Dmitri Krajec

Kathy Boen Nall

Chris Mullis

Lysentia Jade

E. Smith

Mr Highway

Jager

Wpody

Bryan Faw

Heavyal

Cmallyn

Bigmom10

Food Lover 812

MAtt

Joe

Matt Kemp

Peggy Darlene

Lee Halbig

Melanie J Watkins

Jim Hines

Jennie.B

Gaye W

J.A.

Shelly Lipscomb Arico

Cha Burn Black

Paul Williams

Dan Larson

George Yorgakaros

C Vargas

Danny Donovan

Scott Weiss

Carl Ellyn

Marvin Hayden

Tammi Montgomery

Nikalodean24

Caesar Alarcon

Rick Cockram

Nat Shor

Eric R. Lenza

P Buckley

Frank F. Smith

Victor Erdahl

NeCee Miller

Sarah Richardson

getsig