Reviews Pickelman's Pantry & Pub

4
JudyJ
+4
Very good food but service was a bit slow. Having said that, we would go back.
4
Tristan Wheeler
+4
Went there twice. Has a really interesting collection on the menu
4
Darline McHarless
+4
This place is pretty cool. They have tons of food on their menu. From a burger to a sandwich to Spaghetti to breakfast. I really enjoyed the little salad bar they had going on as well. The service was really good and I would definitely come back. But I noticed that there's a lot of meth heads working there and lived around there. That's the only downfall. It's pretty sketchy. But I guess in a small town people get bored and all they do is do drugs and drink.
5
Larry Crofoot
+5
I had great service and good food. Having celiac's and being gluten sensitive the cook fixed my breakfast in clean pans to avoid cross contamination. The wait staff was fantastic, never letting my coffee get cold and seeing to all our small parties needs. I would recommend this stop to anyone.
5
J Loehr
+5
We had excellent breakfast meal. I love their hashbrowns, cooked perfectly - crispy on the outside and soft inside. The toasts were thick and generously buttered. The bacon strips were cooked just right, not too crispy or not too soft. I would come back here again.
5
Charles Haacker
+5
I give it 5 stars for quality, price and service! They serve breakfast all day. I had the Mexican omelet, which did not require me to add any hot sauce because it was perfectly seasoned to my taste, loaded with meat, onions, peppers and cheese, with more cheese on top, plus salsa.
4
Elmer Boutin
+4
Stopped in here with a large group while traveling in the area. I had a pasty, which was quite tasty. The only complaint anyone had was that the onion rings weren't very good. The service was excellent. This is certainly a solid choice if you're in the area.
5
Josjua Desentz
+5
Awesome small town food. Absolutely the best place in newberry. Arrived at closing time and the waitress said come in and said I'm not going to let you go hungry. Considering nowhere else to eat for like 40 plus miles. Couldn't be happier.
4
Jackie Mason
+4
Dinner was very good. Salad bar was great! Went back for breakfast. One of the best omelets I have had in a long time! The Denver omelet. Ham, onion, and mushroom. Yum!
5
Trei Herbster
+5
Breakfast is amazing! Especially their French toast. And get many dishes for a affordable price. Servers are kind and very helpful! Never to busy and very calm environment.
5
Dave Goheen
+5
Good food. Good service. I got to meet and visit with my sister Nita for the first time in years and got to meet my adorable niece Alyson for the first time ever. My daughter got to meet her cousin and give her a hug.