Andrea Rudin
Pizza Cottage is a Central Ohio institution. They serve top quality and delicious pizza every single time. The atmosphere is always low key, relaxed, and the service is always quick and friendly. They don’t skimp on toppings, and we never have to worry about leaving there any other way but stuffed to the gills! Our only “complaint” is that delivery would be a welcomed option. However, nothing beats fresh-out-of-the-oven pizza right when it’s made. Love this place!
Shanna Hart
Pizza Cottage has gone down hill and gotten really expensive for bad pizza. We used to really like them but didn't go very often because they were on the more expensive side. This time we ended up with two small pizzas that were gross and a mostly lettuce salad for $43. Not worth it and extremely disappointing. My pizza was a small gluten free cauliflower crust that was burned black on the edge and under done chewy in the center. I was up charged $5 for being gluten free and they ruined the crust. Save your money and go somewhere else.
beth ders
The steak sub was huge but was a hamburger patty. Ok, but too much mayo. Fries were good. Prices and service were good. Took a star away as my the food did not sit well.
Bobbi Galvin
The veggie pizza is awesome! I get the personal size, which has a very thin crust. The staff is very attentive. The reason for 4 stars, is that there are usually a lot of tables that need bussed, so it looks a bit messy.
anna ott
Ordered a pizza online, and was told 35 minutes, completely cool- UNTIL we went inside and the pizza WASNT EVEN MADE after those 35 minutes. With three kids waiting on food, and it took well over an hour to get it done because the employees were dancing, singing, and filming tiktok’s in the back instead of making food. Bless the woman’s heart who was nice to us up front but it was outrageous! Waited for a new pizza, only to be disappointed with a sloppy, extremely greasy, and floppy pizza.
Mandee Cole
Seat your self and the waiter says we are very slow . Well every table on patio is filthy tells us to sit at a table that has 14 seats for 2 people. The table he had us sit at was even filthy ….
Brian Mercer
Always enjoy this pizza. Pep and sausage are the way to go. Salad was plenty big as well. A great local option.
Anthony Springer
I love this pizza joint! The crust is thin and crispy and the cheese is extra stringy! The restaurant itself is clean and open. They have an area set aside for the bar. The prices are good. The bread sticks are a little think for me, but the marinara sauce was awesome!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes