Sluurpy > Restaurants in Newark > Nutter's Sandwich Shop

Review Nutter's Sandwich Shop - Newark

Edward Stubbs
This was our first time ordering from there. One of the best things was, you were greeted with a friendly 💖 sincere "hello" as soon as you walked through the door, by the staff. That was really refreshing. We had the crab cake special. One crab cake sandwich and the crab cake platter. Both were very delicious. The Homemade Crab Bisque was DEE😋 LICOUS. Hot when served and the "soul slaw?" was great! It was a little hike for us, about 7 miles but, it was worth it and we can't wait to go back and try more of their menu. Thank you "Nutter" for a delicious meal and a wonderful experience 🤗
Mad Dog 03
First time here.nice friendly staff. Placed order crab cake sandwich, and they brought out to vehicle. Everything was homemade fresh and delicious I'll be back for another visit.
Matthew Stark
I would give 5 stars but they toasted my bread and it was too hard to eat. Food is great otherwise and staff are really nice. Next time I'll ask them not to toast my bread. Make it an option please.
john hughes
They do not skimp and make a nice fat sandwich for you. Try the chicken salad..it is delicious. Parking and leaving can be a challenge with traffic sometimes
Brennen Raimer
Today I went to try Nutter's for the first time. I ordered the cuban. 10 minutes later, when they brought it out to me, they had the wrong order and had to go back and remake it. Another 5ish minutes pass, apologize and hand me my order. I get home, open my order: italian sub and crab (?) fries. It s a good sandwhich, but this is not what I ordered. Also getting in and out of that parking lot is a nightmare
saint carolina
♢ it's tricky pulling in (parking) and pulling out (exiting) this location because there is double traffic and a BUSY crossroad intersection zooming past!! I know if this establishment had a bigger parking lot and easier parking situation this place would profit even more! 🤩🤩 ♢ I have tasted the italian panini (5 stars!!!) ♢ The Italian sub is LOVELY but every time I get it.. the bread get soggy 😫😆They double wrap it in foil which I appreciate. Make sure to ask for the oil/vinegar on the side if you’re not going to eat it immediately ♢ The Crab Soup is by far the best thing I have ever tasted in a long time. You MUST try that soup! It is so impressive... 😍😍😍👌 ♢the chicken salad is delicious - you can taste that the chicken is great quality and the salt and pepper YUM! There’s also celery in it 😆 ♢ There is no public restroom
Shawn Presbery
Little place, big taste. For me the meatball sandwich was the star of the show. The chicken salad club reviews are on point but, truth to much lettuce to little salad. The taste was a 9. The soup was very good, in some ways to good (crab shells). If I had a solid complaint it would be the amount of sodium used to increase the taste. That you Nutters your customer service was a 10 as well.
Dreà
Very Friendly, Staff made recommendations and they bring your order out to your car when it’s ready :) The Crab Bisque & Cuban Sandwich are Delicious! Will be Back!!!
Jackie Kreiner Davis
Fresh Crab Bisque daily, the best.. Fresh Chicken Salad daily, so good, then tried Avocado Salad.. OMG This place is the best and for me well worth the drive..
AD Fray
Terrific food and great service. It gets busy at times, but what do you expect - their food is in high demand and it is a small place. Plus, the customers are always talking and sharing stories making the atmosphere very communal. The best (and healthiest) sandwich on the menu is the Avacado Powerhouse. Keep up the good work!
Thomas Andrea Schweitzer
Food has always been very good...especially the Avocado Powerhouse. But the service, especially call in orders is, well, Poor, one star. Went there today, they said to give them 20-25 minutes when I called in. I walked in 25 minutes as instructed, gave them my name and order and paid and waited another 10. watched a man walk up, order a powerhouse and walk out with one, before me! I asked again, group behind the counter confused and not exuding a lot of customer service tact, but not rude...just not helpful or apologetic. When after waiting another 10 minutes, I was told it was being made, but no one was at the sandwich station making anything!! I asked for my money back. Suddenly a young man gave me the one finger "wait a minute" and produced a powerhouse. No I am sorry, or hey this ones on us...just, we had a lot of phone in orders today... Well here's one for you, See Ya. I can find another more convenient parking lot and sandwich shop...hello, Daddy O's!
Traci Robinson-McGinnis
Delicious and addicting crab bisque! Definitely worth the drive!
Matthew Fields
I grew up down the street from this hidden gem and now 15-20 years later I still have to get it every time I go home to visit my parents. Phenomenal food.
Chris Liskey
Best friggin crab bisque. My job stops here every 3rd week, I always get at least a quart.
Corine Wadkins
Remember when it was a little grocery store owned by Melvin Nutter! Who's owner now?😉
Mimi Sullivan
Love the sandwiches and crab soup..and everything seems to be made with love and attention to detail.
Julie Hart Stewart
Meatball sub was delicious and bisque is always yummy!! So glad you are on my way home from work!
Angela Findle
Come here for their crab bisque, subs, sandwiches...everything is fresh and delicious!
Carol Huenke Kaufman
The sandwiches we ordered were outstanding, the service was quick and personable!!
Alexis O Sampson Holland
I love their Crab Bisque one of the best I ever had!
Rachel Krall
Thank you for your vegan options! I just had the avocado powerhouse with mashed chickpea salad. It was amazing! You made this pregnant girl's day!
Bagels Bass Beef Bento (Lunch Box) Biscuits and gravy BLT Bolognese Breakfast Sandwich Burger Burrito Cakes Calamares Calamari California Style Pizza Cannelloni Cannoli Carrot Cake Catfish Ceviche Cheeseburger Cheesecake Cheesecakes Cheesesteak Chicken And Waffles Chicken Parmesan Chicken Sandwich Chicken Wings Chili Chowder Churrasco Clams Club Sandwich Cobb Salad Cockle Cod Corned Beef Crab Crab Cake Crab Legs Crab Soup Crawfish Crepes Croquettes Cupcakes Curry Dim Sum Donuts Duck Dumplings Eggplant Etouffee Fajitas Falafel Filet Mignon Fish Fish & Chips Fish Soup Fish Taco Foie gras Fondue French Dip French Fries French Toast Fried pickles Gazpacho Gelato Grilled cheese Gyros Halibut Hamburgers Hanger steak Hoagie Hot Dog Hot Pot Hummus Ice Cream Jambalaya Juice & Smoothies Kabobs Kale Salad Kung Pao Chicken Lamb chops Lasagne Lettuce Wraps Lobster Lobster Roll Mac and cheese Matzo Ball Soup Meatballs Meatloaf Minestrone Mongolian beef Mussels Nachos Noodle Octopus Omelette Oyster Pad Thai Paella Paella Valenciana Pancakes Pasta Pastrami Sandwich Patatas Bravas Pho Polenta Pork Tenderloin Prawns Pretzel Pulled Pork Sandwich Ramen Ribs Risotto Roast Beef Salad Salmon Saltimbocca Sandwiches Scallops Schnitzel Scrapple Seafood Paella Seafood Platters Shawarma Shellfish Shrimp Shrimp and Grits Steak Frites Steak Sandwich Suckling Pig Surf And Turf Swordfish Tacos Tapas Tater tots Tempura Tiramisu Toasts Tortellini Tortelloni Tortillas Tres Leches Tuna Veggie Burger Waffles Waffles & Crepes Wings
Share on WhastApp
Share on Facebook
Browse the menu
Add review