Our award winning crab bisque has been a staple of the Newark food scene since it was introduced in 1980's. Our delicious bisque is made from scratch each morning using a combination of freshly picked claw and lump crab meat, butter, cream and old-bay seasoning. See for yourself what the buzz is all about.
15.95 $
Nutter's Specialty Subs & Sandwiches
Homemade Chicken Salad
Our famous chicken salad is made from scratch daily with fresh celery and all white breast meat. Sandwich size is served with our own gourmet chips and fresh grapes. Please specify if you would like lettuce, tomato, sweet peppers, hot peppers, pickles or onions added as well.
12.5 $
Avocado Powerhouse
Our original vegan favorite is served with one full avocado, baby spinach, tomato, cucumber, onion, dill and sprouts on toasted 12-grain bread. Served with our own gourmet chips and red seedless grapes.
14.7 $
The New Yorker
A real monster of a sandwich that will please all hungry eaters. 1/2 lb. of freshly sliced pastrami, Swiss cheese, coleslaw and Russian dressing on rye bread. Served with Herr's chips and a pickle.
12.25 $
The Real Deal Italian
Imported capicola ham, Genoa salami, provolone. and pepper ham on a sub roll with olive oil, oregano, lettuce, tomato, onions and sweet and hot peppers.
12.25 $
Organic Mashed Chickpea Salad Sandwich
Our mashed chickpea salad is made fresh daily using organic chickpeas. This sandwich includes 1/2 an avocado and baby spinach on toasted 12-grain bread. Served with our own gourmet medley chips and red seedless grapes.
14.7 $
BLT Sandwich or Sub
The classic BLT sandwich. Bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise on bread or a sub roll.
11 $
Hot Subs
Homemade Meatball Sub
12.25 $
Pulled Pork BBQ Sub
Tender pulled pork in a sweet hickory flavored BBQ sauce. Served on a 9" or 12" roll with cheese.
12.25 $
The Spitfire Sub
Hot Italian sausage sauteed in a flavorful tomato sauce with sweet peppers and onions.
12.25 $
Cold Subs & Sandwiches
Dietz and Watson Turkey Breast
We use only the best turkey from Dietz & Watson. Try it on white, wheat, rye or on a 9" or 12" roll. Specify choice of : Provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, sweet peppers, hot peppers, pickles or onions.
12.25 $
Good 'Ol Ham & Cheese
Sometimes the simple things in life are the best and what’s not to love about a ham and cheese sandwich. It says, “Hey, enough with all the fancy stuff and give me some simple eats to fill my stomach!” Served with American cheese on either white, wheat, rye or a 9″ or 12″ sub roll.
11.75 $
Albacore White Tuna
We make our tuna salad fresh every day. Served on bread or a 9" or 12" roll. Please specify if you would like lettuce, tomato, sweet peppers, hot peppers, pickles or onions added to this menu item.
12.25 $
3 Cheese Sandwich or Sub
A mix of provolone, Swiss, and American cheeses on a either bread or a sub roll. Sandwiches come with lettuce and tomato. Subs come with lettuce, tomato, sweet and hot peppers, pickles and onions.
11.5 $
Grilled Paninis
Chicken, Mozzarella and Roasted Pepper Melt
Mozzarella, grilled chicken and roasted red peppers melted with a pesto spread on 12-grain bread. Served with grapes and gourmet medley chips.
11.95 $
The Gouda Buddha
Turkey and Gouda cheese with mango chutney and sun-dried tomatoes on 12-grain bread grilled to perfection. Served with our own gourmet medley chips and grapes.
11.95 $
Nutter's Cuban
Over 1/2 lb of ham, roast pork and Swiss with pickles and mustard served on a 9-inch roll and grilled to perfection with Herr's chips.
12.75 $
Nutter's Clubs
Turkey Club
Turkey, cheese, lettuce, tomato, bacon, and mayo on either white, wheat, rye or a 9" or 12" roll.
13.25 $
Homemade Chicken Salad Club
Homemade chicken salad, bacon, American cheese, lettuce and tomato. Served either on white, wheat, rye, 9" or 12" roll.
13.25 $
Santa Fe Turkey Club
Southwestern style turkey, bacon, American cheese, lettuce, tomato and a homemade pesto spread. Served either on white, wheat, rye, 9" or 12" roll.
13.25 $
Buffalo Chicken Club
Buffalo wing flavored chicken breast, American cheese, wing sauce, lettuce, tomato, bacon and blue cheese. Served either on white, wheat, rye, 9" or 12" roll.
13.25 $
Wraps
Buffalo Chicken Club Wrap
Sliced chicken breast seasoned with Buffalo sauce, shredded cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato and ranch dressing on a sun-dried tomato wrap.
12.25 $
Grilled Chicken and Roasted Pepper Wrap
Grilled chicken breast, smoked provolone, spring mix, roasted peppers and our homemade pesto spread on a tomato wrap.
12.25 $
Bubbas Gourmet Wrap
Over a 1/2 lb. of meats and cheese on this bad boy. Sliced turkey breast, ham, Swiss cheese, bacon, baby spinach, sun-dried tomatoes and our homemade pesto spread wrapped in a black bean tortilla.
12.25 $
Vegan and Vegetarian
Avocado Powerhouse
Our most popular sandwich is made with 1 full avocado, baby spinach, tomato, cucumber, onion, dill and alfalfa sprouts on toasted 12-grain bread. Served with our own gourmet medley chips and grapes.
14.7 $
Organic Mashed Chickpea Salad Sandwich
Our mashed chickpea salad is made fresh daily using organic chickpeas. This sandwich includes 1/2 an avocado and baby spinach on toasted 12-grain bread. Served with gourmet medley chips and grapes.
14.7 $
Avocado Salad
A hearty vegan salad with 1/2 an avocado, alfalfa sprouts, red onion, tomato, cucumber, dill and croutons on a bed of fresh greens with your choice of dressing.
12.75 $
3 Cheese Sandwich or Sub
A mix of provolone, Swiss and American cheeses on a either bread or a sub roll. Sandwiches come with lettuce and tomato. Subs come with lettuce, tomato, sweet and hot peppers, pickles and onions.
11.5 $
Fresh Salads
Chicken Salad
A 6 oz. portion of our homemade chicken salad served on a bed of greens with tomato, onions, cucumber, croutons and onions with your choice of dressing.
12.75 $
Antipasto Salad
A hearty Italian favorite with over 1/2 lb of chopped Italian meats. Genoa salami, capicola ham, and provolone chopped on top of a bed of fresh greens with sweet peppers, onion, tomato and your choice of dressing.
12.75 $
Avocado Salad
A hearty vegan salad with 1/2 an avocado, alfalfa sprouts, onion, tomato, cucumber, dill, and croutons on top of a bed of fresh greens with your choice of dressing.
12.75 $
Tuna Salad
A 6 oz. portion of our homemade all-white albacore tuna salad served on a bed of greens with tomato, onions, cucumber and croutons with your choice of dressing.
12.75 $
Side Salads
1/2 lb. Chickpea Salad
4.25 $
1/2 lb. Macaroni Salad
3.75 $
1/2 lb. Potato Salad
3.75 $
1/2 lb. Coleslaw
3.75 $
Quinoa Tabbouleh Salad
Made fresh daily with cucumbers, tomatoes, fresh parsley, quinoa, red onions, lemons and olive oil.
4.25 $
Kids Menu
Ham Slam
What’s more American than a ham & cheese sandwich? Maybe apple pie? Who knows but our Ham Slam comes on white bread with American cheese and is served with grapes and Goldfish. You can choose between apple juice and fruit punch for a beverage. It also comes with an awesome toy to keep your child content for minutes in the backseat as you return home.
8.49 $
Lil' Meatballer
Two delicious meatballs on a 5 inch roll with provolone cheese added upon request. Our kids meals come with Goldfish, grapes and your choice of apple juice or fruit punch. Your only a kid once so of course we have included a toy!
8.49 $
Nutter Butter
Our own delicious PB& J sandwich served on either white or wheat bread. This meal includes your choice of fruit punch or apple juice. Included with the sandwich are grapes, Goldfish and a fun toy.
8.49 $
Bisque Jr.
An 8oz. serving of our famous crab bisque also includes a toy to boot!
5.49 $
Gift Cards
$20 Gift Card!
Nothing makes your favorite person happier than receiving a Nutter's Gift Card! That's right we said it, nothing.