Caffe Gelato is a great spot for lunch with girlfriends. I've done Mondays with friends and really enjoyed the $6 salads. Of course, after a salad, you don't feel guilty splurging on gelato. Hard to pick a favorite flavor, they are all good! I've also done the $6 paninis on Thursdays with friends. Their lunch specials are a great deal! They validate parking and service has always been friendly and professional! If you're wanting to impress company from out of town, go to Caffe Gelato!
Cindy Zebrook Guerrazzi
+5
The Caffe Gelato wine paring dinner is an experience you have to try! We had a delicious dinner with wine parings and from the beginning to the end of the dinner the wine sommelier picked all of our pairings with perfection.
In addition, the meal itself was delicious and the wine pairings enhanced all the food we were served, so have to say the chef did an excellent job too as we could not have asked for a better dinner! Definitely will do this again with friends—it’s a bargain if you
Caffe Gelato catered a few work events I attended and has never disappointed. I decided to drive out of state to enjoy a special event they had last night. Pappy Van Winkle Bourbon Dinner. OMG ! Am I glad I did. It was 7 delicious courses paired with out of this world bourbon 🥃. The restaurant was totally full for this popular sold out event. However the service was still outstanding. The food was incredible. Nice job Caffe Gelato. We will be back. I highly recommend Caffe Gelato for your catering needs and in restaurant dining.
Place looks very nice inside.. First time here... got the classico pizza from their Woodfield oven.. its great.. good amount of cheese along with nice, soft and crispy crust... fantastic place... they also service cocktails and other beverages along with ice cream..
Cafe Gelato is a phenomenal place to eat. Whether I’m with friends or family, young or old they have something for everyones taste. They have a vast selection of wine for those who would like to just stop by and have a drink or if you’re there for a special occasion. The staff here are amazing and their hard work shows in the efforts that are put in to the wonderful taste of the food as well as the beautiful ambience of the restaurant. And not only is the restaurant wonderful but when they cater events they truly outdo themselves. This is a kind of place where people truly care about the service they provide.
Food was delicious. I had the salmon and it was perfect.
Edit: another great meal. Really love this place. Lots of outdoor seating. I love that you cam reserve online.
My family went to Cafe Gelato for a complementary wedding tasting and could not have been more blown away. The staff were all helpful and Emily was an amazing host. We were provided with samples of so many appetizers, meats, cheeses, entrees, and desserts. Everything was delicious and I found myself liking items I would have never tried otherwise. I couldn't recommend this experience more. Cafe Gelato definitely made us feel special!
We were disappointed at first. Service was less than stellar (wrong food served to one of us and wrong price on the check when we got it). However, the owner of the restaurant came to our table to apologize and explain. The situation was handled extremely well and professionally. Food was excellent. We ordered a pizza and a pasta dish.
We will definitely be back, because of the quality of the food, as well as the kindness of the owner.
Thank you, Ryan German!
Went here when it was graduation night at the local university. Expected it to be busy but not too bad. Was a little disappointed that the menu was cut down with every pasta dish in a cream sauce. Could have been more variety.
Food was excellent but the reason for 4 stars was that one of the wait staff at the end of his shift decided to change out of his shirt in the restaurant next to our table.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Newark
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes