Best Pepperoni Pizza Slice in New York City

9 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Prince Street Pizza
Prince Street Pizza
90/100 (8469 ratings)
Quick Bites
Restaurants
Fast Food
Vegetarian Friendly
Fast food
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Bakery
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Pesto
Pineapple Drink
Veggie Pizza
Soft Drinks
Spicy Pepperoni Pizza
Pepperoni Square
Vodka Fra Diavolo Square Pie Sq
Pasta
Sit down
Fast food
Pizza
Italian
Wheelchair Accessible
Delivery
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Cheap Eats
"Highly rated pizza place in NYC! Can’t go wrong with any of the flavors. I personally like their vodka sauce, but you can’t and don’t want to..."
Edward Halim
"There was a ton of hype surrounding this place as evidenced by the long line when we got there. Gotta say, it lived up to the reputation. It's damn..."
Daniel “TheOldNorthWind” Jones
"Best pizza in NYC I’ve had (so far). That Spicy Spring is something else, man! Grabbed 3 square slices for $20. Really good food they serve at..."
ECA
"Every bit as good as the videos look. There are 2 entrances, one for whole pizzas/pies and delivery drivers to collect and the other for slices. The..."
Alan King
"I’d watched YouTube reviews and TV shows of this place and it was on top of my list of places to eat at in New York. It definitely deserves all the..."
Krishna
"RIGHTEOUS pizza. This must be crafted from a recipe delivered to us by an extraterrestrial, because this pizza is out of this world. Avoid the..."
Ramish Zaidi
"This place is amazing serving up some crazy slices downtown in the city! Prince Street has square slices only, and be warned. There’s always a..."
Ivy colon
"I had very expectations, and I was not disappointed in the slightest. Prince Street is known for one slice: their square pepperoni. There was queue..."
Myriam Ward
"I was recently in NYC and let me tell You this place did not disappoint ! I was transiting through NY and decided to give this place a chance as I..."
parinaz elavia
"I had to check out Prince Street Pizza in New York City, and I can confidently say that it's the best pizza I have ever had in my life. First of..."
Kyle Graves
The Original Little Italy
The Original Little Italy
90/100 (444 ratings)
Restaurants
Fast Food
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
Pizza by the Slice
Manicotti
Firenze Pizza
blt Hero
Mixed Sandwich Tray
Slice Neapolitan
Robusta with Pepperoni Sausage Peppers & Onions
Personal Hawaiian Pizza
Slice of Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Extra Cheese Pizza
Garlic Knots
"I think this is the best plain pizza slice you can buy in mid-town. I have worked in Mid-town for almost 29 years and have not found anything..."
Paul Dolan
Joey S Pepperoni Pizza
90/100 (7 ratings)
Restaurants
Plain Slice of Pizza
Calzone
corona
Caprese Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Spinach Pizza
Fresh Mozzarella Pizza
Fresh Pies
Sicilian Square Pie
Stewart's Soda
Plain Cheese Pizza Pie with Half Topping
Joe's Pizza - Carmine St
Joe's Pizza - Carmine St
89/100 (12372 ratings)
Quick Bites
Fast Food
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Fast food
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Meatball
Peppers
Supreme
Dough
Coca-Cola
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Maple Taffy
Pizza by the Slice
Pizza Cheese
Margherita Pizza
Sicilian Slice
The White Pizza
Plain Cheese Pizza Slice
Slice One Topping
Pepperoni Pizza Pie
That Cheese Slice
3 Fresh Mozzarella and 1 Cheese Slice
New York Style Pizza
Sit down
Fast food
Pizza
Italian
Wheelchair Accessible
Delivery
Takeout
Late Night
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Joe's Pizza is the absolute best pizza in New York City!! I have visited both Carmine Street and the one in the theatre district and the food quality..."
Steph Bissett
"Some of the best slices of Manhattan.Historic and famous for a reason.From the first bite to the crust you will be wanting more.Had a..."
Jimmy Eats Food
"Best pizza we tried in America. So cheap, large and tasty. The reputation is well and truly deserved and worth your time if visiting this beautiful..."
Mattywii
"The pizza here was to die for. I ordered a slice of fresh mozzarella and oh god it was amazing. It was cheesy, but not too overwhelmingly so, and it..."
Danelle Lim Yun
"If you want to eat good pizza in New York, this could be the space. Pizza is always coming out. They have the simplest, the cheese one, one with..."
Joana Coelho Canhoto
"Great old school quintessential NYC slice! Fast and busy, but very good. Your typical, no frills, NYC cheese slice. If you are in the area grab a..."
Hungry87
"Pizza ninja!!A must get when in NYC ... a New York slice of heaven!Known for their pizza with thin base this pizza joint serves..."
Asian Food Ninja
"As a tourist, this is exactly what I was looking for. It was really good pizza overall, but I have to say I liked the dough the most. I got nice and..."
Kevin Cleroux
"Ate at three different pizza places this trip and Joe's totally won the pizza battle for us this time around. It was so good. I do recommend going..."
C.Will
"Definitely one of the most iconic places to eat a pizza in NYC. The place itself is a small restaurant with the concept of "pick up a slice and move..."
João Dimas
"For forty dollars you can eat up to 3 people. This place is characterized by having the best pizza dough in the area. A handmade product, with fresh..."
Emilio Parra
"Best Sicilian I've ever had. Its not my usual go to since Joe's cheese slice is exactly what I usually want, but I decided to try it tonight and I'm..."
Pamela Rubin
"When hippoCHAN was at school, I was browsing YouTube and stumbled upon Buzzfeed’s Worth It Video featuring pizza at three drastically different..."
Curtis G NG
"Right when I entered this place, I was brought to a new world. This place had the heart of a true pizza place. It reminded me of the Ninja Turtles...."
Howard S Wood
"I always make a point to stop at Joe's Pizza. This is THE best pizza spot that I have tried in New York and if you're looking for the classic, world..."
Helen Kirtley
"Busy bustling place with simple and fairly yummy New York pizzas. Would have loved a bit more flavour in the sauces , but certainly not bad pizza...."
Kan Do
"A friend recommended Joe's and we sure were glad we went. There was a small line up when we arrived. Their main pizzas are just cheese, pepperoni and..."
604fOOdie
"I was informed by friends, New Yorkers, and online articles that this place was a must try while I was visiting the city, and I understand why. The..."
AytchEmm
"A few weeks ago I went in New York for the first time. I spent 5 amazing days there and ended up walking 72km around Manhattan, Brooklyn and..."
Jeanne-Marie B
"First time to NYC and several people told me I had to try pizza at Joe's. Ordered a couple of slices and was very happy with it. Crust has a good..."
Guero James
"Great crust, great sauce, and decent enough pepperoni. The prices are low and it is open till early morning.There are high tables to stand..."
Sp354
"This pizza place is amazing. We went simple ordering, a cheese pizza and it was great. I liked how they were fast with service even though they have..."
The Culinary Passage
"Joes Pizza - WOWZA! I could eat this all day every day (to be honest I kinda did at one stage). This small, unpretentious little slice of heaven in..."
McFoodie Jones
"Joe's pizza are greate. Have a lot of types, i eat a simple pizza only for travel money. But i recomendes. Pepperoni are reale amazing. American..."
ANONYMOUS
"If you want the best New York style pizza then Joe's is your place! This place is particularly famous because of all the celebrities that have been..."
Sukhi Singh
"Good pizza in the village. I'm a sucker for pepperoni and enjoyed the slice. Thin slices but lots of flavor so it really hits the spot. Washed it..."
Tkaull
"و ما زالت جوز بيتزا تستهويني و أمرهم كل مره..."
Saudifooodie
"For an old school slice of New York pizza you can't go wrong with Joe's. The regular cheese slice is a simple, no-frills slice with a crust that..."
Hoju_eats
"Tasty pizza slices. Small shop that had many people eating pizza inside and out. We walked past it and thought we would give it ago and tried their..."
Miffy7
"Featured in Grand Theft Auto as well as Spider-Man movie, this is a no frills no fuss NY pizza slice cafe and the pizza is good as people say it..."
Collin Allin
"True to its name...this place serves the best pizza in NYC..Other than some poor service and long queue, this is the best slice u can get for..."
Aatif Mehraj
"Joe's Pizza. My slice of cheese ZA at joes was fulfilling. I bit into it so quickly that I forgot to snap a real pic. The pizza was good but I..."
Felicia Braude
"There’s no denying that Joe’s is a NYC institution.If you want to experience a true (old school style) New York slice, honestly look no..."
IMONGRY
"Delicious!. Absolutely, hands down, delicious!!! The best pizza ever! Just get a cheese slice, find a place to sit or even stand and enjoy the pizza!..."
MooMoo
"Best pizza anywhere... Melt in your..."
Craig Sylvestre
"Man, What a Slice!. After eating my weight in pizza during our 2 week trip to NYC I found Joe's by far delivered the best slice. Yes we visited those..."
Cheezles
"The best? It's a matter of personal taste.. Joe's is a great slice! It it the BEST? Very very tough call in NYC, there are so many great..."
Rich
"Best Slice in the Village. This is a very simple slice, but it is representative of what a NY slice should be. The crust has the perfect texture and..."
JEL
"Best Pizza in the world!. The crust had a light crunch and thin. You could taste all of the ingredients in their..."
Winford
"I don't know, I thought it was just..."
JR C
"Famous or Not, They Conduct Tours of This Place. John's up the street on Bleecker is a funky pizza palor, this place is a tiny hole in the wall dive..."
FredB
"My 2nd real NY slice. On a walking tour stop we had a slice from the very efficient Famous Joe's. You got the feeling you better know what you want...."
Kellyhende
"Famous Joe's Pizza. Well...yeah I like the pizza, a plain slice is what you're looking for here but, and that's a pretty big but, if you..."
Doug
"Best slice in NYC. On a quest for the best NYC slice? A place to take your friends to show them the ulitmate NYC pizza joint. Go to joes..ed of..."
Silkadonis
"The Best. The best pure pizza slice in New York, and maybe the USA. Don't come here if you're looking for one of those multi-tiered..."
Ken Goldstein
"Best pizza in Lower Manhatten - this is where I get my pizza..."
Anthony Diaz
"Best Pizza in..."
Jeremy Vixie
"Don't argue - it's #1. Let's not argue. This is the best slice in NYC. I been going since high school, there is no better. Thin, crunchy,..."
2 Slices
"Good. Very tasty..."
Jjolma
"The best part is when the cheese is still bubbling and it gets all stringy and gooey because it's fresh out of the oven and piping..."
Bella Vivere
"...really look at what people think and expect with the word "pizza", the result is something similar to your basic New York style "Slice" of pizza...."
Kaszeta
"When I have been drinking, I usually get a serious case of the munchies. In most cities, this means either 24hr fast food, a bag of chips, or cooking..."
F O O D O S O P H Y
"So much good can be said about this classic New York pizza shop. Joe's is a spot where your slice (or pie) is exactly as good as the last time, and..."
Chase
"We ate here on our first trip to New York. We were just trying to get out of the rain and thought we would try them out. The pizza was delicious!..."
Kenneth Fox
"I'm not sophisticated enough to explain why it was better than similar pizzas, but it was. It just had the right amount of bite and crispness on the..."
Marc Bascom
"Good New york pizza ! No seating area, only the standing table are available and they have only 2 tables in front of the shop and one counter inside...."
Supakij Khomvilai
"When you think of the quintessential New York slice you think of Joes. The place does not disappoint; with the perfect style of pizza. Crispy with..."
Jeremy Alfano
"We made sure to stop by on our vacation to try Joe's Pizza. It was very busy but the service was quick and we did not have to wait long. The actual..."
Allison Nguyen
"A classic for a reason. Cheese slice may be the best in the city. Hits every time and appreciate the fast service. They mean..."
Sam
"Straight up "New York" style thin crust pie. One of the originals, one of the best. Hole in the wall location, no dining room just a counter to grab..."
Gene
"Over hyped. Good pizza but not worth the long lines that you need to wait through to get a slice. Pepperoni is good, cheese is OK. Staff are very..."
Bhav
"Sometimes you just have to sit down, admire and order another slice. Well, after the Cheese Slice I actually had to try a slice of everything on the..."
Lift_Run_Eat_
"First, they're cash only. In a battle of Joe's vs Bleeker St., Joe's wins in my book. Good ratio of cheese to sauce. Sauce has a strong tomato..."
Quintin Coppola
"Delicious.. Massive… Thin crust … Pizza. You will not regret this. I ordered carry out and ate the whole thing. The cheese is a must...."
Nina Ayers
"The atmosphere at Joe's is casual and friendly. It's a great place to go for a slice with friends or family. The restaurant is located in the heart..."
Junaid Baig Mirza
"5/23 pizza tour 6 of 11- Way better than expected. Just a simple cheese slice but killer. Had great taste, held up, nice crunch and crust. Nothing to..."
g gerl
"Amazing pizza place. The cheese pizza was good but the pepperoni was much better. Very local type feel. The line moves fast and you better know what..."
Mike H
"One of the best slices I have had in a long time. Worth the wait. Cash only, they have drinks as well. Chase ATM down the street. Would highly..."
Patrick McKenna
Upside Pizza
Upside Pizza
88/100 (1142 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Assorted Pies
Vodka Sauce Pizza
Pepperoni Sicilian Pie
Sicilian Pizza Pie
Two Slices and a Coke
Mushroom Pizza Cheese Pizza
Sausage and Pepper
White Pizza Slice with Mushrooms
Falcowitz Slice
Slice of Pizza
Bottom of Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Chicago-Style Pizza
croissant
Margherita Pizza
Pizza carbonara
Pepperoni Slice
Slice Cheese Pizza
Sicilian Pizza Slice
Fast food
Italian
Pizza
Wheelchair Accessible
Accepts Credit Cards
Delivery
Takeout
Lunch
Dinner
Cheap Eats
Rosella's Pizzeria
Rosella's Pizzeria
86/100 (5558 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Chicken Alfredo
Greek salad
Margarite Pizza
Meatball Parmesan Sandwich
Buffalo Chicken Slice
Supposed to Be Meat Lasagna
Chicken Bacon & Ranch Pizza Slice
Spaghetti or Penne with Sausage
Fettuccine with Alfredo Sauce & Chicken
حلويات
Salad
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Extra Cheese
Penne alla Vodka
Garlic Knots
Salad bar
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Reservations
Seating
Delivery
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"I loved this pizza. It was hard not to eat just two slices. Each pepperoni slice was like a small bowl with a small layer of oh so good oil that..."
Donna Fong
"Hands down the best pizza in NYC! Their sauce is out of this world and they are super generous with their ingredients! We had the pepperoni slice and..."
Roberto Morris
"Nice little pizza place. We tried the pizza by the slice and the garlic balls. The pizza was very good and we should have stopped eating there,..."
Fred Holmen
"Truly memorable and delicious pizzas! Their dough is spectacular. The combinations on the pizzas are amazing, with choices like Potato & Caviar,..."
Charlie Harold
"Great lasagna for reasonable price. And good portions. Pizza was ... not great. Don't recommend..."
Chris Gregory
"I know I’m this picture it’s a Sicilian but I also had a regular slice as well and both were super good. Even though it was take and go and/or..."
Nora Symphony
Bravo Pizza
Bravo Pizza
84/100 (822 ratings)
Quick Bites
Fast Food
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Chicken and Bacon Pizza
Chicken Bake
Pizza and Garlic Knots
NY Pizza
Regular Pizza Pie
Pizza Peperoni Salchicha Vegetariana Texana Y Pollo
A Slice of Pizza
Meat Stuffed Pizza Slice
No Alla Vodka
Ham & Pineapple Pizza Slice
Sicilian Cheese Pie
Escalope Milanese and Spaghetti with Tomato
Milanesa
Calzone One Filling
Pepperoni Pizza
Side Salad and a Slice
Bakery
Roll Pizza Pepperoni
BBQ Chicken Pizza
"Great selection of pizza. I had a Peroni beer with my veggie style and it was..."
Randall B. Kam
"Estoy loco de regresar a new york para ir a comer las mejores..."
Reimon Correa
"Best pizza ever!! So many choices.The pepperoni and sausage were out of this..."
Edward Wright
"Was great. Thanks to thanks to the all personal. They have a nice..."
Luis González Jr.
"Best pizza I have had in a while very..."
Tara McDonald
"Love love this pizza, I will gladly pay extra for kosher..."
Diana Sanchez
"Pizzaria otimo paladar :) porto-riquenha !! Ambiente é muito agradável..."
David Lagares
"The pizza is wonderful and the salad was wonderful..."
Dana Allison
"Good value for money. Really good food and friendly..."
Ruan Westermann
"Great..."
Lezio E Rosiane
"Me encanta comer sus pizzas siempre que voy a New York gran sabor y precios espero ir pronto..."
Kevin Roca
Majestic Pizza Corp
Majestic Pizza Corp
79/100 (991 ratings)
Quick Bites
Fast Food
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Garlic bread
cheese pizza
chicken caesar salad
Meat Pizza
Hawaiian Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
BBQ Chicken Pizza Slice
Sausage Pizza by the Slice
Pepperoni Pizza with Pepperoni & Cheese
sushi
Calzone
"This business is truly amazing. We are super grateful for all they have done for my family and I while we were there! We will be long time..."
Iwannabe Yawmommy
"This is a small place but has plenty of character! We got lucky with grabbing a couple of seats! The slices were huge and the pizza was nice! It’s..."
Craig S
"Yum. A slice of cheese pizza with the right amount of sauce to cheese ratio. Crust was perfectly crisp & brown. Staff was friendly &..."
Becky Hapeman
"Pizza, average. If your visiting and want a NY pizza that screams NY I had better luck with Picasso's Pizza the night prior. Visiting from another..."
Jeff Craig
"Very busy pizza small place at lunch hour eventhough it doesn't look like much from the outside. Short waiting time until your pizza is reheated and..."
Jasmine
"Came from Toronto looking for great New York Style pizza and this place hit the spot. Thin, cheesy, and incredibly fresh. Great pizza! Be warned..."
Karishma Desai
"Typical counter serve pizza joint. Limited seating inside. Fair price for a..."
D.J. Escusa
"The best pizza I tried in NY loved..."
geraint pritchard
"The pizza parlor is very small and has casement doors that open up. Despite being very simple, the pizza we had was absolutely amazing. The crust had..."
Ken Wong
"I've been going to Majestic since I was a baby. This place reminds me of my dad and mom's time in New York. The pizza is fantastic but moreso it's a..."
Nigel Sequeira
99 Cent Fresh Pizza
99 Cent Fresh Pizza
79/100 (665 ratings)
Restaurants
Fast food
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Cheese Pizza Slice
Sicilian Pizza
Pepperoni Pie
Italian
Fast food
Pizza
Wheelchair Accessible
Delivery
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats