Best Old Fashioned in New York City

8 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
11th Street Bar
11th Street Bar
91/100 (743 ratings)
Restaurants
Bar
Pub
Bar
Pub
Dinner
Old Fashioned
Ginger Beer
Guinness Stout
Ithaca Flower Power IPA
Made in Oaxaca
Paris Texas
Taytos Irish Crisps
Iced tea
Ham & Swiss Toastie
corona
Warm Pretzel by Sigmunds
Bar
Pub
Seating
Dinner
Cheap Eats
Bar Moga
Bar Moga
90/100 (767 ratings)
Restaurants
Bar
Pub
Bar
Pub
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
Uni Toast
The Moga
Cafe Printemps
Kogashi Duck Roast
Wagyu Toast
Seasonal Fish Tataki
Dewazakura Ginjo
Old Fashioned
Whiskey Sour
Strawberry Shortcake
Wagyu Katsu Sando
Black Manhattan
Beef Tongue Curry
Omu Rice
Pisco Sour
Kani Cream Croquette
Duck breast
Curry Doria
Pub
Bar
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
"Great decor, menu, and fancy cocktails. Above all courteous and friendly staff, especially Stefanie! Bartenders are knowledgeable to serve you high..."
Kedar K. Vengurlekar
Bar Pleiades
Bar Pleiades
88/100 (303 ratings)
Restaurants
Dinner
Lunch
Foie Gras Torchon
Fernet with Coke
Seafood
Slider
Martini
Pistachio
Old Fashioned
Ile Flottante
Employees Only
Employees Only
87/100 (6480 ratings)
Restaurants
International
Bar
American
American
International
Bar
Dinner
Late Night
Drinks
Cheesecake
Oysters on the Half Shell with Mignonette & EO Bloody Mary Mix
Bacon Wrapped Lamb Chops with Salsa Verde
Lamb chops
Besod
Bass
Seared Rib-Eye with Horseradish Potato Gratin
Cheesecakes
Hand-Cut Steak Tartar with Crostini & Mixed Greens Salad
Steak Tartare
Wine Mineral Water Marrow Pastries
Lamb
Orecchiette
Burrata
Mojito
Spirits
Cheesecake
Old Fashioned
Pasta
Roasted Chicken Breast
Manhattan Cocktail
Whiskey Sour
Billionaire Cocktail
Vesper
Salad
Bone Marrow Poppers with Pastry Shell & Bordelaise
Cheese Plate
Oyster
Fraise Sauvage
Sit down
American
International
Bar
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Reservations
Seating
Late Night
Drinks
Dinner
Mid-range
"One of the world top bar (rank 49 - 2023), we make a reservation though Resy for dinner. The dishes size is large for 2 girls, we had 4 drinks and 1..."
Erin Hwang
"Speakeasy vibes and atmosphere. The food was delicious. The drinks were topnotch. Our new waitress did great. Tarot reading was intense. The 1..."
KILO GULF
"This place was terrific. Great cocktails, awesome staff and classic atmosphere. Reece at the front door was a true gentleman and welcoming. My..."
Paul Vetrano
"Very enjoyable cocktail and dining experience. 4 stars only because it is rated in the top 100 bars in the world so I had high expectations. I..."
Benswing Rich (EV Road Tripper)
"This bar is absolutely stunning! Love the atmosphere, the service, the design of the place omg… and the cocktails are unbelievable! High quality,..."
Marta Galmozzi
"🎊 We were a party of two and got there around 7 PM on a Thursday. It was PACKED! We were lucky enough to get two seats crammed to the right of the..."
Samelia J
"Fantastic spot with great cocktails and amazing service! The cocktails were delicious - we got the espresso martini, the ginger smash, the Mata Hari,..."
Rahul Manju Goyal
"Surprisingly good bar food! On the heavier side but still yummy. Drinks were really good too! The last leaf is a must..."
Jade Li
"Drinks were great 10/10, food was decent 7/10. Apps: beet salad, bone marrow poppers, gnocchi Mains: pork chop, cavatelli, risotto I would go for..."
Angela N
"Overall a great hangout spot! Got there at like 6:15 and it was nice and jazzy, but by 7, it was standing room only. The bartenderes are absolutely..."
Cassandra Hong
Lillie's Victorian Establishment
Lillie's Victorian Establishment
84/100 (6643 ratings)
Restaurants
Bar
Bar
Pub
Vegetarian Friendly
Gastropub
Gastropub
American
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Brunch
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Double Ginger Moscow Mule
Nachos
Chicken Sandwich and Burger Lunch Special
Eggs Benedict
Pub Nachos V
Pretzel
Toasts
Fish & chips
Salad
BLT
Manhattan
Calamari
Fish
Pork
Truffle Fries
Mussels
Charcuterie
Old Fashioned
Tuna
High Tea
Chicken Pot Pie
Calamares
Chocolate cake
Espresso Martini
Salmon
Afternoon tea
Chicken and Waffle
Sandwiches
Mimosa
Fish and Chips
Burger
Beef burger
Sandwiches
Fish & Chips
Hamburgers
Eggs Benedict with salmon
Blistered Shishito Peppers
Vanilla Bourbon French Toast
Sit down
American
Pub
Gastropub
Bar
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Television
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Live Music
Reservations
Accepts Discover
Lunch
Late Night
Drinks
Brunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"A great establishment for food and drinks. Vast range of craft beer, lagers, cocktails and spirits. Extensive and super food. Hard working and..."
Kanika
"Really great interior. Very high ceilings, ornaments, paintings. Really long bar, with hundreds of bottles of spirits. The food is okay. Definitely..."
Can
"Great place for a quick drink or to meet up with a friend, great..."
KKing
"It is a great place but falls short with the promotional beer glasses,shakers and etc....sports network playing on a flat screen kind of takes away..."
Aaron FooDNY
"This is a great place. Sheer laziness tempted me to copy and paste my review for the Union Square location here; great restraint has been exercised...."
Rich
"Newly opened and living up to the reputation it has gained on 17th street... The food was delicious, I had the chicken pot pie, and the interior is..."
James Talvy
"We stopped in for brunch before seeing a show. We absolutely loved the holiday decor and the food! The service was just okay, it took a long time to..."
Ariel Bonk
"Super cute decorations. The cocktails were cute/pretty/fancy but I wouldn't say my drink was particularly good. That said, I really loved the decor..."
Kristen Ryan
"This place is definitely one of the most Instagrammable places we've been to so far. We went around Halloween, and the decoration was awesome. Very..."
Denisse Zarelly Cuba Tello
"Wow! This restaurant is so impressive. The decorations are stunning and so festive (we were there during Christmastime). Every staff member we..."
Karen Kappert
"This is was our first time visiting Lillie’s and we were pleasantly surprised to get in due to the holiday popularity. We were in love with all the..."
Stephanie Henriquez
"We came for Brunch on Christmas Eve and had a great time. We were worried because we were out with our 18 month old but all was well. The music..."
Christina Ferdinand
"We found Lillie's by accident and was pleasantly surprised. As we walked through the door, we were taken back in time to when beauty and wonder from..."
YVETTE NEFSKY
"We've been to this location a couple of times, and the food is excellent. The atmosphere is always festive, and the Halloween theme was..."
Angie R
"The decorations and service were excellent! The food was good for a bar, but so-so for a restaurant. Overall, 5, maybe a ~4ish on the food. Great..."
Yury T
"If you are looking for a different place with a unique atmosphere, this is where to go! Great music and cocktails but the best part is the..."
Elisa Basile
"Had a couple of drinks each here. The bartenders were really friendly and quick to make everything. The decor was so cool too! Fun to see Halloween..."
Kyle Rapps
"I give 4 starts and it’s purely for the decorations. We didn’t have the reservation so we have been told to sit at the bar. Little they forgot to..."
Anastasia Karpovets
"I visited this bar last night in Manhattan to catchup over a drink with my buddy. Overall very nice place, good atmosphere and a very nice bar. We..."
Joseph Moussop
"We came here for Lunch time , this place closed to Time Square (I heart ❤️in NYC) and beautiful..walked to inside that's decorated an amazing,..."
Piyanan Oransidhipong
"OMG. The perfect dating spot. I had a blast at Lillie’s Victorian Establishment, what a place! Great food. Incredible vibes, the whole place was..."
Ted Weitz
"Awesome place! The atmosphere is second-to-none and the drinks are incredible! The food was also delicious! I would love to come for their tea time!..."
Brittany Dorner
"It’s a nice restaurant but could be better. The food it’s okay but I expected for much better plates. The service was good except for the host..."
Jorge Correa
The Immigrant
The Immigrant
83/100 (1155 ratings)
Restaurants
Wine Bar
Wine Bar
Dinner
Old Fashioned
Pinot Noir
Greek Olives
Fancy Papers IPA
Spirits Line Up
Beer
baklava
Red wine
Wine Bar
Seating
Dinner
"The Immigrant also has a small plates menu to snack on while imbibing. Most of its food is Mediterranean-derived. Bro ordered a plate of..."
EateryROW
Harry's
Harry's
81/100 (6160 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Steakhouse
American
American
Gluten Free Options
Steakhouse
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Brunch
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Juice & Smoothies
French Onion Soup
Beef
Steak Sandwich
Steak Sandwich
BLT
Squid Ink Pasta
Lobster
Ice Cream
Porterhouse for Two
Hanger steak
Harry's Beef Wellington
Crème Brulée
Fish
Cajun Rib Eye
Hand-Cut Steak Tartare
Salad
Cocktails
caesar salad
Diver Sea Scallops Lemon-Caper Sauce
Oyster
Juice & Smoothies
Butter
Tuna
Steak salad
Salmon
Manhattan
Hash browns
Old Fashioned
Lobster Bisque
Sandwiches
Filet Mignon
Steak & Eggs
Burger
Polenta
Creamed Spinach
Toasts
Onion Soup Au Gratin
Seafood Tower
Shrimp
Sit down
American
Steakhouse
Free Wifi
Private Dining
Seating
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Gift Cards Available
Reservations
Full Bar
Late Night
Dinner
Drinks
Lunch
Brunch
Fine Dining
"Classic steakhouse with other options. They have some classic dry age grilled steaks but they do offer other things. I've had a few things here and..."
Victor Lao
"Very convenient location if downtown and nice clubby feel inside. Good for both business & non-business lunch or dinner. Overall service was..."
Lou
"More a 4.5 than a 4. Had a group of 20. Was able to taste the Wellington, Filet Mignon, and Rib Eye. Filet was best of the 3. Sides I was able to..."
Nick Carbonara
"Sunday brunch comes with unlimited sparkling (90 mins limit) with any purchase of entrees. The portions are large and generally the entrees were all..."
Susie Su
"Just a super awesome weekend brunch option. Yes, the dishes might be slightly on the pricier side and maybe they could be a tad larger but against..."
ReedH
"Harry's is an iconic, long-time steakhouse in Lower Manhattan's Financial District (FiDi) that's as classy as the food and service is excellent. If..."
Jeffrey “Captain Z” Zampitella
"Happy I found this spot. Walk down the steps into the door and the place is very cozy. The service was great. We were seated in this cute private..."
Isis Chestnut
"Just what you would expect for a steakhouse in the Financial District. Very nice inside although when we visited, it was a lot of groups of business..."
staci manning
"Been to Harry's many times over the years, but after having dinner a few weeks back, I am compelled to provide a 5 star rating for this..."
Larry K
"Yes, love the atmosphere here. The drinks and food are spot on. This is the place to hang out if you’re in the financial district and visiting the..."
Bosslady Ivy
"The best steakhouse burger I’ve had so far. Pricey but worth it for once a year. Top quality ingredients that blends in together perfectly. The..."
Eric Rivera
"Beautiful atmosphere! It is a loud place, but personally it didn't bother us. For pop they have Coke products. They give you a glass of ice and a..."
Jennifer Winthurst
"I’m a Harry’s regular and it never disappoints. Usually go for the lobster cocktail but they didn’t have it this time. Lobster bisque is so..."
Jeff Wan
"Food was awesome! Excellent service. Thank you guys at Harry’s..."
Jordan
"First off, the food is seriously good. It’s expensive, but everything was worth it. I especially enjoyed the swordfish steak. Secondly, the staff..."
Emily Jo
"Came for a brunch with a group of friends. We had a great time. Food was excellent, service was awesome (shout out Arlene!) and we loved our table...."
Amber DAngelo
North Fork Restaurant
North Fork Restaurant
79/100 (609 ratings)
Restaurants
Bar
Pub
Wine Bar
American
Dinner
Late Night
Brunch
Drinks
Bottomless brunch
Espresso Martini
Branzino
Cheese and Meat Plate
Waffle
Chicken and Waffles
East Coast Oysters
North Fork Burger
Wild Boar Bolognese Pasta
Hudson Valley Maple Braised Rabbit
Braised Goat Neck
Murray's Cheese and Meat Plate
Shaved Veggie Salad
Pesto Spinach Fettuccini Vegetarian
Cocktails
Burrata with Cantaloupe
Margarita
Mimosa
Juice
Old Fashioned
Bar
Pub
Wine Bar
American
Free off-street parking
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Digital Payments
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
BYOB
Non-smoking restaurants
Delivery
Reservations
Outdoor Seating
Accepts Discover
Takeout
Seating
Accepts Mastercard
Table Service
Accepts Visa
Wheelchair Accessible
Private Dining
Accepts American Express
Serves Alcohol
Street Parking
Wine and Beer
Drinks
Brunch
Dinner
Late Night
Mid-range