Best whoopie pie in New York City

There is only one restaurant
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Melt Bakery
Melt Bakery
88/100 (440 ratings)
Dessert
Bakeries
American
American
Lunch
Ice Cream Sandwich
Sandwiches
Taiyaki
Peanut Butter Cookies
Ice Cream
76'Er
Muffin
whoopie pie
Sit down
American
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Reservations
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Mint ice cream tastes homemade - not too sweet. Chocolate chip cookie is delicious and warm. Service was friendly. We will be..."
Roberta Piket
"All I can say is yuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuum! We had the red velvet today at The High Line and it was amazing :) My husband is actually on the website now..."
Tracie Smith
"I Had the cinnamax he had the classic... Both were..."
Trena Hill
"This company rocks!!! I'm from out of town, Waaaay out of town, and just curiously emailed them about ordering cookies and the whatnots and was able..."
Ellen McCraw
"Great Place for summer sweet treats. The most amazing Ice Cream..."
Kyma TheDiva
"You'd be a FOOL not to fall in love with melt..."
Vicky Modica
"All I can say is..."
Heather Ziehl-Fitch
"Fantastic ice cream sandwiches that couple unique..."
Lesley Sigall
"Great service and interesting choice of ice-cream sandwiches at $5 each. Their Mocha flavoured ice-cream sandwich was amazing, however the Cinnamax..."
Irena Savchenko
"Stopped by for a snack, on a beautiful 90 degree day. All of our ice cream sandwiches were delicious — the cookies were soft and the ice cream was..."
Melissa O'Connor
"The ice cream sandwiches are delicious. Well made, substantial for the price - overall worth the..."
John Angarano
"They make ice cream sandwiches! They are about 8 different options, each with a different type of cookie and ice cream flavor. You can't mix and..."
Jon71992
"Their presence in Hester Street Fair last year brought many of fans, and their ice cream sandwiches did not disappoint at all. PHENOMENAL sandwiches..."
Aristotle
"Creative and delicious ice cream sandwiches! I tried the variation with snicker doodle and cinnamon ice cream--it tasted like Cinnamon Toast Crunch..."
Rob Yu
"Been to several of their carts in the city. Wonderful full of flavor and the cookies are crisp and match well with the flavors of ice cream. Not sure..."
Kevin Chan