Review Elmo - New York City

Albert Husmillo

Excellent dining experience! First of all the restaurant is really nice and decked with beautiful Christmas decorations. Feels very festive. The food and cocktails were amazing. Get their frozen Margaritas! Probably one of the best I’ve had in the city. The Tuna tartare with Avocado and Wonton chips were really good and perfect fpr sharing. A great starter. We had the steak frites which was cooked to perfection comes with truffle fries, creamed spinach and au poivre sauce. It doesn’t get any better than that! It was absolutely satisfying. And we had to get the apple crisp for dessert which was the perfect way to end a wonderful meal. Definitely the perfect spot for that holiday vibe. Service was nice and topnotch! Definitely coming back. Highly recommend!

Carlos Garcia

I just want to say that this restaurant is very good. It’s very nice, romantic and perfect for everybody and gay couples. We ate the meatloaf and the steak frites. It was delicious. The meatloaf comes with match potatoes that was excellent. The atmosphere is very nice and the service was good as well. I totally recommend this restaurant.

Marc Davis

We had a great time here eating dinner with our family while in New York. Everything was so delicious! My seven year old decided that he loves calamari now. It was exceptionally crispy and tasty. We had several dishes and we all enjoyed them. The cocktails were also great. They even made cotton candy for my son's dessert! I would definitely recommend this restaurant for an awesome dining experience in a great atmosphere with exceptional service.

TheRJWilliams

This place had Really nice ambiance and artwork and Plenty of lighting. The drinks we tried were the Chocolate martini and Malibu bay breeze double. They were both strong. We’ll worth the money. Calamari was crispy and delicious. Spinach and artichoke dip with fresh pica Little light on spinach. But very cheesy. Both food entree items came hot and fresh. Chicken fried chicken with mash and green beans. The chicken was crispy and juicy. Chicken was butterflied, Mash was tasty, Gravy delicious and had a Nice peppery taste. Steak frites medium, spinach with garlic and fries. Tender and juicy, highlight of the night for me!

Susan Brownlee

Very loud place. Food was pretty good. I had the sole and it was tasty. It was crowded so it took a bit to order. It is a Friday night so we didn't mind.

Joanne Robelen

Had the pleasure of being waited on by TJ - both personable and attentive. I was trying to decide between two items. Ended up choosing the Meatloaf, primarily based on TJ's recommendation. The Meatloaf was beef & cooked!! I was eyeing the lemon meringue, but I was too full to even finish the main course! Reasonably priced meal. I was seated immediately. I felt the wait time for service/meal was well within standard time frame.

Kevin Hessam

Great place to eat at. The salmon was pretty good The guacamole is very excellent, as well as the tuna tartar, Didn't like the fact that the appetizer and entree came in 2 minutes separated from each other. Let me explain, the table wasn't ready to accommodate the entrees, nor where the plates from the appetizer remover before we could receive our entrees. Also, our server made us pay half way through our entrees, totally fine however all these things add on and separates a 4/5 from a 5/5. Take all in consideration. Other than this, food is great!

Alexa D'Ambra

We really enjoyed our dinner here. We all ended up getting salads/grain bowls and they were delicious and huge. Highly recommend getting a side of fries; they're perfectly cooked and seasoned. I was a bit disappointed in the blue cheese stuffed olive martini but everyone else was happy with their drinks. We went on a Tuesday, and it was not crazy busy but plenty of tables were filled. Service was great. Their bathroom signage is... dated, using pink for women and blue for men 🙄. Ambiance is nothing special but the art is very interesting and unique! I'd go again! FYI the facade doesn't say Elmo anywhere just a but sign that says RESTAURANT

Angel Addams

The food was absolutely delicious and well presented on the plates. Cocktails, outstanding. Staff are incredibly friendly and attentive, accommodating, and fun! Topical NY prices but well worth it. Plenty of space, so you don't feel like everyone is on top of you. Can't wait to revisit 🫶🏼!

Nora Parashkev

One of the best restaurants I have been!! Great service great cocktails great atmosphere! Tuna tartar great Spice Margaritas too Delicious Chicken and all the salads. Definitely worthy!!’