Our signature pie is made with fresh granny smith apples and has a brown sugar, cinnamon and walnut streusel topping. Five inch pie: serves1-2, Ten inch pie: Serves 8-10
9.95 $
Mississippi Mud Pie
Our triple chocolate treat featured on the food network.
9.95 $
Southern Pecan Pie
Rich and tender pastry complements our traditional filling.
9.95 $
Florida Key Lime Pie
Smooth and piquant filling with a graham cracker crust.
9.95 $
Old-Fashioned Apple Pie
Traditionally spiced golden delicious apples in a domed crust.
9.95 $
Little Pie Sampler
Choose four of our five inch pies or opt for our best sellers in our Little Pie Sampler.
(Standard sampler includes: Sour Cream Apple Walnut, Old Fashioned Apple, Florida Key Lime, Mississippi Mud)
38 $
Chicken Pot Pie 5"
Tender white chicken, fresh cream, peas, carrots and onions. 5 inch: Serves 1-2
9.95 $
Three Berry Pie
Fresh strawberries, blueberries and raspberries.
9.95 $
Red Velvet Cake
A mild chocolate cake with a little buttermilk and cream cheese icing. Large Cake: Serves 12
45 $
Old-Fashioned Chocolate Cake
Belgian chocolate and dutch cocoa in our family recipe! Large cake: serves 12
45 $
Fresh Pies
Sour Cream Apple Walnut Pie
Our signature pie is made with fresh granny smith apples and has a brown sugar, cinnamon and walnut streusel topping. Five inch pie: serves1-2, Ten inch pie: Serves 8-10
9.95 $
Three Berry Pie
Fresh strawberries, blueberries and raspberries.
9.95 $
Mississippi Mud Pie
Our triple chocolate treat featured on the food network.
9.95 $
Old-Fashioned Apple Pie
Traditionally spiced golden delicious apples in a domed crust.
9.95 $
Florida Key Lime Pie
Smooth and piquant filling with a graham cracker crust.
9.95 $
Southern Pecan Pie
Rich and tender pastry complements our traditional filling.
9.95 $
Sugarless Apple Pie
No artificial sweeteners golden delicious apples are all we need to sweeten this American classic.
9.95 $
Chicken Pot Pie 5"
Tender white chicken, fresh cream, peas, carrots and onions. 5 inch: Serves 1-2
9.95 $
Little Pie Sampler
Choose four of our five inch pies or opt for our best sellers in our Little Pie Sampler.
(Standard sampler includes: Sour Cream Apple Walnut, Old Fashioned Apple, Florida Key Lime, Mississippi Mud)
38 $
Montmorency Cherry Pie
We cannot tell a lie—while good old George had his cherry tree, we at Little Pie Company have our cherry pie and to tell the truth, we simply love it! And now, as our featured pie of the month, we are offering 1 day delivery for cherry pies across the nation for the first time ever! Topped with a lightly browned crinkle crust and the perfect amount of sugary crystals, plump, fresh cherries leap out of their time-honored bowl and proclaim quite honestly, “Life is like a forkful of cherries!”
9.95 $
Sweet Potato Pie
A Traditional Southern Classic made from scratch. We start with fresh Kentucky Sweet Potatoes, and then we select a special blend of imported spices to create this delicious and creamy dessert. A perfect autumn treat.
9.95 $
Homemade Cakes
Applesauce Carrot Cake
Light yet superbly rich and moist. Large Cake: serves 12
45 $
Old-Fashioned Chocolate Cake
Belgian chocolate and dutch cocoa in our family recipe! Large cake: serves 12
45 $
Red Velvet Cake
A mild chocolate cake with a little buttermilk and cream cheese icing. Large Cake: Serves 12
45 $
Large Creamy New York Cheese Cake
Our famous New York Cheesecake sends the senses reeling with a creamy yet slightly dense combination of fresh cream cheese, pure vanilla, and all-natural ingredients that rest in a golden graham cracker crust. Serve with fresh fruit or fruit glaze to complement the rich flavors.