Highly rated pizza place in NYC! Can’t go wrong with any of the flavors. I personally like their vodka sauce, but you can’t and don’t want to miss their square pepperoni. It’s crunchy, fresh, and meaty - all combined to have an atomic explosion in your mouth. This pizza isn’t like any other pizza you have had before, it’s a bit thick but not too overwhelming and challenging to bite into. The bread is just magical and all the topping is just the cherry on top!
Daniel “TheOldNorthWind” Jones
+5
There was a ton of hype surrounding this place as evidenced by the long line when we got there. Gotta say, it lived up to the reputation. It's damn good pizza. Fluffy throughout but crispy on the edges due to their square slice. We got the spicy pepperoni and the four cheese and were very happy. Only thing we wish we had done was gone for some parm or salt to send it over the top, but I'll happily be back here again.
Best pizza in NYC I’ve had (so far).
That Spicy Spring is something else, man! Grabbed 3 square slices for $20. Really good food they serve at this joint.
Generous serving of pepperoni and that spice just kicks in right from the first bite.
Definitely coming back to get some more Prince St. Pizza when I’m back in the city.
Every bit as good as the videos look. There are 2 entrances, one for whole pizzas/pies and delivery drivers to collect and the other for slices.
The queue when we visited was for slices. We got 2 pepperoni slices and enjoyed them standing outside. The queue moves quite quickly and the staff are efficient with little pleasantries.
There was a spicy vodka pizza, which nearly got a look in but not this visit.... 🍕
I’d watched YouTube reviews and TV shows of this place and it was on top of my list of places to eat at in New York. It definitely deserves all the hype it gets!
I could’ve kept on eating their Spicy Pepperoni and Spicy Vodka slices and had to really stop myself. The meat lover’s pizza was a great pick too.
A MUST VISIT!
RIGHTEOUS pizza. This must be crafted from a recipe delivered to us by an extraterrestrial, because this pizza is out of this world.
Avoid the Sicilian style rectangular cuts - those are nothing compared to the NY style.
Service could be improved, because I got a cold slice when I clearly asked for the opposite. But damn, the one hot slice I did get overrides anything negative - including the person rummaging through the trash right outside.
This place is amazing serving up some crazy slices downtown in the city! Prince Street has square slices only, and be warned. There’s always a line out the door, no matter what time of day that you go!
I personally like the vodka, the pepperoni, and this one featured here which had both
I had very expectations, and I was not disappointed in the slightest.
Prince Street is known for one slice: their square pepperoni. There was queue at the entrance, but within 20 minutes, my hot slice was ready.
This slice is just delicious. Crispy at the bottom, and the stars of the show are the thick slices of pepperonis: crispy towards the edges, chewy on the inside, with small pools on oil in the middle. The tomato sauce isn’t too sweet and works great with the pepperoni.
Worth the queue and worth the hype:
definitely one of the best slices in the city.
I was recently in NYC and let me tell
You this place did not disappoint !
I was transiting through NY and decided to give this place a chance as I kept seeing it all over my Social media feed and wanted to see what all this hype was about.
I’m usually not a fan of thick crust pizza but I was absolutely mind blown ! I had the naughty slice. The base a vodka sauce with pepperoni and a drizzle of honey and let me tell the explosion of flavours was immaculate !
I was so addicted to it that on my way back to Toronto i went there at 2:30 am to grab a slice!
When I went there for the first time Each slice is about $7 but I got there at 2:30 am the second time they charged only $5 cuz I guess they were closing in 30 min!
I’m so happy they decided to open one in Toronto !
Ps: the cashier was a bit rude when I when there at around 2:30 am but over all the staff was really nice when I had gone during the day
I had to check out Prince Street Pizza in New York City, and I can confidently say that it's the best pizza I have ever had in my life.
First of all, the ambiance is classic New York pizzeria.
The crust was the perfect combination of crispy and chewy, and the nice charred flavor that only a true brick oven can achieve. The tomato sauce was rich and tangy, and the cheese was perfectly melted and gooey. But what sets Prince Street Pizza apart is their pepperoni - it's spicy, crispy, and absolutely addictive. Each bite was a burst of flavor that left me craving more.
Whether you're a local New Yorker or just visiting the city, you owe it to yourself to try Prince Street Pizza. It's a pizza experience like no other, and I can't recommend it highly enough. This place has set the bar incredibly high for any future pizza I may have.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes