Sluurpy
Reset

There are 13 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in New Windsor

There are 13 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Uncle Matty's Eatery
93/100 (634 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Fusion
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Greek
Fusion
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Paninis
Sandwiches
Burger
Shrimp
Salad
Crab
Sit down
Fusion
American
Takeout
Television
Accepts Mastercard
Reservations
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Seating
Accepts Discover
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Gift Cards Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"YES! Chicken Wings are really juicy inside but crispy outside. I eat a lot of wings and these were tremendous. Cold Cut on point with generous cold..."
Andrew Taylor
"Great food and quaint space. I ate in the patio. Kinda small and intimate but felt right for the small town. Well kept establishment. I got a turkey..."
Rob Phelps
"Uncle Matty's never disappoints! I moved to Montana years ago and whenever I get back to Carroll County to visit Uncle Matty's is one of my go to..."
Donald Roe
"Stopped by for lunch after trying unsuccessfully to get a look inside IAG nearby. Ordered the Tuna steak with Chips and a Woodstove Imperial Stout...."
SEAN HAHN
"A very pleasing find in New Windsor - we drive out into the scenic countryside just to enjoy lunch at this homey family-friendly restaurant (they do..."
ytcarol
"Love this little place. Staff is great and its always nice seeing familiar faces..."
paula heffner
"Food is always high quality and consistently great. Beer selection is phenomenal as was the very knowledgeable ..."
Matt Watkins
"Great food, very friendly..."
H Mayle
Cafe Richiesto And Pizzeria
92/100 (283 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
American
Cafe
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Lunch
Brunch
Breakfast
Café
Italian
Café
American
Pizza
Takeout
Television
Accepts Mastercard
Seating
Accepts Visa
Table Service
Accepts American Express
Wheelchair Accessible
Accepts Discover
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Highchairs Available
Digital Payments
Accepts Credit Cards
Delivery
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Pizza is one of the best up here. Closest to the city. Heros are great and we enjoyed the wings as..."
Traci Laffin
"Liked the food. No too expensive. Staff were good and helpful. No liquor are available. Only root..."
Simranjit Singh
"Excellent service and friendly staff. Lots of choices of food to choose from ! Highly..."
Jorge D Agueda
"Great place. Great service. Good..."
Jacqueline Burton
"Service was fast and friendly! Food was good I’m not a fan of eggs from a carton but it hit the spot. Banana pancakes were very..."
M-P Amendolare
"This restaurant is the one I like best. I visit plenty of restaurants but here I constantly return again and again. The stuff is very cordial and..."
Manuel Martinez
"Cafe Richiesto, Italian name, but the espresso (caffe) no so good! All the rest,..."
Gentian Breshanaj
Mr Cannoli
90/100 (129 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Italian
"One of the best cameli's I've ever had. Very friendly great place. Only the best of the best go into his ingredients. Want the real tree try the wine..."
Eric Birdsalel
"If I could give more then 5 stars I would ! The cannolis are amazing !!! And the pina colada sorbet with Bacardi was even more amazing !! I will..."
Kori Conklin-Schaefer
"Talk about FRESH!! Every CANNOLI is filled when you order. Biting into the crispy shell filled with the smooth delicious cannoli cream will excite..."
Atlas Moscato
"Mr. Cannoli is amazing. If you are a cannoli lover, you will be brought to the next level. If you aren't a fan of cannoli's (is that even possible?)..."
Colin Schmitt
"Soft serve is quite good (not the best I've ever had, but better than most), but the Italian ice is TO DIE FOR. We got the "tropical" ice boat, which..."
Sarah Wassberg Johnson
"Excellent cannoli! The raspberry Bordeaux sorbet is beyond heavenly! The blood orange prosecco was amazing! Lemon ice, yummy! Very unique..."
Janice Jacobina
"Picked up the frozen cannoli cream in ShopRite. OMG!!! This is amazing and so easy when bought with the shells. What a great party dessert. We..."
Joe Dropkin
"It's a great place for friends and family. Everyone that works there are helpful and nice! I've tried just about everything with my friends and..."
Amanda McKnight
"Absolutely the best! So many delicious options to choose no matter what mood you're in you'll be satisfied when you stop..."
Brianna Ashley Buring
"Excellent ice creams, Italian ices, sundaes, Malteds and Milk Shakes, banana Splits, Cannoli's are all so yummy delicious. Everyone must get down to..."
Dennis Chiamulera
"Awesome place!! And our friends own it!! So happy I got to see you guys!! Best ice cream ever!!! :) love you guys and so happy for you!!..."
Trish Acer
"I had the Cannoli sundae. It was absolutely delicious . I think this should be on everyone's list to try. Can't wait to come back..."
Robert Hufcut
"Met the owner of Nr. Cannoli tonight at the Cornwall music night. I tried the blackberry ice. It was absolutely wonderful !!! My friend and I ate..."
Joanne Cooper
"Delicious Ice cream flavors and sundaes. And don't forget to get a cannoli!!! The Best in town and..."
Ken Chiamulera
"I just went for the first time. I tried the coconut ice and I usually hate anything with coconut pieces because the texture is terrible to me, but..."
Ciara Yvonne
"The ices are made with real fruit pieces, and are always delicious. Excellent portions and prices. My family always loves coming to Mr...."
Frank F. Smith
"best Italian ices my son loves it..."
Kara Smith
"Local family owned ice cream spot. Homemade ice cream, great assortment of flavors and toppings. Wheelchair accessible. Reasonably..."
Paul Samuelson
"Great icees, homemade, no high fructose corn syrup. Friendly people. Good portions. Definitely worth..."
Anthony Savarese
Pizza Mia
88/100 (598 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Pizza
Italian
Reservations
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Great pizza joint here. Amazing began options. Regular pizza and Italian food too. Friendly staff. I always want to eat the whole..."
William Gimeranez
"Great place for Vegan and Regular pizza and Italian food. Amazing friendly..."
William Gimeranez
"It was great to come back home to a place that made vegan pizza. But that's not all, garlic knots, and sandwiches too. I recommend the cheese..."
Kurt Robinson
"Delicious pizza! Crust is very unique loove it not 5 stars because could use some interior..."
R Garza
"Pizza Mia is the best choice for pizza in the New Windsor and Newburgh area. Their ingredients are always fresh, and they specialize in over 100..."
Stanley Zgrodek
"Love this place! The staff is always great and the service is quick. The pizzas excellent, I come here fairly regularly for a couple slices since..."
Bryan Takeuchi
"This Pizza was like nothing I’ve ever had before. The sauce was AMAZING! I just wish this place was closer to me! The owner is also very..."
Justin Combs
Pizza Heaven
87/100 (439 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Accepts Credit Cards
Delivery
Takeout
Television
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Accepts Discover
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"A superfluous review. If you live near Pizza Heaven, you probably eat there already. And if you don't, you probably don't know where New Windsor is...."
Paul Ackman
"Their giant slice is the best Brooklyn style slice in the area. Nice thin crust with a slight crisp to it. Sauce is awesome - not too acid. Just..."
Kevin C.
"WOW !!! The slices of pizza here are massive!! It really is PIZZA HEAVEN. They are more then double of what a normal slice usually is. My nephew and..."
Rachel Milito your Realtor
"My family has finally found our Pizza 🍕 place! After a year of trying different pizza joints around New Windsor and Newburgh. We LOVE Pizza..."
Heather Gleason
Mama Theresa's Pizza Restaurant
86/100 (459 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Sandwiches
Salad
Italian
Pizza
Takeout
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"I usually order and pick up from Mama Theresa's. The food is always ready on time, hot and delicious! Also, Mama Theresa's are friendly and..."
Geovanna Towers
"Service was great, ordered three slices and the waitress brought us out free garlic knots. Pizza was pretty good as..."
School of love
"Best pizza and meals and salads and dressing. Just like having Mama make your meal. Authentic NYC style pizza hard to Come by in Orange..."
Maylegn Holguinua
"3) UPDATE.....Was contacted by owner very pleasant and concerned...offered us another pie when in the area. Would now consider moving to a 3 of..."
Jennifer M
"Best pizzeria/restaurant in Orange County using the best ingredients! My..."
Mitchell Glick
"Service was great and the food was..."
Tom Lewicki
Ivanas Cucina
85/100 (139 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Pizza
Italian
Reservations
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"I absolutely love this place! Ivan’s, you have the best Italian food in..."
Kristina Owen
"I love this place. The food is delicious and ALWAYS..."
Susan Finnegan
"Best restaurant in New Windsor! You can get anything from pizza to a full course dinner! Everything is always fresh and made to..."
Debbie Moore
"Love..."
Karoll Rodriguez
"Food is always fresh, homemade by owner herself and plenty for take home leftovers. The pizza is a crispy thin crust with always fresh topping. The..."
Tony Mazzuca
"I went to Ivana's Cucina for the first time ever. I can't believe I didn't find this place sooner. I've been in New Windsor for 14 years and I have..."
Steven Summo
"Ivanas is a huge hit with our family. Whether it’s lunch, a night out, or ordering pizza in, we love it here! Great Italian cuisine, great..."
Amanda Mcknight
"Best Chicken Parm in Hudson Valley. Their pizza is incredible. When I order it, the office loves it and raves about how good it is. Can always relay..."
Scott Dwyer
"Took my daughter for a quick lunch there for the first time...It's a beautiful little place, fantastic food, reasonable and very friendly. We will..."
Carolyn Ayestas
"Good authentic Italian..."
Lyla Answer
La Casa Vicina
85/100 (696 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Pesto
Shrimp
Pasta
Salad
Calamari
Calamares
Sit down
Italian
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Full Bar
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Great place , wonderful owner and staff , great food and specials every week!! We always feel welcome and leave full and..."
Laura Dowd
"Another perfect meal at one of our favorite spots! As usual, impeccable service, tons of specials to choose from, and delicious food! The striped..."
Lora Whaley Eubank
"The food is amazing. Clean n staff very friendly. Felt like I was family.. HV gone there many time. N will continue to go. I recommend you try it....."
Louisa Tucciariello
"Delish! Warm friendly staff,great sized portions,lots of..."
Jacklyn Hirsch-Calderone
"Amazing food!! Always consistent! The staff is the..."
Stacy Crisci DeGelormo
"On February 6th after a memorial service for my father a large group of my family went to La Casa Vicina without a reservation. My company had used..."
Susan Borath Hurd
"Great restaurant ! Service is excellent, food delic, reasonably priced & varied menu. We always enjoy & bring our out of town guests there. Check..."
Lynda Chernek
"I had my sons 18th Birthday party it was a snowy day,and the owners where very accommodating. We had a great time , the food was delicious, & there..."
Susan Cruz
"Great service and the food was delicious. Good atmosphere and not loud so you could here the conversation. Will definitely be..."
Mary Ann Ritosa
"Absolutely amazing , great food , great service, and great price. Could not ask for anything..."
Pete Mitchell
"I love this place! Food is always amazing. They let you order off the menu if you have a craving for something different. Owners always come and..."
Virginia Evans
"We went to a party there and it was great. Tge food was good. The service was great. Very pleasant and friendly staff. Very..."
Joanne Mazzarelli Silva
"My wife and I have dined here 4 times in the past few months. The food is excellent and the service is great. I strongly recommend La Casa..."
Jeff Garfinkel
"Delicious! Always look forward to going back! The muscles are to die..."
Kim Tetreault McDonnell
"Absolutely excellent food and the service is superb. We love the veal..."
Cathy Rush Muller
"The food and the service was excellent. Our waitress was friendly and attentive. The food was exceptional. I'll definitely be returning. I recommend..."
john estrada
"Not my favorite, but very decent quality food. I ordered the braised short rib ravioli, smoked salmon pasta, and duck risotto. All of the dishes..."
Tyler Wong
"The food here is phenomenal! I got the lobster ravioli and my husband got the New York strip. It was probably some of the best ravioli I've ever had!..."
Kimberly Crill
"Such delicious food! Super authentic Italian.. best cappuccino I’ve had in a while.. ordered calamari, eggplant parm, grilled octopus, and rack of..."
Vicki M
"I highly recommend this place! I called only a few hours before I needed platters of food for a party and they took my order! And it was ready on..."
M. A.
"Can not say enough. This place is Perfection when it comes to the food. We go a couple times per week. And since they opened we consistently rave..."
Laurie Bennett
"Superior food, superior service, a true example of what fine dining should be. Family run and the kind of place you go back to over and over again...."
Lori Messina
"We just held our daughter’s First Communion celebration at La Casa Vicina, and We couldn’t be happier with the outcome! The room is large and..."
Meghan Zigler
Marcelino's Pizzeria & Restaurant
84/100 (1108 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"I spent years eating at Marcelino's and then moved. I was so happy that I was able to take my boyfriend here this time. He ordered some slices (white..."
Larayna Smith
"Stopped in for 3 sandwiches based on online reviews. Reviews were spot on ! Meatball & Chicken parm sandwiches were awesome and service from the..."
Jay Jollie
"Went out with some friends to dinner there. Didn't realize they had a big dining room in the back, as I usually go there for take out. The food was..."
Paul Pasquale
"We just had the most wonderful time here... The service was amazing, as was every delicious morsel! Eat here, you will be..."
Tabitha LoPresto
"Our waitress here is always phenomenal. She remembers our preferences. The other waitstaff are super nice as well. I've never had a problem with the..."
Samantha Weck
"ah yes Richie the "C" and not to undermine some of his staff such as Laura and especially that girl named Dee personable real tell you how it is..."
Kenny Dunne (Dun-rite)
Capri Restaurant And Pizzeria
82/100 (781 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Salad
Pizza
Italian
Takeout
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"The waiter or should I say server was very nice, the food was absolutely wonderful, we will absolutely be back! Thank you for such a fabulous..."
Peg Hansen-Cilli
"Always great food , wonderful staff and amazing atmosphere! Definitely one of our family..."
Katie Wallace
"Always a delicious dinner. We had the chicken pizziola and the chicken franchese last night. With awesome chocolate cake for dessert. Excellent..."
Joseph O'Brien
"Great consistently exceptional food. I'm Sicilian and would pass their meatballs and sauce as my own in a pinch. Staff are always pleasant and..."
Cecilia Licata
"The food here is fantastic and the staff is so pleasant and accommodating! It's our favorite..."
Christine Capasella-Anderson
"The shrimp Capri was great! The bartender was very friendly. Service was..."
Linda Hall McAdon
"Great food and excellent service. Highly recommended for a nice family..."
Brian O'Connell
"yummy each and every time. Would highly..."
Lisa Lopez
"Capri moved from Broadway, we would follow you anywhere!!!! Delicious food! DEFINATELY a must..."
Karen Kaiser Sharp
"Hello people what are you waiting for we've been going to Capri for bout 6 years even though he moved to from Broadway to with the limited parking he..."
Sonny Gotz
"Delicious!!!!! Staff is great , nice, pleasant with a..."
Leza Muschett
"Celebration of Lynn Birthday. Food was delicious. Bread was good taste. Service is..."
Lady Mardy
"Love this place. Food usually top notch, interesting specials, full bar. Would give it 5 stars, but a piece of chicken in chicken parm was rubbery,..."
Lisa Cobb
"Beautiful dinning room with linen table cloths and napkins. Prompt and friendly service. The house salad dressing is amazing! Salad was crisp and..."
Karna Mullin-Pfeifer
"Have always loved Capri's sauces, their homemade house dressing, shrimp parm, stuffed chicken parm. Very reasonable prices..."
Susan Glassey
"Such a nice place we have discovered! FOOD IS DELICIOUS! I went there to ask if they do catering and to see if its possible to try some food, because..."
Rokso Lana
"They were able to accommodate my large party with short notice. Friendly staff. Food was very..."
Rachel Smith
"They have the best food ever. Especially the chicken parmigiana is by far the best that I ever had. The staff is also very nice and great to deal..."
Jennifer Pizzo
"Humble but warm location, and the food is AMAZING!!! I frequent this restaurant for small occasions (birthday dine outs, mother's day dinner, etc)..."
Jennifer Sass
Abc Pizza And Restaurant
81/100 (296 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Pizza
Italian
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"They're pepperoni pizza is seriously good. It's on the crispy and contained side, unlike a runny, cheesy slice that teeters out of your hand. No, I..."
Carrington Satcher
"I ordered a pizza to go and it was delicious! The staff was friendly and attentive. I plan to go back for dinner..."
Jim Kimball
"Love this place George the owner is great, Mary is great also. Best pizza..."
Chauncey Gatterdum
"I've been eating here for 40 years. Admittedly it's been a few years, but it's still the best pizza I've ever..."
Andrew Gulak (FatalException)
"Amazing customer service! Delicious..."
Jamie Kirwan
Cosimo's Pizza
88/100 (14 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Pizza
Italian
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"What a great experience! From the first person I spoke to behind the Deli who was beyond sweet. To one of the owners who happen to be sitting at the..."
Toshi Sweetser
"Great local deli in the area. Great food, great service, great prices. My new go to deli. Their breakfast options are amazing. Definitely recommend..."
Wili Camacho
"This is the sandwhich I missed. I went to high-school up here in NY, and I didn't realize that I was taking a sandwhich on a roll for granted. This..."
Matt N
"While visiting the area I had the pleasure of trying this Deli & Pizzeria business out. I have to say they by far had the best prices for their..."
Anthony Chavis
"I was in a rush, so I asked the lady behind the register what she suggested. She said the American Philly Cheesesteak and I listened!!! The service..."
Matthew Johnston
"Great food, large menu and staff is friendly. Stopped here a couple weeks ago for a turkey sub. They give you name brand deli meat and mayo and don't..."
Alberto Grieve
"Great sandwiches convenient to KSWF..."
Stephen Upton
Belisimo's
70/100 (137 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use