Review Yoder's Restaurant & Buffet - New Holland

It’s nothing fancy. But it’s cozy! You walk in and they have a little shop filled with handmade crafts and books and such. And you can walk right in and get seated. The buffet is nice limited choices eggs, tater tots, chip cream beef, pancakes, cereal and a few other choices. The staff is extremely friendly and the facility itself is super clean. Once your done with your food you can exit right into the Yoder market without even stepping outside which is a huge plus during inclement weather conditions. Plenty of parking and easy access if you are handicapped or disabled. A great spot for a quick meal!

Love how you have a choice. Either you can order from the menu or choose the buffet. We chose the buffet. No waiting in line! Hostess greeted us and brought us to the table immediately. Server was friendly and continuously cleaned up the dishes from the table as we returned to the buffet. Food was hot and delicious. I also enjoyed the cold shrimp and salad bar. Many items to choose from. A 5 star experience! The resturant had comfortable seating as well

Some daily specials. Pretty basic food choices. Daily buffet also available but at $21-$23 per person plus cost of drinks is just a little too pricey for me. Serrvice is fair. Food is still pretty decent. Not what it used to be but we will probably still stop by when we are in area.

We were thankful to have lunch here. The variety of hot and cold items on the buffet line was generous and the salad bar was impressive. They also have a wide variety of deserts. The staff were pleasant and helpful. If you don’t want the buffet, they have a menu you can order from.

Good food and a decent variety. I’d call myself a professional reviewer of all things related to Lancaster County, especially in terms of Pennsylvania Dutch cooking. Again the food was warm and tasty. The options were good. However, I wasn’t thrilled with the service. We waited over 10 minutes for a server and drink refills didn’t happen even once as our server only returned once and that was to provide the check. Because there are so many options in this area for Authentic PA Dutch Smorgasbords (Buffet) I’d hands down choose other places before Yoders. With that being said, I am sure it’s still worth a shot checking out if you never been. The food is worth a visit if even just once.

Great tasting food and great service. All you can eat buffet was on point.

I ve now been here 2 times. The food is superb! Much higher quality than Ive ever gotten at a buffet anywhere else. They handle tour groups great, and you would never know the place is so full of people, because they know how to handle the crowd. I would eat here anytime I were in the area!

Good food. Great price. The place full of people, my waitress did a GREAT job. I gave her a 20% tip. Looking forward to going back again.

We ordered the buffet. The server was nice. However, she was a little slow to ask how things were and if we wanted refills

Our server's name was Ginny. We were 14 in the room for a wake. Gunny told us about the steak station, kept us filled with Coke, coffee soda & tea. She was very helpful with the 2 wheel- chair bound ladies. The salad bar was immaculate, and everything perfectly fresh. Steaks were done to specification & had onions, mushrooms and other fixins. Pearl tapioca & egg custard were favs for dessert!

I'm really happy I tried this place on my recent trip to Lancaster! I've been to the Shady Maple in the past and heard it's going downhill.. but this place had great reviews! We went for lunch on a Monday and it wasnt overly crowded, we were pretty distanced from everyone else! All the employees were very friendly. There is a lot of hot food to choose from, and a huge salad bar. I loved the fried chicken! Things were also restocked consistently. I am a picky eater and I found lots to enjoy. Their dessert area has cake & pies pre cut & covered to keep them sanitary. Theres at least 3 tables set up with gloves & sanitzer. Overall the food was great & the price was fantastic! This will be our new place to eat when we come visit the area.

I always love my visitors to Yoder’s. Our group of Pastors meets there monthly and we always enjoy great food and service from the team. I love that Yoders is not an oversized “house of gluttony” as a rival smorgasbord seems to strive to be. Highly recommend!