Evelyn's Tavern

One of the best pizzas I've ever had well worth the 26 dollars for the large all meat everything on it piggie definitely could stuff 4 people just sucks that we have to sit outside in the heated Beer Garden not too bad if you got a little propane heater right next to it which they provide but otherwise your hands are cold well worth the food though highly recommend great service as well

I used to love this place but I've had really poor service the last 3 out of 4 times I've been there. A month ago we waited 45 min. (We looked at the clock) and no one came to serve our table. At all. We left. Then we came again and got a round of drinks just fine but then the second order never arrived. We waited 30 min (also checked the clock) and nothing showed up. At that point we gave up and left. They gave us a drink discount on our previous rounds but still didn't get our second rounds because of last call (even though we ordered 15 Min before it). Third time was great. Fourth time we waited 25 min before someone even served our table. We ordered food and waited over an hour and the food never showed up. Went to ask and the order was never put in and now the kitchen was closed so we couldn't get dinner. We had showed up at 740 to order and by this time it's around 930. They ordered us a cheesy bread and a ceasar salad to make up for it (don't know how that's done with the kitchen being closed and not making our actual order) and the ceasar salad was also never delivered. They gave us a 25 g.c. because of everything that has happened and compd our food. I don't think I even want to use our g.c. I'd like to go somewhere that will serve us instead. I'm giving a two instead of a one because the attempted to make up for it and where apologitic.