Sluurpy
Reset

There are 8 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Montauk

There are 8 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Primavera Pizza
90/100 (479 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
"Came to this pizza joint after leaving the lighthouse for lunch on a summers day, and boy, that was a great lunch! While there is no indoor seating..."
TheLongIslander
"Delicious sauce,high quality cheese and thin chewy crust with a delicious smoky flavor make this the hands down best pizza ever in Montauk. This is..."
Peter Vita
"My choice location for pizza in Montauk. Great selection in pizza variety. My fav is the Margarita Pizza, my son says their garlic knots are the best..."
Lidia Ciamarra
"Best Authentic Italian food in Montauk! Need more cooks, counter help and better counter pizza types displayed ,but everything is so good food..."
Anthony Paratore
"Primavera Pizza is hands down the best Italian food in Montauk. Food is always fresh and perfectly made. Whether you have a slice of pizza, eggplant..."
Rich Dec
"By far, the pizza in Montauk. The crust, sauce. Pepperoni slice is what to get. 4 min walk off main street. Outdoor eating. Seats 4 total. No..."
Kevin DiVeglio
"This place is a hidden gem. One of the fast casuals places in Montauk. From the pizza to the eggplant parm, extremely fresh ingredients. Located..."
Amy Ward
"Good pizza! I just wish they didn't heat up there slices so hot...then again I could have asked them to just warm them..."
Kenneth Kohlmann
"ACCEPTS CREDIT/ DEBIT. That deserves a 6th star around here, lol. Perfect crust, delicious pizza sauce. We ordered a cheese pizza, shoestring fries..."
Reina Navarro
"Best pizza in Montauk. Life savor. Solid food, great price. Monster heros. Eat here regularly. Thank you..."
John Luniewski
"Went in for the first time and got some regular slices without too much expectations, pizza was sublime! Paired with a majestic sunset, can't beat..."
One Fast Dean
"Best pizza and sandwiches in Montauk but DONT GO THERE because it will make the lines out the..."
Jerrier Atassi
"Great! Delicious pizza pie, 1/2 onion (delicious saute onions) 1/2 Pepperoni ....very courteous counter worker..young lady from the Chek..."
charles mcLean
"Good for a quick meal. Panini's and salads are very good as well as the pizza. Reasonably..."
Robert Bacchi
"The pizza is good and you can rest outdoors. The kiddos lived it and the went to play in the party across the..."
Rodolfo Nunez
"Actually had a very good margarita pizza here. It's Montauk priced, but..."
J P
Blade And Salt
89/100 (362 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
Kenny's Castaways
89/100 (73 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Seafood
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Drinks
Sit down
Seafood
Italian
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Non-smoking restaurants
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Private Dining
Street Parking
Seating
Table Service
Waterfront
Wheelchair Accessible
Wine and Beer
Drinks
Dinner
Late Night
Mid-range
Pulcinella East
84/100 (79 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
"Wonderful experience all around. BEST eggplant appetizer we’ve ever had. View was incredible, service was impeccable. We were treated like family...."
Tamara Verushka
"Great food. Great views. Cheese wheel pasta is delicious. Would definitely recommend if you're in..."
PJ B
"Last Friday we dined at this new addition to the Montauk dining scene. We had a party of 17 including 6 young children. Gennaro and his entire staff..."
Mary Ranieri
"Awesome delicious different menu Friendly staff One of best Italian restaurants Ive ever been to! We had 9 people in our group who all raved about..."
Bob Scroope
"Excellent food and service at a beautiful restaurant overlooking a pond with gorgeous sunsets. And reasonable prices, especially for..."
Bill and Marlene Maderer
"What a perfect evening! Sitting outside on the water was lovely and the food was delicious! We will definitely go..."
Colleen
"Amazing food, amazing service, get to taste authentic italian/napoletana food in the heart of..."
Arbnor Kokolli
"Food was amazing!! Can't wait to go..."
GEORGE GRECO
""
María Marin
""
Robert Pannell
""
Jesse Reynolds (By Jesse Reynolds)
""
Sdeini Avani
""
David Gale
""
Gennaro Minale
Sausages Pizza & Pastabilities
83/100 (326 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Pasta
Salad
Pesto
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Delivery
Takeout
Lunch
Dinner
Cheap Eats
"Our family of 10 walked in and had the best pizza � for a great price. We were super pleased and plan to make a trip back for..."
Virginia White Rinker
"Great pizza,amazing chicken parm calzone and pretty girls.Great place!..."
Adam Deckman
"I met Hunter and his mom last night! We enjoyed our dinner!! Awesome place !!!! 5..."
Denise Kennedy
"The best quick and delicious lunch. Loved it! I love the fact that they are open in the afternoon, while all other places are..."
Sean ainechi
"I'm from Queens, NY! This pizza was delicious and for a reasonable..."
Lilibeth T
"My favorite pizza in Montauk Offering dine in, takeout, and delivery this is a NYC style pizza joint that has a few small booths and outdoor tables..."
Jennifer LaFreniere
"Im new to the area, Sausages always takes care of me. Best pizza in new england, let alone new york. Love yall, thanks for fresh food when i need it..."
MC900FooTJesus
"We order from Sausages every time we are in Montauk. Their pizza is awesome - would absolutely recommend. We look forward to it as our first night's..."
S Gries
"Really good NY Pizza. Very pleasant ordering process. Delivers when promised. Order here if in Montauk. Regular and Grandma's are the go-to..."
Jay Goldstein
"We ordered 2 large pies to be delivered and it came in 45 minutes still hot! The pizza was better than expected. This is a great spot to order from..."
Danny Chong
"Love this place. Except that lately, they can't seem to get the orders right for take-out, but pizza is still delicious...."
christina marie
"I'm from Brooklyn NY and this might be some of the best pizza I've ever had. Everything in Montauk is a little expensive but I definitely got what I..."
f2bacon
"Don’t just drive past this place. Do yourself a favor and stop and eat. The chef is phenomenal. The customer service was great. Don’t overlook..."
Jeanmarie McDonald
Scarpetta Beach
81/100 (2648 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Seafood
Italian
Seafood
Gluten Free Options
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Drinks
Chocolate Brownie
Black Cod
Tagliatelle
Lobster Roll
Cod
Shrimp
Creamy Polenta
Halibut
Charred Octopus
Chicken Cobb Salad
Lobster
Yellowtail and Short Ribs
Polenta
Pasta
Creme Fraiche Panna Cotta
Tagliatelle
Salad
Pesto
Fish
Sorbet
Scallops
Fritto misto
Cavatelli
Duck
Braised short ribs
Asparagus
Calamari
Duck breast
Tuna Tartare
Seared Scallops
Tuna
Juice
Veal Tenderloin
Calamares
Bread
Beet Salad
Seafood
Italian
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Reservations
Outdoor Seating
Seating
Waterfront
Table Service
Valet Parking
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Drinks
Dinner
Fine Dining
"Excellent dishes that somehow manage to upstage the gorgeous oceanfront setting. My scallops were perfectly cooked, and the lobster pasta was..."
Stephen Zubrycky
"What can I say? The experience was totally wonderful as we haven’t been here for many years. Reservations worked like clockwork, seating, and..."
David Solano
"The food is amazing everytime I come here. Drinks by the fire pit on the water is the perfect vibe. Highly..."
Destiny Pomarico
"Wonderful experience. Very attentive service, delicious plates. Amazing..."
Alberto Vazquez
"Amazing place. You have to go! It was pricey but I have seen more expensive. Not bad price wise. The food was superb. Staff was attentive and quick...."
Mike “Bar.snobs” DeMarino
"I absolutely love this restaurant and everything that they offer. I cannot begin to describe how amazing the food tasted and how well it was prepared..."
Magnus Mootoo
"Cant begin to explain how delicious the food was here. It was hard to even limit yourself when choosing from the menu, everything on there looked..."
Christopher Persaud
"The food, service and atmosphere at Scarpetta Beach are incredible. The individuals at the valet are particularly kind. We were able to get drinks at..."
Julianna Capobianco
"Wonderful appertizer and *perfect* pasta dishes. Scallop was very well made. Amazing view over the beach and very romantic for sunset dining. ..."
Erica Chan
"Amazing experience at Scarpetta in Montauk! Set outside on the deck with a great view of the ocean. We ordered cocktails with our appetizers and got..."
Christina Romano
"Service is excellent, food tastes great no matter what you get, however the portions are very very small. You can order almost the entire menu with 4..."
John Chimento
"i like it here, the best view and nice service, design is beautiful..."
Nata
"this Hamptons Outpost of the Scarpetta group is everything you'd expect it to be if you've ever been to a Scarpetta or to Gurney's previously. The..."
Barney Simon
"This is the tale of 2 nights 2 different experiences. We had a 2-night stay at the beautiful Gurney's. Our first evening at this stunning restaurant,..."
Susan G
"We came here for Memorial Day weekend for dinner. Originally the reservation was for two. However, a few hours before the reservation we needed to..."
PB
"So good. Food was perfect - exactly like the scarpetta in nyc. Ambiance was unreal with the views from turkeys beach Club looking over the ocean. The..."
Michael Sinensky
Pizza Village
80/100 (1302 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Pasta
Salad
Meatballs
Lasagne
Baked Ziti
Pesto
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Highchairs Available
Delivery
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Cheap Eats
"Pizza Village is the place to go in Montauk for your pizza fix. It's a dated establishment that has been around for a long time. A classic old school..."
Lou Cap
"CASH ONLY * Our duo tried three different slices from the glass case and we ooohed and ahhhhed over every bite. My favorite by far was the spinach..."
Amanda Miller
"I don’t like a small pepperoni aS much as the next guy and this is hands down some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. Do yourself a favor and order..."
Ryan James
"They did not have the baked lasagna but I tried the ravioli instead.. AWESOME..."
William L Jones Jr
"Pizza was great and convenient to take a box to go and hit the..."
J Anthony
"Stopped in for a few slices while in the area for a wedding. Indoor dining was not open but there were a few tables outside. I got 2 slices, one w..."
Jennifer houlihan
"Our family members have been going here for years and it really never disappoints! We stopped in for a late lunch this year when in town. We ordered..."
Laura Johnson
"When looking for places to eat in Montauk, we were looking for a local shop to feast at. Came across this in our Google search rated as one of the..."
Luke Carlson
"Love ❤️ this place. Super nice stuff and amazing pizza..."
Goran NYC Photographer
"💥One hot slice ready to go in minutes with authentic pizza joint "decor". Just what I was looking for right at that moment 😎 Nice thin, crispy..."
Eric Schofield
"Went in here on a whim after not finding a good carbonara nearby and was in for a super pleasant surprise. They make linguine carbonara that..."
ivan roman
"dropped in right before close for a meatball slice with cold cheese topper. 2 slices for $10. Pizza was REALLY GOOD! Way under rated. Get..."
Doug Gamble
La Fine At Montauk Manor
76/100 (248 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
Pasta
Salad
Clams
Meatballs
"We ate here last Thursday night. First, we had a great table outside by the heat lamps and we were close to the amazing musician. He played all types..."
Morgan Nicole Saatchi
"What an amazing staff!! food was great and the espresso martinis were..."
Victor Sala
"we had a great time and the food was superb! the atmosphere was intimate and..."
Danielle Gagliardi
"Im reading The bads reviews of this restaurant, and im really surprised !! well excuse me but this is an amazing place , very nice , clean, elegant,..."
Ammy Vanessa Mattheus
"Words cant explain...from the minute we laid eyes on the cozy and quaint entrance, to the beautiful outdoor setting. The owners were beyond..."
Tony Gab
"I love the place.... Perfect 4 a romantic night..."
Gilma Catalan
"Awesome restaurant. The wait staff were..."
Michelle Lynn
"This place was awesome! Great food. Stand out was the octopus and the mushroom appetizers. I had the burger and it was not overcooked with plenty..."
Chris Kies
"Overall, a good bite for myself the family. Drinks are pretty strong (not a terrible thing) Appetizers were tasty (the crispy mozzarella was to die..."
Gamal Aly
"We really enjoyed dining here. Atmosphere could use some attention. We liked the casual environment but it felt a bit like a college dining room..."
Elisabeth Aly
"We had an excellent meal at the Hilltop last evening. Rockefeller stuffed mushrooms were amazing. Fish was fresh, beautifully presented and..."
Noreen Haren
"My birthday dinner last night was a pork oasis buco and amazing desserts…Just as special as my visit to Montauk a year ago. Colleen will take care..."
Liz Harris
"A true find in Montauk Ambiance, food, service 5 star. Our waitress katalina also a treasure. Garden seating quaint and..."
Gary Aquarius
"What an unexpected surprise. Fabulous service, wonderful food, all for a great price. Highly recommend to..."
Karen Sweeney
""
Val Feldsher
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use