Nypd Pizza
231 E North Ave, 53212-3315 - Milwaukee
Recommended by Sluurpy:
2025
2024
2021
#929 of 941 restaurants in Milwaukee
Updated on
€€
Italian
Pizza
Sluurpy Quality Index
PROPRIETARY
Popularity
100/100
Quality
53/100
Data Completeness
72/100
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
🚚
Delivery
🥡
Takeout
🍽️
Dine-in
♿
Wheelchair accessible
♿
Accessible restroom
😊
Casual
🛋️
Cozy
👥
Good for groups
📊 Popular Times
Not busy
Moderate
Very busy
📷 Photos (5)
Photo 1 / 5
100%
Google Reviews
982
Google reviews
Very friendly employee took my order, repeated order back to me & applied a coupon for the two pizzas. Cheese type was changed & pizza was baked as requested, "please don't burn the crust." Both pizzas were done to perfection! Thank you to the cook! Two lasagna orders were also cooked to perfection! Garlic & garlic cheese bread seem like they needed more garlic, but maybe that's their recipe. It was good tasting otherwise. Had a turtle sundae while waiting, & it was tasty, but I didn't realize it was soft serve ice cream. Love this pizza because it tastes great hot or straight out of the fridge. Pizza crust didn't get soggy when eaten two days later & not warmed up.
Read more
Google
Pretty great food, if you’re in the area, I recommend it.
Google
Great food, okay atmosphere, all business-like.
Google
This is my First time eating here in a very long time, it was okay but good. The food was good, love their bone in wings 😋 yum. Their thin crust pizza 🍕 was ok for me. They also have a variety of pies slices and cake, so delicious. The menu is very much great having so much things that we love. Thank you for a very good customer service, treated us on Monday with a very nice smile, respectful way. Love the pictures on the wall. And the two statues. Would love to go again and try other things.
Read more
Google
First time eating here in a very long time, it was okay but good. The food was good, love their bone in wings 😋 yum. Their thin crust pizza 🍕 was ok for me. They also have a variety of pies slices and cake, so delicious. The menu is very much great having so much things that we love. Thank you for a very good customer service, treated us on Monday with a very nice smile, respectful way. Love the pictures on the wall. And the two statues. Would love to go again and try other things.
Read more
Google
love the pizza, tough neighborhood.
Hours are questionable late night. Which is understandable because of the neighborhood.
Google
I've only been inside this place once and there were a few teenagers i assume waiting for food, but they were giving a couple other customers a hard time and they weren't told to either calm it down or leave which i felt like the safe should have addressed that issue when it was happening.
Other than that i cant say anything negative about this establishment...
The food was great... I will say some things i think are a tad bit pricey but other foods make up for the prices. I've tried a bunch of their menu and i cant complain about nothing taste wise because everything was made just perfect... The place was clean and staff were nice but its in a not so great area. If you're in for having some good pizza and ribs NYPD is definitely the spot to go.
Read more
Google
All in all really good food, I good wings that were great, but I am disappointed that I can't get pizza by the slice. When I go to something that tells me it's NY style pizza I expect to be able to get a couple slices and not need to buy a whole pie.
Google
Excellent service, call in orders ready upon arrival. Variety of menu selections. Have tried several menu offerings and found the meals to be favorable. The pizza no doubt is New York style. Definitely would recommend them for an unexpected event or occasion .
Google
Great tasting New York style pizza! Quality ingredients and quick turnaround time. The weird booklicker name and theme of the place did keep me away for literal years, but the pizza is good despite the cop pun.
Google
Explore more in Milwaukee
By cuisine
By specialty
Recommended pages
Help improve this page: