Blackwater Bistro
5147 Elmira St, 32570-5905 - Milton
Recommended by Sluurpy:
2025
2024
2021
#2 of 73 restaurants in Milton
Updated on
€€
American
Bar
Sluurpy Quality Index
PROPRIETARY
Popularity
100/100
Quality
60/100
Data Completeness
72/100
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
🌳
Outdoor seating
🥡
Takeout
🍽️
Dine-in
🚚
Delivery
🍺
Alcohol
🍹
Cocktails
🍷
Wine
📅
Reservations
♿
Wheelchair accessible
♿
Accessible restroom
😊
Casual
🛋️
Cozy
👥
Good for groups
📊 Popular Times
Not busy
Moderate
Very busy
Contact Information
📞
Phone:
+1 850-623-1105
🌐 Website:
http://www.blackwaterbistro.com/
📍
Address:
5147 Elmira St, Milton
📷 Photos (11+)
+3
more photos
more photos
Photo 1 / 11
100%
Google Reviews
1,520
Google reviews
Quaint eatery near downtown, Main Street. Park across the street in the lot or behind the building. Great date spot for Friday evening live music and delicious chef prepared food. We're talking fresh, homemade, unique and flavorful dishes served by really friendly staff in a historic downtown home that's been converted into the Blackwater Bistro. I originally had lunch here with my coworkers and was so impressed my husband and I returned and thoroughly enjoyed dinner. Our waitress, Josie, was a great resource for dinner recommendations. My husband had the Creole Trio Pasta and I had the Chicken Divine. We were both impressed with the quality and quantity of our meals. We completely cleaned our plates, which seemed to be a theme as I saw tables being bussed with consistently empty plates. Full disclosure, we over-ate even opting to indulge in a shared dessert of bread pudding and ice cream. You can judge by the picture how it it was because we almost ate the whole thing, but couldn't muster the last bite, being so full.
Read more
Google
Beautiful old house! Warm and welcoming staff! Delicious food! Party of 4 had the daily dinner special and wedge salad, Lobster Ravioli and Filet with added Blackened Shrimp! You can't go wrong with the Sampler Starter! Highly recommend the Bread Pudding for dessert!
Google
Had dinner with a friend here per her suggestion. We sat outside and enjoyed a very tasty meal. Atmosphere is casual to dressy. Service was wonderful. They have a large menu with unique samplings. I enjoyed the steak divine with gouda grits. My friend ordered the ? Appetizer sampler. We were both very pleased with our meals. I enjoyed leftovers as well. Highly recommend.
Read more
Google
Stopped here on a whim. Best decision ever! Food was fantastic and fresh. Apple cobbler was the best, homemade and warm. Jessica was our server and is personable, pleasant, kind, and attentive. We'll be regulars here when we move here for sure!!
Google
Awesome service and cute place, great parking . Food was good but not great; Wrap was light on meat, PoBoy was tasty…But worth the money and visit!
Google
The artichoke cheese cake dip was out of this world. The service was also extraordinary. We went there after a wedding rehearsal and they had no problems over exceeding our expectations in a large group. The food, drink and service was exemplary.
Thank you Blackwater Bistro you are a gem.
Google
This was our first time coming since the menu was recently updated and new chef hired and we were very pleased! The little things show the quality, like the flavor of the fries and lumpia that will tell you if the oil is fresh and it makes a big difference, and they nailed it. Everything came out hot and tasted fresh, the gumbo was delicious! Get the artichoke cheesecake app, you will not regret it! Ask for Lucas, he took great care of our party of 6! The peach cobbler was SO good and you can't go wrong with the gouda shrimp and grits either!
Read more
Google
Amazing food and service. I got the Cajun Cheesecake, Mac-Daddy Bleu, and Peach Cobbler.
Google
The host was so warm and friendly, inviting and engaging. Their decor, and especially the floor was absolutely stunning! Our waiter Lucas was an absolute delight! He made the entire experience so phenomenal! Lucas helped with making superb menu selections and great drink pairings. We enjoyed the sampler platter of appetizers tremendously, it had coconut shrimp, savory artichoke cheesecake (sounds unusual but I promise it was exceptionally delicious), and a hummus that was way better and so much beyond the norm! Then we enjoyed the Chicken Divine, the Lobster Ravioli (the accompanying Caesar salad had the best untraditional dressing that I have ever had the pleasure of tasting), and a GASP Pizza! Everything was well prepared, prettily plated, and they were all such a tasty treat! Thank you for making my French 75s with tequila in lieu of the usual gin, they made the whole meal even better!!! The portions were great, the prices were really reasonable, the food was awesome, and the staff definitely made our trip to Blackwater Bistro unforgettable! Thank you so much, we hope to return again when we're back in the area!
Read more
Google
First time stopping in, and we were very impressed! Service was quick and friendly. The live band was great (they need to add a band name somewhere on the nights they are playing)!
Beer was ice cold and food tasted amazing! Lots of menu choices, so no matter how picky the eater, you should find something they will like! We will patron many times in the future, especially on live music nights!
It was busy but that's to be expected for a Saturday night, but there was plenty of seating both inside and out, so if there is a wait, I would guess it would be very short! We noticed several people with their dogs, so I assume pets are welcome, at least in the outside dining area. Don't delay, patron soon! You won't be disappointed!
Read more
Google
Explore more in Milton
Help improve this page: