Noah's Ny Bagels

The people here seemed very nice and the service was fast, but this has been the only time I’ve been to Noah’s bagel and they make it horrible. First off we asked for both bagels to be toasted and they were not so I cold bagel is kinda tough to bite into. Another thing is the cream cheese, usually there’s a lot of cream cheese that goes onto the bagel which the picture on the left got enough to cover the bagel while the one on the right barely had any at all so my boyfriend ended up throwing it away. Waste of our money for it not being made right.

Fantastic collection of bagels, no complaints at all for the quality of bagels that they serve. It has been a go to place both for me and my fiancé for bagels. Everything bagel and five cheese are my fav! However, the service we received today wasn’t upto the mark. We ordered 1 five cheese, Asiago and two everything bagels and in one of the wrapped bagels, a very small piece of bacon (third attached picture) was found, which isn’t acceptable especially as both I and my family are vegetarians. What I also didn’t like is when we were waiting for our order to be prepared, I saw that a tray filled with bacon was placed right next to where the person was wrapping the bagels. What if a person ordering is either vegetarian or vegan? When we saw the bacon piece, it also made us think that may be the person who wrapped a bagel with bacon for someone else’s order, prepared our order too. It was extremely disappointing to see this coming from Noah’s. Last, because of a bad experience for ordering through the app last time, we went inside the store to order the bagels so we can pick what’s available, today when we asked for a free coffee that you usually get with each purchase of a bagel if ordered from the app, they denied the free coffee as the bagels weren’t ordered through the app. I would think twice before coming again here!

Update 12/3/2021: We submitted an order through their online catering process on 12/2/2021 for pickup 12/3. Went to the store to retrieve our order and it was not ready. They said they did not have an order from us. When we produced a hard copy confirmation, they said we saw that but were to busy to prepare it. One has to wonder... ------------------- We are a local business. We ordered 2 dozen bagels and smears to be delivered by Door Dash. The delivery only included the smears, napkins and plates. No bagels. The Door Dash person said that was all that was given to them. Really? You go to a bagel shop and don't get bagels? Tried calling the store, no one picked up my call. Frustrating. I jumped in my car and drove to the shop to pickup the missing bagels. Once there, the cashier looked confused and got the manager. The manager came out with our bagels and said "We wondered why the Door Dash person did not take the bagels?" Manager? 30 minutes, 7 miles, $25 delivery fee later we had our bagels.