Sluurpy
Reset

There are 8 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Pizza cuisine: the best places to taste it in Millersville

There are 8 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Sugar Bowl
89/100 (579 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
American
American
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Cheesesteak
Sit down
Pizza
American
Seating
Delivery
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"As a Millersville alumnus and employee, I have had many a meal at the sugar bowl. Their food is always amazing and they are faster than you would..."
Doug Kyle
"A nostalgic blast from the past for my wife and I as I had not been there in over seven years, but I’m happy to say that the place has still got..."
Bryce Sadler
"We really enjoyed having a stromboli,cheesesteak, and milkshakes. Staff was nice, the prices were good and the food was tasty. We would be happy to..."
John Campbell
"Great little sub/snack shop. I had a turkey sandwich and my husband had a cheesesteak. We shared French fries. Everything was..."
Judy Deleo
"This is the best reason to visit Millersville, but can be very inconsistent. I’ve had the best Italian sub in Lancaster County, and I’ve had an..."
ERIC UNGRADY
"Sugar Bowl is a hidden gem on the Millersville campus that has good food and prices. The pizza and cheesesteak subs are delicious and they are not..."
Seth Johnston (Tinzien)
"When we first moved to the area, everyone said we had to get Sugar Bowl stromboli. It was a tip that has proven valuable over the last 8 years. It's..."
Anthony Boyer
"Awesome place, just moved in to the University, and I’ve had more food here than in MU dining. All the staff are nice, the food is good, and best..."
Ian McHale
"Im a commuter at Millersville University, and I eat lunch here 3 times a week in-between classes for the past year. I have tried almost every menu..."
Laurence Foley
"I have to admit: I came back for nostalgia. I remember back when this kid from the Philly area came here in 1985. The Sugar Bowl was one of the first..."
Stephen Kaelin
"Food is always tasty. Delivery time is fast. Very good cheese steaks..."
George Ciarrocchi
"The Owners of this great piece of Millersville history, are the nicest, kindest and hardest working couple you could meet. Great food, great service..."
Chad Wolf Sr. (Wolfman, Shots)
"Service was amazing, they served us when they were about to close. They were very nice, and the food was..."
Ben Gehrt
"Solid, thick, flavorful pizza at an incredible price. I’ll be back, no..."
Jake Lamb
"Good food, good prices, fast service. Pizza is average, but the sandwiches and appetizers are..."
Harry Davis
"Came for a University visit with my son. This place was recommended. It did not disappoint. My son said the pizza smelled good and tasted even..."
marnyka buttry
Ledo Pizza
83/100 (1422 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Pizza
Italian
American
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Salad
Sit down
Italian
American
Pizza
Serves Alcohol
Gift Cards Available
Highchairs Available
Takeout
Television
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"The best pizza ever! I never miss a chance to enjoy Ledo Pizza with cooked bacon and..."
Linn Hickman
"Our server was great!! Perky as well as efficient. Wild boar pizza was great, wings and mozzarella sticks were..."
Maureen LaCharite Hutchins
"I celebrated National Pizza Day, yesterday at that location. Our sever was great. Our pizza was served fresh and hot. It didn't take long for our..."
Mary Benedict Jennings
"Such a great place, awesome staff and amazing..."
Alice Peek
"Always amazing pizza and great service!! Our favorite Ledos for..."
Casey Banks
"I love the staff here they was very attentive even though they was short staff. They all pull together to make sure Us the guest didn't notice. The..."
Chef Stinson
"We come here every week for dining with our family. The food here is always consistent and delicious. The servers here are awesome. Every single..."
Mj Fador
"The staff was efficient and kind. A great spot for a quick..."
Breonna Roberts
"Pizza was had lots of cheese and my girls loved it. The pepperoni was abundant. We should have let pizzas settle for 10 min before eating. We eat..."
Gecko Tech
"We've become regulars on Monday evenings, picking up a pineapple/ ham pizza for my wife and mushroom/ sausage gluten free for me. They are close so..."
Rob Appleton
"I had the pita bread chicken sandwich it was great and the seasoned fries were..."
James Anthony
Nino's New York Style Pizza
83/100 (652 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Takeout
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"The cold subs on their fresh, homemade bread are so good. I was going to save half for dinner but couldn’t help but eat the rest. The prices are..."
Austin Boley
"Great food. Lunch specials and the Stromboli are nice choices. Giovanni and Tony offer friendly..."
sidney C
"Best pizza I’ve had period. It’s home for me. The chicken tenders are great as well. Love the employees as well. The plain cheese hits like..."
James Buterbaugh
"We were in the area and really craving some New York Style pizza, ended up here. I'm not an expert with pizza so I can't compare it to "actual" New..."
Elizabeth Ford
"Great pizza with an amazing crunchy crust if you get the well done..."
Malia Cherry
"Grabbed Pizza to go. Was done quickly and on time great crunch on the crust and tasty cheese blend. One of the better pizzas I've had in..."
Matthew Lascek
"The best pizza place in Lancaster county.. no competition... The family atomosphere keeps me coming back.. fast and friendly customer service always..."
Kenny brayboy
"Always a go to spot for the best pizza & subs in town. The staff are always so friendly & have smiles on their faces. Definitely recommend..."
Olga Pysher
"ABSOLUTELY THE BEST PIZZA!! Owners and staff will make everyone feel at..."
Candi Shank
"Great place to stop for pizza... I absolutely love their sicillian pizza! Give it a try you will like it..."
Greg Mazzeo
"I’ve never gotten Nino’s pizza, but their breaded chicken sub is incredible. I’ve gotten it on two separate occasions, and both times, it has..."
A. Nelson
"Got the Buffalo chicken pizza and was amazed by the size of their slices huge. No drink refills..."
urban Discipline
"My family's favorite pizza in Lancaster County. Reasonably priced and consistently great food. Moreover Nino's is a very friendly family run..."
James Kirchner
"I only ever order pickup from ninos. The Ninos combo pizza is my go to. The chicken Parm sub and meatball subs are also very good. Garlic knots on..."
James Sterling
"Large Italian was a great size definitely worth the money and the homemade bread was..."
nmartz157
"Delicious food and friendly owners. We stopped by for a quick lunch today and had a wonderful experience. We ordered a pizza, eggplant fries, and..."
Kara Cadenhead
"Nino’s Pizza is #1 according to my tastes. Same goes for the cold subs. Their house made sub rolls are beyond outstanding. Almost pretzel-like in..."
Ashton Mason
House Of Pizza
82/100 (1021 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Pizza
Seating
Serves Alcohol
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Great food, Great Beer, Great service! Hopie has been a staple establishment in Millersville for years, for a reason. Great spot all..."
Brien NoOne
"Love the place..Have some very good memories from there and it was fun to be there and chat with..."
Shirley Groff Boring
"I love there plain cheeseburger and love there pizza. Great owners too..."
Jim Robertson
"I've been a fan of the House of Pi since I was at Millersville University. 20 years after I graduated and I'm still coming..."
Miro Gutzmirtl
"I'm a Jersey boy.. I've tried many of cheese steaks in Lancaster.. You my friends have nailed it!!! Great steak!! Reminds me of..."
Jim Stavely
"Best Pizza and..."
Sally Fleming
"I had the Italian sub. It came toasted by default, so if you don't like it that way, heads up. There was a generous amount of toppings, and it was..."
Chuck Lund
"My second visit for pizza and it's even better than the first! I can't say enough about how good this pizza is. It is really delicious!! I added..."
Carey Wentworth
"I usually love this place and get a great sandwich but it was a hit or miss today. Apparently they can't keep up with a full parking lot and they..."
Lisa Myers
"For a pizza & deli type shop they are tasty. I enjoy their cheese steaks without the sauce. The prices on their website need to be updated. I called..."
Kim Auger
"As a MU student, I frequent this place pretty often, and have always had a great experience here. I’ve tried a good amount of the menu items, and..."
Brandon P
"Very pleased with our Stromboli tonight. Flavorful, full in ingredients. We will be back to try pizza next. Thanks for making our..."
Jamie&Karen Hirschberger
"They not only took us an hour early but they also give my group of 7 free pizzas as a compensation for their card reader having..."
Msuh Süöb
"I’ve been going to this pizza house since my childhood years! The food is always great and the service is as well! My hat is off to Gus because he..."
David Madonna
"Had lunch here today with my coworkers for the first time ever. I have driven past the House of Pizza many times. Why I don't know!!! First..."
Judy Keller
"Ordered from here several times and each time pizza was perfectly cooked with plenty of toppings and delicious. Today I called to place another order..."
mark borishkevich
"H.O.P. makes some of the best stromboli in town. And beer on tap. Great place to celebrate a win with your..."
Dan Rabatin
"I love the way they show me attention when I come there it like they focus their service on you when are placing your order and they want you to know..."
Eugene S
A-1 Pizza & Subs
81/100 (404 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Pizza
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Great service, super clean and always welcoming. The Pizza and subs are always fresh and definitely my favorite spot in town. The food is delicious..."
Roni Angel
"Best carry out chicken Caesar salad I've had and the stuffed white pizza was different and delicious..."
Courtney Jenkins
"LOVE their cheese steak subs! Best around this..."
Jackie Propst
"Best Greek Pizza Eva!!!! Love love love💜The food the portions, and the staff 100%. Sylvana at the register was very cheerful. Thank you..."
Vero Debsia
"I have ordered from A-1 for many years. The food has always been great. Have even moved and keep ordering from them from my new place. I have never..."
Joe T
"Pizza was good. Gyro is really dank too. Fast service cool people good take out. I would prefer these guysis over any dumb chain place any day. All..."
Leavy Peretto
"Hands down THE BEST local pizza spot, dare I say best pizza I have ever had. They don't skimp on the toppings, great sauce, and dough. The meat..."
Benjamin White
"Living in area for 6 yrs & never tried A-1! So sorry I never did! Pizza was delicious, great prices, they have a great menu with many options, pizza..."
Kimmie B
Two Cousins Pizza
78/100 (493 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Wheelchair Accessible
Gift Cards Available
Delivery
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Delivery. The girl that delivered my pizza the other day was a complete B. She gave me the dirtiest looks and told I need to answer the door quicker..."
Tdthomas
"Great pizza-our go to pizza joint in this college town with plenty to choose from. Best philly cheese steaks...get the special steak its..."
Ben Newton
"In my opinion one of the best in the area. The food is good, fast almost rediculously fast, service is prompt and the staff polite and helpful. I am..."
Argonaut
"I really enjoyed my California cheese steak hoagie. I real like their komade sub rolls. The employees are always nice. The best improvement that this..."
Dennis Regitz
"Great food, multiple choices from sandwiches to pizza to dinners to Stromboli to salads and more. Reasonably priced. Delivery service available and..."
Steven DiGuiseppe
"My husband and I stopped here for the first time because I told him I wanted authentic pizza hahaha. Well let me tell you they did not disappoint...."
Amanda Miller
"Two Cousins Pizza offers a typical menu but their food and portions are really good and offered at a decent price. They bake their own bread on-site..."
Seth Johnston (Tinzien)
"The food was good. However, the delivery driver needs to be proactive and not sit where one needs to send out a search crew. The most rude thing for..."
Tee
"Tonight I had the best sandwich ever. Loaded with meat. Friendly service..."
Lisa Myers
"The food is good. The French Fries are always Service is exceptional. The Cheesesteak Supreme is awesome! The Super Italian Sub is good..."
John Rosenow
"Great service, amazing food, and no wait! My husband even left his wedding ring on the table and it was held for us until the next day. That is top..."
Teshera Annashea
"Two Cousins Millersville has been a staple of the area since they first opened, on the opposite side of town, about 20 years ago. Their bread is..."
Josh Dyer
"Great place. I can never find any other pizza place that can beat it. Well at least not..."
Misael Colon
"Love this place, it's been a fav since forever.. Moved away, came back, couldn't wait to have my fav pizza again after 7yrs. The order taker was so..."
Leslie Day
"Two Cousins Millersville is a go-to in my house. They have great pizza, wings, subs and salads. Their salads come with homemade garlic bread. We go..."
Charlotte Brown
"Amazing subs! Had an Italian sub & my husband a..."
Janelle Funk
"Love my Two Cousin nights! No matter what I try I am always very happy, the food is delicious, delivery is fast and the prices are..."
Francisca H
Domino's Pizza
70/100 (250 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
"I ❤️ my local Millersville Domino's pizza. Delivery person is so nice and my order is always delivered timely! Great overall..."
Monica Colunga
Domino's Pizza
70/100 (921 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
"Dominos is the best! Thank you for supporting our..."
Missy Ann
"I placed order #83 on 12/21. Y'all must have just had your oven calibrated, got a fresh delivery and whoever was building pizzas was just the right..."
noah bos
"It’s always hot when delivered. Been ordering from them for over a year and haven’t had any..."
James R Eckman Sr
"Never cared for Domino's before. Then, about a year ago my daughter wanted a 'snack' at about 11 PM so she ordered one from this location to be..."
Jim Gable
"Food was great. 4 stars is because I couldn't order online. Also I was on the phone for over 15 mins trying to place a order. Arrived at the store..."
Renee Burkhart
"This is the first time i order online a Domino's, although i became a fan a few weeks ago having it at a restaurant. The ordering experience was..."
Leduan Commercial
"Orders are timely, but lacks consistency. Pan pizzas not always proofed properly and are thicker in the middle and everything slides to the outside...."
Andy Pham
"Best pizza crew ever!! They are so friendly and accurate, I’ve never had an issue with my order. They are on time all the time and deliver the..."
Angelica Castro
"Quick and easy deliveries. They definitely abide by their 100% no contact policy. Food turned out hot and fresh. Another job well-done by..."
Gian Fabian
"Food is always good, but delivery time is super slow. Could just be the time I order, but I've had to wait over 90 minutes for my orders multiple..."
Jennifer West
"Food consistently is well made and arrives in a timely fashion. Only ever had one hiccup, and it was resolved professionally and the driver..."
Amaroq641
"We generally eat Domino's at least once every week or two -- fast, easy meals at a reasonable price... Domino's offers something for everyone. The..."
Gene Detter
"The employees at this Domino's Pizza delivery restaurant are absolutely amazing. They bake every order to perfection, and the gents who deliver..."
Rose Boettinger
"I sent my brother an early Valentine's Day gift of a Domino's Pizza since he is away at school (Millersville). The staff was very friendly, and..."
Brittney Richardson
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use