We were at a special event today at the restaurant. There were a bunch of us there and appeared to be only in waitress/bartender. She did a fantastic job! We were worried about getting drinks and food with so many people and only one server. The kitchen did exceptionally well to handle us all also. It was a great experience and our first time here. We have been to the other place in town that a lot of our friends know about, but this place is MUCH better imo! We will be returning.
We came to the area for the weekend for a quick getaway. Luckily we stopped in at the Hotel for an afternoon beer. The staff was friendly and service was very good.
They showed us The evening dinner special, haddock homemade mac & cheese and stewed tomatoes. We made a reservation (you don’t need but recommend to be safe).
We ordered The haddock special, which can be prepared in three different ways. The food came out hot and the portions are very large.
The haddock filet was prepared perfectly, The stewed tomatoes and mac & cheese are obviously homemade.
The stewed tomato sauce is thicker and sweet and the best stewed tomatoes I’ve ever had in my life.
They have a large selection of beer to accompany your meal.
We will certainly be coming back to the Mifflinburg Hotel and Scarlet D Tavern and suggest that you come in as well.
The Scarlet D has good food at good prices, good people, and the owners and employees do a LOT for the community. There is an intentional antiquated vibe to this place, which has been a landmark in the community for many years.
My only complaint is that most of the chairs in the restaurant either need reupholstered or replaced, as they were definitely uncomfortable for most of the guests at my table, including me who has chronic hip and back pain. (I did get used to it after a while, but when you first sit down on a cushion most people expect to feel a cushion, and are surprised by a hard flat chair beneath their "sit bones.")
All in all, a great community business!
Nice place friendly service. Good looking blond tender. I didnt get her name. I haven t eaten there yet so I cant say about the food. Definitely a good visit.
Excellent as always. Great food and service. Our favorite place for us to sit and talk over a beer.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes