Review Amici Pizza

Todd McDonald

This family owned business is located in a Mesa strip-mall near Dobson rd. and Guadalupe rd. The owners completely overhauled the decor a few years ago and the result is a comfortable, friendly environment. They offer slices at least during lunch so I was able to sample 2 variations of their pizza and their lunch special kept 2 slices and a drink under $10. The pizza was very much NY style (thin crust- except for the Sicilian thick crust. They also offer an extensive menu of pasta/subs/salads, etc. that I did not try. Great little neighborhood restaurant.

Justin Klein

First time eating here, I got two slices of cheese pizza and it was fresh hot out the oven and perfect. Huge slices for only $3. What a bargain and the slices are delicious. Never thought I'd be so pleased with a simple cheese pizza. But this place is legit. Definitely will be seeing more of me.

Ana Zamora

Mom and pop stop has a new meaning with the young owners of this well established New York style pizza spot. The food is amazing... I had a margarita pizza with their stuffed balls and they were amazing . Sweet staff and amazing teamwork was shown as I dined in with my fiance.

Ashley Albury

As a Brooklyn er I absolutely loved this, authentic. I had Amici balsamic chicken sub. Did not disappoint, fresh with good bread and the chicken cutlet was done perfectly 👌 also, the black and white cookie? Sublime. The service was top knotch and I’ll def be back for the lunch special 10/10

Andrew McGuire

This place is a hidden gem and I highly recommend. I've been in AZ for over 20 years, coming from the tristate area - NY, NJ - There's very few places in AZ we've truly been able to recommend for NY style pizza. THIS. IS. IT.!!! We've been here now three times in three weeks and the pizza has been INCREDIBLE. We can't get enough of it. It's a must go but also a must to dine in and enjoy the pizza in all it's glory piping hot and fresh right out of the oven. Very nice staff and the chef is an artist, go find out for yourself! Go for the pizza but stay for the dessert options! No many good desserts to choose from!

britney lacey

First time here, I love small family owned restaurants. I got a large (8) piece pepperoni New York style pizza and fried raviolis for an appetizer. The pizza was to die for, the flavor was great so good I forgot to take a picture of it. The pepperoni are super small but packed with flavor and a little spice. Their menu is amazing they have a little bit of everything even offer an upside down pizza. They have pasta, calzones, salads, desserts and beer selections. Inside the place is kind of small but they have a good amount of places to sit and a couple of TVs which baseball was on when I was there. I would definitely recommend this place.

Darreika Washington

Food was amazing with the best pizza I’ve had and the crust was so delicious and crispy just enough :) the fried zucchini and mushrooms were delicious! I wish I took pictures of my 1 slice of bbq chicken pizza. And the meat lovers pizza 🍕 to go was amazing for a late dinner! Our waitress was sooo kind and accommodating to my infant and toddler! Will definitely be back! Only thing I wish was for a little bit more of a family vibe or seating.

Drew Carlson

Friendly staff, great pizza. Thinnest and most like New York pizza I've had. I get it "well done" because I think the crust needs that little extra crisp and they don't over-do it still. Glad I finally checked them out. There's always somewhere to park in that lot even if not right by the door.

L M

I am pregnant so I was having a craving for pizza by the slice and so far this restaurant has been my favorite over any . For $7-8 with drink and two large slices of pizza can’t be beat during their lunch hour. I was surprised there’s tasted like it hasn’t been sitting for so long like most places I’ve been to. It was hot inside but if you can find a seat underneath a fan you’ll be fine. I enjoyed the service here very much

Bob Martin

Outstanding, authentic, New York style pizza! The cheese, the sauce, the toppings, and the crust all taste like you bought it at 2:00 in the morning at Times Square. It's casual and kid friendly, and you won't be disappointed.

Caitlin Von Hagen

Amicis is our fave pizza date spot! The hospitality is fab and the food is tasty and makes me feel like im back in NY. Highly recommend!

Jasmine J

Got two large pizzas, which were way bigger than we expected! Puts other pizza places to shame. We got the square grandma one, as well as a chicken pesto pizza. We saw the chicken pesto on tiktok, and while it wasn’t a pizza normally on the menu, they were so nice and said they could do it for us! Both pizzas were PHENOMENAL! Perfect crust, perfect ratio of sauce and cheese and toppings. This has got to be the best pizza I’ve ever eaten.

veronica milburn

We ordered the Sicilian-style pizza. The slices are huge. It will easily feed 2-3 people. The crust was thick and crusty--perfect! It was our second visit, and we are definitely going back. Our server was terrific as well.

Mayra Bejar

I saw the owners' videos on tik tok and decided to visit this place because of that, and it did not disappoint. We ordered wings, garlic knots, a sicilian slice (dough was so fluffy), and a small calzone. It was a lot of food for the two of us and the calzone was pretty big. What I liked the most was the service and how clean the place was. Prices are very good as well. Would definitely recommend it, and we will try to come back.

Dolores Damian

Great prices. Wings were really good. Pizza felt like it needed something. So I added ranch and it tasted better with ranch. Glad the pizza wasn’t so thin. You can get pizza by the slice! The garlic knots were okay felt like it needed something too. Had to dip in the marina more. But liked how hot and fresh the garlic knots are. My brother got the Italian sub.

Jeff & Jenny

We came to Amici’s because our special needs daughter Brittany saw it on Tic Tok, and wanted to go while visiting Arizona . We are from Michigan and my husband is always up for trying a new pizza , so we decided to visit Amici’s. The pizza was great , the service outstanding, and the owner not only took time to visit with our daughter , but gave her an Amici tshirt and dessert! We highly recommend Amici’s where now we actually even feel like friends 😊

Leon Taveras (LeonimuZ)

Just moved to Phoenix from New York City and right away started looking for a new pizza place. This place is great! Service is okay and the calzone I had actually tasted NY Style, which a lot of places outside NY try to make but fail miserably. I will say it is missing the slight saltiness of NYC water, but besides that it was a good calzone. They have a sign that says they use Boars Head products which is the same stuff they use in NYC so that also greatly helps the taste. Definitely recommend.

Review Amici Pizza - Mesa