Review Jimmy And Joe's Pizzeria Serious Slices - Mesa

We had our orders taken as soon as we came in with little issue, and the food came out fairly fast. We got the #2 and #3 combos w/ 2 24 oz drinks. Lobby was 85° and although it was cooler than outside it was still noticeable and uncomfortable (hence the low atmosphere score) only one Parmigiano shaker - that was weird. Apps: Salad, Wings and Cheesy Bacon Fries Overall the salad was a simple spring mix with diced cucumber, small tomatoes, and sliced carrots. Blue cheese dressing was great in flavor and not overpowering. Spring mix was basic - nothing fancy there. The wings were really good. Mild was the flavor I went with because I wanted to taste the chicken and not just have it drowned out. Mild was a solid flavor. Only one wing was a let down* and overcooked, but it was due to hardly any meat or skin to protect the flat. The rest were perfect all the way through. Good crunch and plenty of meat. They werent JUMBO - which is ok. They were a great wing. The fries? Worst of the apps. If I had to guess - they use preshredded cheese and precooked bacon. The way they looked arriving to the table, it looks like they ran it under the pizza oven too long. Really need to work on how those are prepped. Pizza: Serious Slice Cheese, Serious Slice Pepperoni. The slices were as advertised - MASSIVE, but they were refired after we ordered. Biggest let down of the pizza portions was that it was obvious my Pepperoni was added on to a cheese slice and that my wifes cheese slice was just tossed back in the oven. Flavor was good, portion left us full. Drinks: 8 fountain options: PEPSI, DIET PEPSI, STARRY, MOUNTAIN DEW, TWO CREAM SODAS, BRISK SWEET AND UNSWEET. They did have bottles of Dr Pepper behind the counter and bottles of water branded with the stores name/designs. Overall - a good experience. It wasnt perfect execution, but I take food reviews seriously with new places and this score/experience was pretty standard. Hope to see improvements and try a pie next time so it's guaranteed made fresh and not refired. Receipt said UNDER NEW MANAGEMENT. Might have something to do with the uptick in positive reviews and decrease in negatives. Give it your own shot and hot take like I did.

Nice staff. The blonde girl with the glasses and purple accents in her hair was super helpful. Huge slices. Added artichokehearts to mine. Literally super filling. Good location too! My new fav spot!!! 🍕🍕🍕🍕

Love, love, love the pizza here. It's seriously a cut above the rest. And the joe's chicken sandwich is great! They have ENORMOUS slices and make up to a 24 inch pizza. I had it for the first time on Monday, it was so good I went back on Wednesday. And I'm gonna buy a 24 inch pie for a family pizza night next week. They run specials Sunday/Monday/Tuesday. They also have a challenge but I didn't see pictures so it must be tough. Go try to beat the gigantic pizza challenge!

I love this place. I get the NYC vibe. I haven’t been here in about five years but things haven’t changed. Pizza slices are huge and very good. Adding the pizza slicer is a definite must since the slices are huge. Great value to say the least!

Employees are very awesome and enthusiastic, great vibe in the restaurant when you walk in. Food is definitely priced right for how big the slices are and the quality definitely the quantity of the salad, not to mention the toppings are plentiful on the pizza. Would highly recommend this pizza joint for a nice quiet sit-down for any occasion. Definitely come hungry to get your grub on. 🤤

I’m from Chicago and ordered the Chicago in Feb 2022 and was pleased. I loved how they used garlic for the crust and how fresh and crisp the vegetables were. I added black olives to mine. The customer service in the restaurant was great. Will definitely be back multiple times.

Fantastic place to grab lunch. The daily lunch special of a slice and a soda is the best value. Not only that, but the pizza is the best around. Shout out to the employees. Photo attached. The slice is nearly the size of a normal piece of paper.

After 3 years of getting my hair cut next door, I finally came in to check this place out and I have mixed feelings. I liked the vibe here, it was a great deal for the portion size and flavor. I liked that you could get a custom slice, as most places that do slices are just whatever is out and made. It was just a little uneasy having this little guy the size of my fist next to the order counter...followed by a piece of moldy cucumber in my salad. I will 100% be back to give another chance, but I just hope these little details aren't overlooked in future visits

Holy moly !!!! This pizza is not only HUGE but super yummy ! The staff is wonderful. The wings were cooked perfect. I will for sure put this on my lost of favorite pizza places ! Yum

First time ordering from here and definitely not our last! This is the carnivore add ricotta and request crispy. They nailed it! So glad to find a place close by with quality over quantity! The only thing is we live a half mile from here and don't deliver but that won't hinder a 5 star rating!