Review Menemsha Galley - Menemsha

The soft serve is the best I've had. They offer dipped in chocolate , chocolate peanut butter or cherry . Two line's, one for ice cream and one for food. The line goes fast.

Follow the locals and you, too, can have a fresh and tasty meal with views like this! Place your order at the window out front with the friendly, helpful staff. Then head around back to find a table with a wonderful view of the Menemsha Basin. They also do an awesome business with their soft serve ice cream.

grabbed an ice cream and enjoyed the view

Worth trying if you are not a seafood lover, has plenty of good options (chicken, hotdog, burgers,..etc) … we tried the cheese burger and we loved it (almost 10 dollars each), u can add fries but with extra charge. We got Ice-cream with hot chocolate fudge and it was delicious. There is an indoor seating area (not really big) but the view is amazing. Its mainly take-out. Worth trying. 6 mins walking from the port.

The Menemsha Galley is exactly what you would expect from a walk up eatery in a small fishing village. Beautiful views from the back porch (try to sit on the benches to the left), and food done just right. If you're looking for gourmet, head to Edgartown to be charged more. If what you want is a quick lunch that's tasty, with fishing village atmosphere and well priced (for MV), this is your spot!

Great lobster roll! Walk around the back & grab a seat on the patio

Seasonal and super cute spot down on the water for chowder, lobster rolls, ice cream and more. Open 11-3 daily in season. Staff were super friendly and service was pretty quick even though the line was 10-15 minutes to wait and order. No matter though given the views all around! The lobster 🦞 roll was perfection with just the right touch of mayo.

Good spot, everything is simple but good. Swordfish sandwich is highly recommended. Clam chowder and lobster rolls also very good.

This is an amazing restaurant and a real staple of Chilmark. I have been getting the same order of fries and a fish sandwich here for 13 years and have yet to be disappointed by it. Would highly recommend!!!

Do yourself a favor and grab a burger with fries, sit on the porch and let the scenery wash your worries away. Bonus points if you grab a soft-serve swirl with peanutbutter crackle and walk down the dock

Had an amazing day in Menemsha. The beach is worth the drive and hike to. I def recommend spending the day here!!! A must see while on island! ❤️

They’re really great about my gluten allergy and they change their gloves and clean the machine and get fresh forks that don’t have gluten which I hadn’t thought of. The ice cream is good and the view is spectacular. We used to sit on the rocks growing up so this is a long time place to get ice cream.

Cute place for a quick bite. Diverse menu including vegan choices. Back deck is grrat spot to eat on the canal

Delicious, casually charming window-service food and ice cream. The kind of local business humans are thrilled to support.

A tradition dating back decades. Simple yet good food that you order from the window. You can eat out on their back deck or take it with you to the beach. Chowder, fish sandwiches, lobster roll, cheese burgers all great. Ice cream is good too. Ice cream frappes are excellent. Scenic back porch to watch boats and sealife. Limited parking. Watch for celebrities in line behind you.

Simply the best fried fish sandwich I have ever had. I hear that the crabcakes are awesome too.