Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill
353 Mendham Rd W, 07945-2507 - Mendham
€
American
Steakhouse
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
🥡
Takeout
🍽️
Dine-in
🚚
Delivery
🍺
Alcohol
🍹
Cocktails
🍷
Wine
📅
Reservations
♿
Wheelchair accessible
♿
Accessible restroom
😊
Casual
🛋️
Cozy
👥
Good for groups
Contact Information
📞
Phone:
+1 973-543-7675
🌐 Website:
http://www.sammyscidermill.com/
📍
Address:
353 Mendham Rd W, Mendham
📷 Photos (11+)
+3
more photos
more photos
Photo 1 / 11
100%
Google Reviews (10)
Excellent food the idea is great it just needs some updating to the Ambience
Google
I love this place and love MaryAnn. I will admit that the steaks are not as great as they used to be 30yrs ago, but its still really good. The atmosphere and tradition is what keeps us coming back. My kids love it and I grew up loving it too.
Google
Excellent steak, penne with vodka sauce, spaghetti with garlic and olive oil. You order up front and then wait in the "speakeasy" and have a drink and chat with the friendly bartender, until your meal is ready. No sign out front. Exceptional place.
Google
Great experience tonight! Greeted by the hostest (part owner) who took our steak order, then went downstairs where Woody, bartender served up drinks. Shortly after, got called up for dinner - 30oz T-bone to perfection! Service was spot on and we'll timed. A must visit to this landmark, not fancy but mouthwatering feasting spot. I'll be back with a bigger crowd next time, ty!!!
Read more
Google
One of the most unique spots! You either get it or you don't. Food is amazing and the history of the building and the family ownership is fascinating. Get shrimp scampi as an appetizer! The best soft shell crabs when they are in season. NJ sweet corn is delicious. French fries in beef tallow are the best!
Read more
Google
I came in with some close friends to celebrate my birthday. The bartender downstairs, Woody, is great! The family owned business was very fun to enjoy its history. My grandmother went there when it was a speakeasy, and my aunt grew up going there as well. So it was cool to have dinner where there was a bunch of history within those walls. The food, the food was delicious. Everything was exquisite. Thank you for a great night out!
Read more
Google
Always delicious food. Never been disappointed here! Really good place for families to come. The speakeasy downstairs where you wait before your table is ready is a fun vibe with great history as well.
Google
We've been here a few times and it's an interesting place to visit. You go anticipating long waits, usually at least an hour. The service is great and attentive once you're at the table. Food is okay, nothing mind-blowing or extraordinary. You really go for the experience.
Google
I love this place My kids brought me. I saw the comment on the "plain lettuce", well that is one of my Son's favorite things. I looked at him and said of course you love it, that how I always made it. The other is the spaghetti Di Olio, he loves that too, yup, I made it since he was little. It is amazing real food!. We ordered a bunch of stuff to share and taste, not ONE complaint!!.
Read more
Google
Fun spot if you're looking to switch things up. Place your order. Go downstairs for some games and drinks. Get called up for your dinner. Reasonably priced bottles of wine. Always enjoy my experience here!
Google
📊 Compare with Other Restaurants
| Restaurant | Score | Tripadvisor | Reviews | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Black Horse Tavern & Pub | 81% | 4.3/5 | 3.5/5 | 1,993 |
| Dante's | 81% | 4.5/5 | 4.0/5 | 248 |
| Piattino: A Neighborhood Bistro | 84% | 4.4/5 | 4.0/5 | 914 |