Review The Watermill Restaurant & Grill - Menasha

The food was delicious and the salsa so fresh and amazing! The service was excellent, very friendly and efficient. I had the enchilada/Chile relleno combo and it was enough for 2 meals! The burrito was also great. Fried ice cream and tres leches MUY BUENO! Highly recommend!

Every time I have come here the food has been amazing! The carne asada is my absolute favorite! The servers are always so sweet!

The food here is good, it does not disappoint. They have delicious grilled chicken and various Mexican snacks. The reason for 4 stars out of 5 is due to their service. I came in for ice cream and ended up waiting for 10 minutes to be served. There were various people standing around who could have assisted, however they just looked at me and never came over. I ended up leaving and going elsewhere.

So I give it a 3 stars due to the flavor I was expecting to the flavor I got. I had ordered the carnitas enchiladas w el pastor taco and posole to go....the carnitas I expected was not the flavor I got. Their carnitas have this kind of smokey BBQ flavor that you don't expect from your typical carnitas...not so much a fan..good..but not my thing.. as for the el pastors tacos ....they are good if you like pineapple and that extra sweet flavor in your pork. I prefer a hint of that sweet but also bring the heat along w flavor! ... finally as for the pozole!... now this is an item I will return for! I love my pozole and this one had EVERYTHING YOU WANT! I give that at least a 5 star!!!!! Service was slow...I had to get up several times to ask for the check a box napkins....it's a good place and they also seve ice cream! Which I didn't have....but if your into that kind of thing....

Amazing variety in foods and desserts, quick and kind service, been here many times in the past couple months and it's always an easy and pleasant experience. I have and will continue to recommend and bring friends here.

horrible service found small hairs cooked and baked to the plate and into the food. not sanitary AT ALL. they DO NOT wear gloves and its obvious they do not pay attention to what gets into drinks and food. bathroom is HORRIBLE. and beef was very dry, found a hair on my straw and red stuff in my mountain dew. never going again.

Excellent food with fast and friendly service. The food is authentic and homemade and is freshly served. Everything was delicious. The staff was courteous and knowledgeable about there product. They have amazing homemade desserts made in-house such as ice-cream and sherbert, we recommend the Oreo ice cream and Cucumber sherbert. Absolutely delicious!

It was like a meat freezer when we were there. Service was terrible.... We waited like 20-30 minutes once seated to even order. After 30 minutes of waiting for our food after ordering we told them we wanted it to go.... Way too cold in there and way too long of a wait!