Review Evelyn And Olive - Memphis

As soon as our feet crossed the threshold, we were greeted. It felt like we had come to an aunts place. Mary was the most informative and hospitable server. We ate slow, talked, laughed, and enjoyed! The lemonade was perfection. The beef patties were full of spicy flavor enveloped in a flaky pastry. The ox tails were tender and moist. It reminded me of a succulent roast packed with flavor. I had the pasta ot was packed with flavor and more than I could finish.

So for my birthday I decided to try out a spot that I saw so many good reviews about and had to give it a try. The Rasta Pasta with shrimp was so delicious with a kick of spicy! I also ordered two Jamaican Rum punch! No I didn’t drink both! lol But you will need some stronger if you’re a real drinker! But my food was hot & fresh just how I love it! I will definitely try again in the future.

Simply delicious. Had the stew chicken with rice and peas and cabbage. I will say I noticed the portion size is bigger for take out. I was also charged a 10% service fee on top of taxes. A bill went from $12 to $20+ in a heartbeat lol Server was great. The atmosphere is definitely uncomfortable if you've never been to a restaurant that has so much going on.

My son and I decided to have our weekly meet up here today and what an awesome choice it was! Being pescatarian and plant based respectively we enjoy going out on most Wednesdays and trying restaurants. There were 3 choices for vegans/vegetarians excluding sides, at E&O. My son had the potato/chickpea curry with a side of greens and rice. It sounded tempting but I went for the black bean tacos served with rice and a tomato & cucumber salad. I have lots of taco experience under my belt before going plant based from Memphis to 5 years in San Antonio. This was THE best tacos I have EVER had. I've had some seriously delicious street tacos but man, this was an altogether different and glorious experience. I cleared my plate, which is odd for me. We also ordered adult beverages. I took my Jamaican Lemonade to go because I was driving. She made it without ice so I am able to have it now at 6:30 pm as I write this. Again, a great experience with properly made drinks. I do look forward to the Jamican Punch but they were out today. Our meals were $10.90 each. A reasonable price for a big meal these days.

I love this place! This was my 1st, but definitely not last visit. The taste is almost authentic to Jamaican food. I had the Jerk infused burger 😋. My co-workers ordered the Rasta Pasta, Jerk Chicken Pasta & Grilled Chicken wrap. Everyone was more than satisfied. Our waiter, Corey, was really nice & attentive. I can't wait to go back. We went during lunch hours (Memphis downtown dinning) & it was not crowded. The prices are not expensive at all. I highly recommend this restaurant

My husband was celebrating his 40th birthday and Evelyn & Olive was very accommodating to our large party. The food and drinks were delicious!! I highly recommend the beef patty as an appetizer. I felt like I was back in the islands once I took a bite. Darrin is an incredible host. He took the time to thoroughly explain my options for making a reservation for a large party. He took care of us the day of our reservation and everyone loved him.

So my first time trying Caribbean food and I must say that I am impressed. I’ve heard about E&O for a while now and finally had the chance to try it. The appetizers was a Jamaican meat pie, very similar to an empanada with a different shape. The crust, was perfect, flaky and brown as perfect as could be. The flavor inside of the meat pie was definitely explosive. I was shocked it was amazing. Next up.. the salmon cakes. I did enjoy them they remind me of Down south Salmon croquettes but they were fried. On the menu for some reason they didn’t indicate that they were friend salmon cakes BUT nevertheless they were delicious and I was definitely happy about my decision. The grits were creamy and delicious. Last up is the main course what they are known for is the oxtails!!! The oxtails were so tender, the gravy was mouthwatering and the side items were just beautiful. They paired them perfectly with the plethora of seasonings and I couldn’t be anymore happy. I can’t wait to visit again

Got to visit the place for first time after hearing about it for years, and totally loved it!! We went to this restaurant on a Friday night. It was totally busy, but the servers were attentive. After couple of minutes of waiting, we were showed to our table. Our server was friendly and provided good recommendations on the items to be ordered based on our preferences. Her recommendations were superb! We ordered Jamaican Jerk chicken and Rasta Pasta. I loved the flavors of Jamaican Jerk chicken, it was spicy and on the same note it was sweet too. The contrasting flavors were a perfect blend. Rasta Pasta had a different note of flavor than the pasta which I had in a Italian restaurants. Some Jamaican spices were added to pasta and they complimented the pasta well. I like spicy food, so I enjoyed the food to the fullest. Do not forget to try their deserts- cream cheese pound cake. It was a delight to my sweet tooth!

To-go pickup The food was very flavorful and very tasty. However, every bite of my chicken curry had a bone in it, just be very careful eating this wonderful spiced dish. Pineapple slaw has a unique taste profile that keeps me coming back to kill the heat a tad. The meat pie and plantain are just the best.

Super friendly staff and personable. Efficient service. Ordered the potato and chickpea curry. So delicious. Comfort food- felt so full after. Very affordable. Plenty of vegan and vegetarian options. Would definitely return while in Memphis. Seated immediately on Thursday night- not too busy.

This place was amazing!! The people were nice and service was good. They were considerate and the food was amazingly good. Meat tender and everything cooked to perfection. Cocktails were also good.

I had a wonderful time 3/18/17. The service was excellent and the atmosphere was cozy. Ms. Donna was so friendly and helpful. All of the staff were very professional. The food was absolutely delicious. I had the Curry Chicken with extra Scotch Bonnet, Callaloo and fish fritters! My Jamaican Rum punch reminded me of my trip to Montego Bay. I will definitely be going back.

Love Love Love Evelyn & Olive!! I love authentic Jamaican cuisine and they never disappoint! My friend never tried oxtails before so I suggested E&O to her, so we went on a Wednesday evening about 6:30 the vibe is always chill the music good, and the food was top tier!! I love Jamaican food so I had my friend try the oxtails and curry goat both were Bomb very well seasoned, nice portions to have you full, just overall comfort food! Love their cabbage so delicious they didn’t have any brown stew chicken today but if you come please try it, it’s so good! The curry goat is spicy but I love it, the oxtails were falling off the bone good all the food we ordered was great! Their drinks are on point, My friend had a Jamaican Rum Punch and I had an Island Lemonade(the silent killer) it’s the strongest drink they have soooooooo amazing! If you’re looking for authentic Jamaican Cuisine you have to try Evelyn Olive!!!! The waitress/bartender was sooo cool and funny!!

First, let me say, the food is GOOD. I frequented this establishment multiple times before the pandemic and was never disappointed. My go to is always the oxtails plate, fried green tomatoes and rum punch - it never misses. This is my first time going under the leadership of new owneers/managers and my time there was great. I will say that the building can use a little TLC, but it doesn't take away from the experience and the great cuisne you get from Evelyn & Olive. We love Darren and he always makes sure we are taken care of. You can tell that the staff there has built relationships outside of the workplace (maybe they are family) so you get some good engergy while youre there. Tables are spaced out enough so that you feel comfortable where you sit and the staff does wear their masks. 5 stars!

Best damn oxtail I have EVER had and the plate lasted me my whole 12hr shift. I literally go there two time's a week

A simply amazing place! Friendly staff and the food is excellent!! Best rice and peas I've ever had, and the catfish and grits is outstanding - savory and spicy catfish, and the grits are indescribably delicious, best I've ever had! Nice drink selection too. :)

I had a wonderful meal tonight. I have truly enjoyed every meal I have ever had here. Tonight, I had the Oxtails prepared of course Jamaican-style. Very delicious. I enjoyed Red Stripe beer with my meal, and it was made even more delicious by being served in an ice-cold glass. The Jama Jama is excellent. The Callilou is a delicious vegetable that I doubt you can find elsewhere in Memphis. The rice and peas is always delicious. I have had the Fish Stew in the past. Very delicious. Our waitress was womderful. Very nice and provided what was just the right amount of attentiveness. I want to try more of the dishes. I know I won’t be disappointed. I know everything will be delicious. I also like the comfortable ambience of Evelyn and Olive. Philip

My husband and I ate here for the first time tonight, and from the minute we walked in, we felt welcomed and valued. The staff showed pride in their service and were warm and friendly. And the food was EXCELLENT, with great flavors at a reasonable price. Our server was very knowledgeable and helpful, and the owner actually came and greeted us! Will definitely be back! Our new favorite place!

I always enjoy my food when we visit. The fried asparagus, salt and pepper shrimp, fish and grits, and oxtails are delicious. The atmosphere is cozy and the staff is great.

A hidden jewel in #greatermemphis. When I came back from Jamaica, I wanted to keep that taste going and luckily E & O had just opened. I was greatly impressed. I try to come every Friday just to have their ox-tails. Good Lawrd!!!! Thankful. If you haven’t been, you are missing out.

The food was wonderful, the wait staff were very personable and knowledgeable about the menu items.

Great food and service! I highly recommend this place to anyone who wants to visit Memphis Tennessee!

The food was amazing and the atmosphere was even better! They had some of the best grits I’ve ever tasted!!

It was my first time eating here and it was the worst experience I've EVER had eating out! I was conflicted about what to eat so I asked for assistance through our waitress. She explained that the Shrimp and jerk chicken came with 7 pieces of chicken and shrimp. I took her word and ordered this meal but it only came with 3 wings, 3 pieces of shrimp and a hush puppy. We asked the waitress about the issue and she said she thought I was asking about something else. I was confused when she said this because I pointed at the menu when I ordered. She went and lied to her manager (who should've never been appointed that position) that I misunderstood what she was saying and they don't exchange orders. I asked for the manager only for him to tell me that he does not believe that his waitress made the error and that he was not going to fix it. He went on to say that if we wanted the additional wings we would have to order and pay for them. We told him that his waitress told us that it comes with 7 pieces of chicken so he should honor what she stated. He called her over and she agreed that she told us this and that when I pointed to the menu she wasn't paying attention and she thought I was talking about something else. How are you a waitress and you are "not paying attention to the customer"? She went on to yell and throw her hands us saying I'm sorry and walked away. The manager yelled to her "it's ok". He allowed for her to not only state she made the error but to yell and walk away from the conversation and still not correct the issue. This was the worst customer service I've ever experienced not only from a waiter/waitress but from a "manager". I will never eat here EVER AGAIN.

Excellent food and excellent service. It's a hidden gem!

Food was delicious!!! Asparagus, salt and pepper shrimp, jerk chicken, fried green tomatoes and Jamaican Lemonade was awesome!! My first visit will not be my last!!

The food was delicious, drinks and customer service was awesome as well. I’ve added them to my top 5 fav’s in Memphis

Food was delicious!!! Service was great as well! Would definitely recommend!

The jama jama and fish cake fritters are perfect for lunch! Also, their bread pudding is simply divine! Friendly staff mixed with Jamaican music makes for a grand experience.

Not to happy with Wait time. Waitress was short, fried.asparagus wasn't good. Had brown stew chicken. Chicken was on point, rice was Hard peas okay.