The best Cheesecakes in Mayville | Sluurpy updated in June

The Sweet Spot

90/100 (141 ratings)

Restaurants

American

Soups

Vegan Options

Cafe

Vegan Options

Dinner

Lunch

Sandwiches

Cheesecakes

Ice Cream

"Everything about the Sweet Spot is 5 stars!! The food is all homemade and out of this world!! Nothing but the best for their customers! Definitely..."

Rachel Burdett Kneer

"Great food! The salad was so yummy and fresh!! The staff is so sweet and kind. Love the products available for purchase and the cookies were well..."

Sara Kleinschrodt

"An amazing place to lunch in Mayville, NY with great people, great food and friendly service. And when I say great food, each dish is entirely..."

Susan Burkhouse Giannantonio

"Best lunch spot! Their food and baked goods are to die for! It's a cute and quiet place nestled in the heart of Mayville, I would recommend anyone to..."

Holly Whitermore

"One of the best around. Great staff, great..."

Neil Johnson

"If you want great hospitality, fresh food, delicious desserts and a fun place to visit - The Sweet Spot is the place to go!! Love this place..."

Lori Nelson Studley

"One of my favorite places in Mayville. Yummy food, great service, and good prices. A must stop and check out when in..."

Sorena Delcamp Gilkinson

"I think the Sweet Spot is one of the best places on Chautauqua Lake. The owners and employees have always given exemplary service. I would recommend..."

Michael Brown

"Love the Rosie's Sugar Cookies, paninies and staff. Great place to eat! You can tell a lot of care goes into the food..."

Megan Arnone

"Fantastic food made with high quality ingredients. The staff is friendly, prompt, and courteous, making sure that the customer is satisfied. The..."

Christopher Myers

"It's the BEST place ever!!! Lunch is always wonderful and if you are full afterwards, trust me, get dessert to..."

Susan Gressley Hurley

"The best cookies I ever ate ! If you once ate a cookie which was perfect it was probably made there !..."

Théo Zimmermann

"We drive once a week to mayville (20 miles )for baked goods and cheesecakes . The food and service is..."

Sheila Myers

"Forget the cheescake chains....Darlene has THEE BEST cheesecake hands down. Had pumpkin cheesecake for Thanksgiving instead of pie!!!! Yum!!! Also..."

Tammy Cosentino Schack

"Perfect name for a perfect place. I LOVE excellent food from an excellent small business owner. The place is a unique old repurposed building which..."

Tammy Schack

"Delicious food at reasonable prices! If your ever in the area I HIGHLY recommend this place, I had the cranberry mandarin chicken wrap and it was out..."

laura pascell

"My wife and I stopped in the morning of July 5 to purchase some muffins and whatever other breakfast pastries we could find to bring back to our..."

Rick Sullivan

"The food is delicious. The building is really neat. The owner and staff are wonderful and so friendly. They know most of their customers by name...."

Kelly Drago Amatuzzo

"YUMMMMM a gem of Erie! I dropped in here to look around and came back for lunch and some road snacks! The turkey club is SO tasty and the sweet pot..."

E. Blakely

"I have yet to find something I don't like on the menu. The tuna melt on multigrain with black eyed pea salad is my favorite! If you haven't tried..."

Adrienne Myers

"Wonderful folks with wonderful food..and interesting gifts..some hand made by the owner’s mother! Absolutely spotless! Fabulous cookies, muffins,..."

Francine Pokracki

"Excellent food and baked goods in good portions at fair prices. Nice little unique gift shop and friendly..."

Pamela Morgan

"it was great but we were actually at the mayville diner lol. had a great steak n eggs and the service was..."

Brandon Cessna

"Great food and friendly service every single time I go. I definitely recommended ordering from..."

Reset

There is only one restaurant

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Cheesecakes in Mayville

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters