A wonderful little Greek shop that belongs in the cover of a magazine; everything inside is so perfectly displayed from the traditional Greek souvenirs to the fresh cookies, natural soaps and assortment of cheeses. The owner is so sweet, attentive and helpful, walking into this shop brings a little bit of Greece into your heart. You will leave with a warm fuzzy feeling and a nostalgia for the Aegean sea. Try a Frappe (iced coffee) and some cheese pies, delicious!!!!
Such a wonderful and friendly little market! The very best Kalamata olives, cheese cake, organic olive oils, not to mention fresh dried herbs straight from Greece. And the spanakopita is delicious - handy for a crowd. The Greeks know a thing or two about excellent food, plus last I looked there were stylish cotton beach covers as well - better snap them up!
I was having trouble finding red egg dye for our traditional Greek Easter Eggs. The generous person I spoke with was able to mail me a packet. I am grateful and will be visiting this wonderful establishment soon. Thank you!
Five types of Fetta?! Who knew? I didn't but staff was accommodating and quick to explain everything and offer suggestions. Cheese & sweets, two of my favorite things were both homemade and excellent. Cute Greek gift shop in the back. Had a real neighbor feel to it that takes you back to shops of old.
Wonderful authentic Greek market with a great range of products. Hot spanakopita ready to eat! And all of the Greek cheeses, too!
The owners Joan and Tony are the kindest and most helpful, sincere people. Their items are always fresh, first rate quality, authentic Greek and great variety. I love the Agora Greek Market in Mattituck. I highly recommend it!
Awesome pastry shop if you love Greece. Bring home the flavors of Greece with homemade desserts..freshly made daily, olives, chese and specialty items from Greece. I recommend this place! Family owned..
Amazing Feta, Spanikopita, Baklava, Olives (I get the oil-cured, Chios-style). And I'm sure everything else there is delicious!! Love this place, and I am a Greek girl that knows her Greek foods!
Excellent store and friendly service. Wide variety of products from delicious feta cheeses, Greek pastries, olive varieties to wonderful smelling soaps and household items. Highly recommend. Definitely a hidden gem.
Great little store serving up the Greek essentials, from canned and jarred goods to fresh cheeses, baked goods and some refrigerated and frozen as well. A pretty comprehensive set of goods given the small footprint, as well as attentive service from the staff.
Wonderful food and great gift items! I love the clothing and jewelry and unique hand crafted creations! Food is delicious! Joanne and Tony are fabulous!!
Feta cheese is incredible! Olives are like I've never had before. Olive oil soap was just what my skin needed. Can't wait to go back. This is the real deal.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Mattituck
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes