The Original Papa Nicks Take Out

I recommend ordering their Cauliflower Crust option for a less-filling meal; green peppers, mushrooms, and feta cheese! I had to take one star from the 'Service' category because the estimated pickup time is never right. In fact, if you leave your home (depending on where you live) at the time your order is "ready for pickup" you'll likely arrive at the appropriate time. Typically I find my order is ready 10(ish) minutes past the est. time. This doesn't stop me for ordering and eating their delicious food, I just account for the extra time in our dinner plans. Thank you Papa Nick!

My nostalgia for this place is definitely biasing my review, but Papa Nick's has been here ever since I moved here. Never once had a problem with getting the takeout. The people there often do very well with attention to detail. I think the fact that they have been here so long is indicative of at least something that they are doing right. Better than a lot of pizza places when it comes to food and pricing.

Love the pizza except our friends asked for there's Well-done, it was not (it was very busy when we went on a Friday, they didn't want to wait any longer to return it). Our side salad was disappointing for $5, small handful of lettuce, 2 small slices of cuc and 1/2 slice of tomato (drenched in dressing). Atmosphere was great but very loud when they are busy. Garlic rolls are extremely garlicky.