Melissa Jamerson
I'm from Virginia and with this being my first Connecticut pizza, I was impressed. I love the thin crust and the flavor of the sauce was so good! I liked that you picked up your to go food at the window and didn't have to go inside.
Zaja Bure
This is the best pizza outside of New Haven , and better than most of New Haven. Amato is the man! Madison is so lucky he carried on his family’s tradition and recipes and brought a real Apizza place to town. Everything else in the area is garbage, this is the only real apizza place to go to! & the Eggplant Parm is award winning!
Jake Barrios
The pizza here is so delicious! Tried the clams casino pizza and was very impressed. Amato’s pizza is the best around and I would highly recommend giving it a try, if you haven’t already!
Eric Miller
Their basic pizzas are great in their own, but its their specialty pizzas that grab you. Specifically their Chipotle Chicken Pizza is amazing. Just the right amount of spice. Highly recommend. Order early because they get busy!
Stephanie Katz Wiernik
BEST OF THE BEST! Hands down the most delicious PIZZA on the shoreline if not EVER!
Found this little spot when my husband and I first moved to the area in 2020, and we haven’t been able to stop enjoying their delicious pizza ever since. It’s our go to every time people visit! Our favorites are their Napolitano and regular cheese w meatballs and black olives (well done)! We’ve also had the salads, mozzarella sticks, the cannolis, cheesecake, veggie pizza, everything is incredible! They recently started selling their sauce and I’ll tell you this, I’ll never by store bought ever again! Amato’s sauce is unbelievable!
We love Amato and Jordyn as well. Super friendly and always have a smile on their face.
A favorite spot in town — worth the quick drive over from main st.
LOVE LOVE LOVE
Rolando Melendez
The pizza is incredible! Its thin type pizza which I enjoy. The sauce is so delicious, the cheese is of higher quality than the average. Fresh dough, and a good crunch to the crust. The prices are very good as well. Cheaper than the other local pizza places which is smart if they want to keep up with B-wall and Grand. Definitely going here again!
Dick Evarts
Yummy pizzas and Wonderful people. Best local pizzaria.
Alvaro Correa
Small and friendly place with good pizza. The crust is very good and the flavors don't disappoint.
I had a little trouble using the online ordering for the first time but I logged out and then back in and worked well.
Is always great to know you don't have to go far to get far to get good pizza.
Will be back.
Tom Davis
Wow, great pizza! Can’t wait to try out the rest of the menu. Reminded me of when I was a kid, eating Pepe & Rose pizza after baseball games. #StartSpreadingTheNews there’s a new pizza place in town!
Anne Livecchi Marrinan
My new favorite place! Excellent pizza, New Haven style. Mashed potato pizza is awesome! Highly recommend to anyone looking for good, traditional Italian cooking.
Dean Fradiani
Great food and pizza. Drive down from Wallingford for the pizza and the vodka sauce is to die for.
Jill Huber Lee
Absolutely delicious! Their plain mozz pie is great, crispy crust and a sauce and you can actually taste the seasoning in. This past week we ordered eggplant rolatini...holy crap. The ricotta was so creamy and the eggplant was perfectly breaded and cooked. I’m so happy they opened near us!
Lorrie Ozimek
We finally tried your pizza and doubt we’ll go anywhere else again! Phenomenal pizza - I’m a Jersey girl and have had the best! This is right up there!! Thank you!
Amy Okamoto
Excellent pizza and desserts! Modern decor and clean eat in or take out. So conveniently located. We will be trying many items from their extensive menu.
Debra Malicki Longyear
I stopped here a few days ago to order a few dinner trays from Amato, and sampled some of the most delicious meatballs I’ve had in years! Looking forward to this coming Sunday for a wonderful meal with family and friends! Thanks Amato!
John A. Nikolatos
I stopped in for a quick bite. Ordered a sub.. and was going to eat half and save half.. ate the whole thing!! Delicious.
Tara DeMarseilles Slowik
Incredible food, and most importantly incredible customer service!
Adrian S. Price
Best Pizza outside of New Haven! Amazing! Love the Amato's Special!
Ralph Pietrosimone
The only thing better than the food is the family!
Wendy Jean Hackett
Tried the Sicilian Pizza last night and it was delicious!!
Joe Pastore
Good Italian food at a fair price, very clean establishment and very pleasant staff, I will definitely return
Nancy Redding
The Best Pizza And Italian Restaurant Around! Try It Out! You Will Love It!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes