Justin Williams
Tried this for the first time today and I am a fan! The half size is perfect for lunch and it’s extremely affordable compared to other options around the square. I had the spicy traditional and it was perfect. Paired it with the their hot sauce for a little extra bite and now I’m pleasantly full. Didn’t get a picture because it looked so good and I was hungry.
Will 1,000% be back again soon.
John Hermida
I absolutely love this place. The owner and employees are always so kind and personable. Every time I'm in Madison I stop by for a pasty and always bring some home. The best pasties I've ever had and my favorite breakfast in Madison.
Patrick Mahoney
My childhood favorite!!!! Still amazing after all these years! I sadly don't get my pasty fix as much as when I lived downtown and in school but I try to swing in as much as I can. The spicy tradition is my fav but you really can't go wrong with any. I tell any friends or family who visit from out of town that it is a Madison must stop. Thanks for going strong for all these years🙂
Felicia
Had a delightful encounter with the workers who were super friendly and helpful! We tried 4 different pasty’s and they were all really tasty in their own ways. Also had a chocolate chip oatmeal cookie made by the owners mom, which I would recommend to finish off your meal!
JJ C
First time I came here was a while ago, got the original and it was horrible. I come back today and get one that has flavor and it is instantly reason to return regularly. $5 for an easy to eat and carry meal that is satisfying and calorie dense is unbeatable in a touristy area, I reccomend it to anyone local or not who has yet to try it
Janmesh Patel
This is a great business, run by even more terrific people. I’m vegetarian so I always get either the sweet potato or veggie wedgie and both taste amazing. The food is always warm and fresh. I even like to buy some uncooked wedgies to take home and bake later!
Brendan Conaway
I'm from the Upper Peninsula, where we can get pretty critical of pasties. I waited years in Madison before giving Teddywedgers a try and I wished I had sooner!! Very happy with what I'm tasting and I'll be back :)
PERNELL F. BROWN
Bland food no seasoning. Not enough meat inside the Pasty. Reynold's Pastries in Milwaukee will put this place to shame!
Casey Buell
I frequented the shop when it was run by the original owner, through when his partner took over, and I am ecstatic the current owners have kept it going while maintaining the high quality of the food. The variety of amazing pasties means you will never have to settle into a routine, and every option is delicious. The expanded hours later in the week make it much easier to get your fix if you work a normal schedule as well and can't pop in between college classes. I recommend this place to everyone I know and will continue to do so.
Christina Marie Caudillo
Loving this pot pie right now! Friendly and nice looking guy at the counter as well ��
Amanda K. Vang-Lee
Definitely recommend trying this place out. The wedgers are baked amazingly and the staffs are totally cool. Came in for a light lunch and got a spiced,fulfilled stomach!
James R Hillenburg Jr.
Everyone is so nice, Pasties are delicious, Thank you, for everything you do!! It's a new tradition, when we're in Madison, WS!
Ross SaintRossy
Brilliant place....great food and friendly service
Chris Crofoot
Best pie in the state, great customer service, cozy atmosphere.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes