Sluurpy > Restaurants in Madison > Conneaut Pizza And Subs

Conneaut Pizza And Subs - Madison - Photo album

I know the Stromboli was the highlight of this place. The other foods were really good though. Wings. Good. Appetizers. Good. Pizza. Good. Did have a burger was not the greatest though but edible. Did have to wait a while but they were busy so that's ok. Came here a year ago and it was bad but most

Food rules so even the outdated atmosphere is whatever. Seemed clean, just outdated. Was busy while I was there with pickup orders consistently flowing.

Our experience was excellent the shop is clean the waitresses / cashier cook all polite. The Stromboli is as good today as it was 38/40 years ago...

Always get Salads and Steak and mushroom subs from here. Still the best after 25 years 😆

Best jalapeno poppers I've ever had

They have the best Stromboli and wings. 💯

I've been here twice in the last year (only because I live 100 miles away). Each time was a good experience. Friendly customer service and good food at a reasonable price. The Philly steak sandwich is very good.

The biggest and best stromboli for your money. It's always cooked perfectly and fully loaded with any toppings you request. Great tasting marinara sauce on the side, add a salad and it makes a excellent meal. Always had fast friendly service with a smile. Keep doing what you do. Thank you.

Service was fast and pleasant. The food was all right, but nothing largely impressive. For a local dive of a spot, this place is pretty good. Building front is hard to spot from the road, so keep your eyes peeled. Great portions for the price. We enjoyed our visit and will most likely be back.

Best stromboli and pizzas I've EVER had across the US. Wow! We bought several and traveled with them all the way back to Florida they were so outstanding. Staff is also friendly. My only regret is that we don't have this gem closer to home.