Sluurpy > Restaurants in Mackinaw City > Mackinaw Pastie & Cookie Co.

Review Mackinaw Pastie & Cookie Co. - Mackinaw City

Amber Connell
The best pasties in Mackinaw City! There's almost always a wait during peak times so plan accordingly. You can buy hot pasties or frozen to take home and bake later. We got the traditional beef pastie meal with coleslaw and a cookie. Everything was fantastic. There's a small sitting area in the restaurant or you can take your food to go. We went to a nearby park to eat.
Rita Clark
Definitely happy we gave them a try! Excellent service Excellent food, fresh, hot, and delicious. We came back for seconds. Pastry was light but tasty. Not to thick that it makes the Pastie. The Gravy was flavorful but not to heavy or over spiced. We will be returning. CoVid friendly, clean, and seating area was welcoming. Restrooms were clean and cared for.
Starla Akers
So good! My first pastie ever and I was very pleased. They're pretty big and I couldn't finish my stroganoff pastie but I'd definitely recommend this place
Melissa G.
Yummy lunch to go. It was packed well and still hot and delicious.
Sara Ankerson
Delicious Pasties and yummy cookies. We stopped in and got was ready in less than 5 minutes, we ate at the picnic tables in the back. Ordered Beef pasties with gravy, and kids cheese ravioli.
Terri Woodhams
We found this place on our color tour and return each chance we get to buy their pasties. They are the best. It was lined up to order pasties but the line moved quickly. The restaurant is very small but you can eat there or buy frozen pasties to go. We buy a hot meal to go and buy several frozen to enjoy later. Their breakfast pasties are so good as well as their stroganoff, chicken, traditional beef and veggies and cheese. Highly recommend.
Laura Hickey
Great pasties! Like pasties I have always had. Diced potatoes and carrots, beef or chicken, with chicken gravy for the chicken pasties and beef gravy for the beef pasties the way we like em'!
Crystal C
I have had many pasties in my life but these are by far the best ever. They taste homemade (not frozen) with a thin flakey crust.
Dennis Mirto
If you are longing for the real deal these pasties are it. We love the beef pasties but didn't really care for the gravy. Great for a quick meal and since the restaurant across the street doesn't do take out this place provides the solution for ones on the go.
fran laughlin
Very good beef pasty with gravy and nice flaky crust. One was plenty to share! We also purchased some frozen pasties to bring home. This place has a cozy log cabin vibe and friendly employees.
Marlisa Smith
We had a veggie pastie….. hot with sour cream! It was DELICIOUS!!! The cole slaw was also good!!! We will be back!!
Fancy Spider
Super fast and friendly service. Rustic "cabin like" interior which gives you the "up North" vibe. Pretty interesting pastie options, I went for the El Grande with taco sauce, cheese, and sour cream and it was really good! I also got a taste of my wife's classic pastie which is always a staple. Delicious pasties and do not suffer from the "bland and dry" effect that I feel like a lot of pasties fall down into.
Christi Jones
They had construction going on so we had to take it to go but it was hot and delicious and the staff was friendly!
Clyde Tompkins
Not the largest area for customers in the world but… they make up for it with great food. Love the cookies as well as good customer service. I’ve been here many times and I Keep coming back.
Alan Neumann
Last stop for lunch on way out of Mackinaw. Had to try one, they were great! Kids said one of best meals we had all week. We tried the stroganoff, with gravy and sour cream. The cookies are the best too!
Michelle Little
The food was really good. The pastie was hot but not dry and the filling was great. Everything was cooked nicely without being over cooked. The service was great and the employee was very friendly. It was clean. The cookies were delicious.
Ralph Amato
Very cool history of the Pastie and how it came to been. Nice selection of books from local authors. The pasties are hot and tasty. You can get gravey on the side or topped 3 different ways to meet you taste preference.
Michelle Ounanian
The best pastie I've ever had. Meaty. Perfectly cubed veg. Awesome thinner crust. I even like the weird way they fold it...
1 2 lb Flame Thrower Grillburger 1 Slice of Meat & Dry Cloe Slaw Tacol 4 Cheese Lasagna Alfredo Almond Croissant Apple pie Arancini Asst Juices Avocado Toast & Fruit Bacon Mushroom Pizza Bagels Baked Beans Banana Pancakes and Blueberry Pancakes Bananas Foster Bangers And Mash Basket of Mini Tacos BBQ Chicken Pizza BBQ Combo Plate BBQ Nachos Beef Beef and Chicken Beef and Veggie Pasties Beef Pastie with Gravy Meal Beef Pasty with Gravy Beef Stroganoff Meal Beef Stroganoff Pastor Meal Big Mac Donut Biryani Biscuits and Gravy Biscuits and gravy Black Bean Burger Black Cherry Ice Cream Blackened Whitefish BLT Blue Lagoon Blueberry Pastry Boneless Wings Bourbon Chicken Sandwich Bowl of Whitefish Chowder Bread Bowl of Chili Bread Sticks Breadsticks with Cheese Breakfast Pastie Breakfast Sandwich Breakfast Sandwich Bagel Breakfast sandwiches Brisket & Pulled Pork Tacos Brisket Sandwich Broiled Whitefish Brownie and Oreo Cupfection Bruschetta Bread Bud Light Buffalo Chicken Pizza Buffalo Wings Burger Burrito Café Mocha Cafe Mocha Latte Cajun Whitefish Cake Batter Ice Cream Cakes Calamares Calamari Calamari Fritti Calzone Cannoli Caprese Salad Caramel Corn Carmel Cinnamon Roll Cheboygan Blood Orange Honey Beer Cheese Danish Cheese Pizza with Jalapenos Olives Cheese Ravioli Cheeseburger Cheesecake Cheesecakes Cheesesteak Cheesy Bread Chef's Breakfast Cherry Pie a La Mode Chicago Dog Chicken Alfredo Chicken Alfredo chicken caesar salad Chicken Drunken Noodles Chicken Fingers Chicken Lo Mein Chicken noodle soup Chicken Pad Thai Chicken Parmazeti Pizza with Bacon Added and Cheese Sticks Chicken Parmesan Chicken Parmesan Chicken Parmigiano Chicken Pastie Combo Chicken Sandwich Chicken Sandwich Sub Chicken SPI Rolls Chicken Wings Chili Chocolate Fudge Chocolate Long John Chowder Cider Cinnamon French Toast Cinnamon Roll French Toast Clam Chowder Clean and Fresh Coconut Cream Pie Coconut Milk Tea Boba Coconut Shrimp Cod Cod Chowder Cold Beer Corn dogs Corned Beef Crab Crab Cake Crab Legs Crab Meat Rangoon's Crostini Curry Dinner - Whitefish With Dinner buffet Drunken Chicken Noodles with Vegetables Escargot Everything Bagel Breakfast Sandwich Fajitas Fettuccine Alfredo Fettuccine Alfredo with Shrimp Fettucine Alfredo Filet Mignon Fish Fish & Chips Fish & Chips Fish and Chips Fish and Crab Rangoon Fish Fry Fish Sandwich Fish Sandwich Fish Taco Flight of Beer Frekce Fries French Fries French Fries French Toast French Toast Breakfast and a Side of Sausage Links Fresh Fruit Bowl Fried chicken Fried pickles Fried Pork Dumplings Fried Pretzel Bites Fried White Fish Basket Frog Legs Fruit and Cereal Gang Curry Thai Red Curry w Tofu or Veggie Gang Peanut Curry Garlic bread Gelato Gluten Free Pizza Gnocchi Alla Sorrentina Gourmet Cookie Grilled Cheese with Fries and Applesauce Grilled Chicken Sandwich Ham & Pineapple Pizza Ham and Egg Ham Egg and Cheese Croissant Sandwich Hamburger Hamburgers Hanging Bavarian Pretzel Hawaiian Mimosa Hawaiian Pizza Meat Lovers Pizza Homemade Bread Honey Sriracha Ahi hot chocolate Hot Dog Hot Turkey Sandwich Hot wings House Bloody Mary Ice Cream Iced tea Italiano Pastie with Coleslaw Salad Java Chip Frappuccino Juice Juice & Smoothies Kids Butter Noodles Kraft Macaroni & Cheese Lake Perch Lamb chops Large Pizza Large Pizza with Pepperoni and Extra Cheese Lasagne Latte Lemon Meringue Pie Lobster Lobster Mac & Cheese Lobster Poutine Lobster Ravioli Alla Vodka Seafood Portofino Lobster Roll Lobster Roll Loco Moco Mac and cheese Mackinac Island Fudge Meatballs Meatloaf Meatzza Medium Chicken Bacon Ranch Meringue Michigan Salad Minestrone soup Mochi moscow mule mozzarella sticks Mussels Mussels Fra Diavolo Nacho Supreme Nachos Nachos Nachos Deluxe Noodle Nutty Donuts Oatmeal Butterscotch Pie Omelette Orange chicken Original Beef Our Traditional Beef Pastie Oyster Pad Park Garlic Pad Thai Pad Thai Noodles Pancakes Parmesan Encrusted Walleye Pasta Pastie Grande Patrolman's Special Pizza Pecan pie Penne Primavera Pepper Steak Pepperoni Mushroom Extra Cheese Pepperoni Pizza Perch Dinner Pineapple Fried Rice w Tofu or Veggie Pita Bread pizza bowl Pizza Buffet PIZZAS popcorn Porky Burger Porterhouse Steak Pot Roast Sandwich Potato Skins Poutine Pretzel Pretzel Bites Pulled Pork Grilled Cheese Reuben sandwich Reuben Sandwich Ribs Roast Beef Ruben S'More Donut S'Mores Frappe Salad Salmon Salted Caramel Apple Sandwiches Sausage & Bacon Pizza Scallops Seafood chowder Seafood Puttanesca Shrimp Shrimp Basket Shrimp Teriyaki Bowl Side Garden Salad Side of Onion Rings Side Salad Single Filet with Fries and Coleslaw Small Pepperoni & Sausage Pizza Small Vanilla Cone with Sprinkles Smoked Chicken Wings Smoked Wings Smothered Chicken and Mashed Potatoes with Gravy Spaghetti Steak Eggs and Taters Steak Gorgonzola Alfredo Strawberry Rhubarb Pie Stroganoff Pasty Sugar Cookie Surf & Turf Sweet Heat Pizza Sweet Potato Taco Fries with Cheese Taco Pizza Taco salad Tacos Tapas Tartar Sauce Tea Thai Shrimp Salad Their Beer Thick Brown Sugar Bacon Toasts Tofu Drunken Noodles Turkey and Swiss Croissant Sandwich Turkey Sandwich Turkey Sandwich Vegetarian omelette Veggie Parmesan Veggie Skillet with Poached Eggs Waffle Fries Waffles Waffles & Crepes Walleye Fries Coleslaw Hush Puppies with Tartersauce Western Depot Burger Combo Western Omelette Wet Burrito White Fish Basket White Fish Dinner White Truffle Fries Whitefish 3 Pieces Whitefish Fingers Whitefish Sandwich Wings Wings and Puzza Wood Fired Pizza
Share on WhastApp
Share on Facebook
Browse the menu
Add review