4 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"Although our family has been coming to Mackinac for several years, I just discovered the outdoor bar. My son and I had a great time watching the..."
David Fine
"My husband and I ate at the Pink Pony on our last night on vacation and we had JD as our server. We ate out every night on the island and we have to..."
Lydia Jones
"We’ve eaten at the Pink Pony twice now and it’s been fantastic each time. I had the apple salad (can’t remember it’s exact name) but it was..."
Denise Bolton-Bjorge
"The food was so amazingly delicious! We had the Chippewa Broiled Whitefish and the Smoked Whitefish Dip. Highly recommend. Fresh fish cooked to..."
Maria Bowles
"I frequent the island often and took my two girlfriends for the weekend. We ate dinner at the Pony and my friends were truly impressed, as I always..."
Christine Newell Woodson
"First time trying The Pink Pony and we were not disappointed. We had appetizers ( calamari and white fish fingers) and crocks of French onion soup...."
Tina Marie Czarnecki
"Four of us had lunch at the bar yesterday with a very friendly bartender from Newport Beach. The service was great and the food was delicious! And,..."
Norine Hrechko Colletti
"Had my first Mac Island experience this past Wednesday after living in Gaylord for the past 7 years and we made the Pony our choice for dinner after..."
Craig Connolly
"We loved the Pink Pony. We stopped there each day on our 3 days on the island. Super friendly staff, the Pink Pony Punch is delicious and the..."
Michelle Newman Owens
"We spent all day docked here and they were wonderful to us! So much fun, great atmosphere, and awesome staff! Thank you for making our first boating..."
Amy Lynn Smith
"Great drinks! Friendly service. Fun gift shop and loved the theme and live..."
Linda Chase
"We had a great time in the bar area for dinner and on the patio for drinks! Rum Runners are a..."
Amber Sue
"I went here right after I got off the boat. No waiting to sit even though it was very busy. Service was excellent, the waitress kept checking up even..."
Todd Wood
"Absolutely the #1 reason I will return to the island!
This was my first trip to the UP and my first trip to the island and I was not disappointed to..."
Victoria Holt
"The food tastes amazing! It's definitely my favorite place to eat on Mackinac Island. The staff are very friendly. It is also a great place to eat if..."
The Refner Family
"Amaaaaaaazing!!! We had the best meals of our 3 day wedding anniversary stay on Mackinac here (twice)! I had the celebration burger (medium) and it..."
Becca Wolff
"We had a quick wait time of maybe 20 minutes. Our server was on top of his game and very fast with taking orders and getting our food and drinks to..."
Paige Jedrzejak
"Awesome ambience on the deck , good food with nice viewing of lake with live music. Only issue might the wait time here. We came here at 12.30 for..."
Prabha Shankar
"Highly recommend if you're looking for great whitefish! The number of ways that they serve whitefish is amazing and the ones we got were all..."
Tiffany Z.
"It was such a fun dining and drinking experience! We were able to walk right in and sit up at the bar. There was a large variety of drinks available..."
Samantha Garvie
"We heard great things about the Pink Pony so we had to check it out. We liked the atmosphere and loved that there was entertainment while you eat...."
Erica Jo
"We were having a tough time deciding on where to eat on the island, but we chose Pink Pony and it did not disappoint! The service was great and the..."
Jessica Olson
"The food was wonderful and so was the view! We sat outside and there was a heater so we were able to enjoy the view while staying cozy. Featured is..."
Gabriella Gomez
"Visited Mackinac City/Mackinac Island recently and of course had to stop at “The Most Iconic Bar in Michigan”. Such an adorable and fun..."
Amber Thompson
"If you visit the island then you need to try the pink pony. It's a staple for tourists. The environment, the music, the drinks and the food are all a..."
Mike Ferguson
"We decided to eat at the pink pony on our day exploring Mackinac Island. The food was alright. Service was great! We got the pretzel sticks for an..."
Elyza Seay
"We ate in the bar opting not to wait 60-90 minutes. Had excellent service from the bartender Danielle. Food was excellent. Probably the best sweet..."
Kimberly Ulreich-Smith
"We had such a great experience! Pink is my favourite colour so I absolutely loved the vibe. To start we felt inspired to have pink drinks, the Pretty..."
Candace Campbell
"Food was just ok, service was great! Wait was about an hour no big deal we anticipated that. My wife’s fish dip smelled and tasted like hot dogs,..."
"This intimate place has the best of everything. The staff are amazing and friendly and the food is off the charts! Justified Lettuce Wraps, Painted..."
Lisalee Chism Hogue
"Came to the island for our honeymoon..this is by far the best service and food we've had yet! Lisa is amazing, along with the bacon and other..."
Stephanie Hakim
"Great dinner and then another great meal at breakfast this morning. The true “go to” restaurant on the Island. Reasonable and tasty craft..."
Sarah Olson-Rosenbaum
"We always enjoy stopping here while we're on the Island. The food is ALWAYS delicious and the staff has always been great with each visit. We usually..."
MagikGal
"Whitefish & chips were very good. My mom got the pulled pork grilled cheese. Both amazing! The grilled cheese was the perfect blend if cheese and..."
Samantha Garland
"Amazing food! The staff were very friendly. Great place to eat if you have a gluten sensitivity or celiac... lot of..."
The Refner Family
"We decided to stop at the Seabiscuit Cafe for a late lunch. We ordered the Painted Pony Macaroni appetizer and it was delicious. My husband ordered..."
Ruth Ann Sommers
"So far to me best food at least on the main drag. Bbq wings, the French dip, fried Mac & cheese. Everything I've seen looks excellent. Nice pub feel...."
Adventure Rhoades
"Delicious whitefish Reuben sandwich !! Complete it with sweet potato fries. Whitefish dip appetizer with naan bread and salted crisps was fabulous...."
adamltw
"We stopped in to have a light lunch. We ordered the cup of whitefish chowder with the whitefish dip. The chowder was amazing. The dip was also..."
Donna Smith
"We stopped at Seabiscuit for lunch after we arrived on the island. Great service, the drinks were delicious and the food was amazing. The smoked..."
Elizabeth Jeane
"Great seafood! Expensive, but worth it. The fish was out of this world! Fish dip was awesome as well. Friendly staff, cool..."
E F
"The Seabiscuit Cafe offers a simple and delicious menu with a full bar. Their service is very friendly and are great with making recommendations or..."
Cody Weikel
"The place so nice we ate here twice. The wife and I were on our 10yr anniversary and stopped for supper. My burger was awesome and the wife had fish..."
Ninji522
"Love the ambiance of this place - really great decor and friendly staff. Food was really good too... the burgers had a really nice flavor to them and..."
Brian Thompson
"Stopped in for dinner last night and it was a great choice. The pulled pork sandwich was fantastic, and my kid loved their classic American..."
Mandy Gooding
"We were fortunate to visit Mackinac Island twice during 2023. Both visits included a meal at Seabiscuit Cafe as you can always count on a good food..."
David Tchozewski
"Our dinner was satisfactory. I had fried whitefish with coleslaw and fries, my dinner partner had a cup of whitefish chowder and strawberry salad. My..."
Nicky Yu
"I haven’t had good dining experiences at Mackinaw Island, however, sea biscuit Cafe was excellent. Autumn, our server was Excellent. She got a..."
Roger Cortez
"Enjoyed a wonderful lunch at Seabiscuit Cafe. Tomato Basil soup and Grilled Cheese Sandwich. The weather was chilly, so a hot coffee & Baileys hit..."
Brian Sawa
"We arrived to a Mackinac Island in the evening and were hangry. A pleasant surprise was Seabiscuit. We were greeted by Hannah, the hostess who talked..."
"Excellent service! Very pretty gardens surround their outdoor seating. Dog & children friendly. Games to play on the lawn next to the dining. Wood..."
Kim Michels
"Love this place. Came here thrice during a weekend trip to the island. Excellent food, service, and atmosphere. And they’re dog friendly! (Our pup..."
Aditi Verma
"My wife, our daughter, and I ate at the Ice House BBQ, on Wednesday, July 19th. I had the BBQ Brisket tacos and fries. I really enjoyed them, they..."
Infantry Shooter
"Nice spot to enjoy, away from the crowds. My salad was excellent.
The fried brie is a great idea, just needs a creamier quality of Brie and might be..."
Nicole Harper
"Great place to visit. Nice staff, and great food. The environment was great, and the service as well. I recommend it to try their food if you visited..."
Haimen Aziz
"I'd recommend this place as the staff and owner are very friendly and are accommodating for your furry family members.
The brisket chili and caesar..."
Aaron Mc
"Great food, service, and atmosphere away from the crowds.
Got here at 12:30pm on a Saturday in August and we were seated right away on the patio...."
Mark Sickmiller
"Visited the Ice House for dinner while we were guests at the hotel there. It was a nice evening. Food was very good, except I ordered spinach salad..."
Gwen Tucker
"The service here was excellent! For that alone, I would highly recommend this restaurant. The setting was beautiful and the food was pretty good. The..."
Kellea Krueger
"Annalise was a spectacular server. So attentive and remembered all the small details. Food was delicious. I recommend the sugar loaf..."
Ann McLean
"Ice House BBQ is a great and unique dining experience. The food is amazing, but the ordering is a little different. Your table has a QR Code that you..."
Cody Weikel
"This is truly a hidden gem off the path & away from the crowds! We loved the atmosphere and the whole experience! Our group of 5 had a wonderful..."
Angela Schoger
"This place was a relief to find. On a busy island, the Ice House BBQ is tucked back behind the Island House Hotel. There's well-shaded patio seating..."
Ben Lightner
"This place was SO GOOD! Would highly recommend the Nachos, Brisket Tacos, and the Fish and Chips! We also had the Kentucky Iced Tea and the Sunset..."
Ricky P
"This is one of my favorite restaurants on Mackinac Island. I really enjoy that it is tucked behind a hotel and off of the main street. The ambiance..."
Julie Mulder
"If i could give more than 5 stars I would. AnnaLiese was so friendly and attentive. The atmosphere was awesome. The food was excellent. They are..."
Patti Clements
"The outdoor setting was very nice and the service was ok. The smoked chicken half was small, bland and somewhat dry. The cornbread and coleslaw were..."
Markus
"It was great! The food was very good. We had ribs, brisket tacos, the pulled pork sandwich, brisket chili, and the whitefish spread. All was yummy!..."
Carl Arendall
"We came here twice during our trip. We passed it up at first but decided to follow the signs and try it out; it ended up being our favorite place we..."
Alexis Langford
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes