Review Brendon's Catch 23 - Louisville

I had an amazing night out with the ladies there last weekend. The food was superb. The service was top notch. The drinks were delicious. I will be going back very soon! Their valet was packed so they couldn’t do me or my friend car so parking was either on the street or in the parking garage around the corner. Cost me $13.

Thoroughly enjoyed the food at this spot it came highly recommended by locals for its food and it lived up to the hype! The waitress was very knowledgeable and provided great recommendations, the cooked oysters were fresh and amazing and the steak was flavourful and cooked to perfection! Will visit again whenever I'm in town.

We came here for dinner this past Friday and it was excellent though a touch expensive. The jar crab appetizer was very good but extremely rich from all the butter. I had the filet and scallops for dinner. The steak was perfectly cooked and the scallops just melt in your mouth. The sea bass was also very good. The staff were very friendly and gave helpful recommendations. Our server was very attentive and friendly.

Nico was amazing at making us feel special. Every item we rested was on point delicious. Chilean sea bass mwah. Salmon yummy. Shrimp so good.

Beautiful outing. I attended this venue for an educational event so we couldn't order are steaks individually so they were all cooked the same. I wasn't impressed with the 2 bites I had of my co-workers steak. I had Salmon with mashed potatoes and asparagus. It was delicious and definitely would order again. My Caesar salad was delicious. Crab cakes melted in your mouth. Amazing crab cakes. This is a great place for a date night.

Great food selection. Delicious steak. Cioppino was phenomenal! Drinks also good.

My sea bass was delicious! I think the wine prices are too high. ...sorry...I'd taken a bite before the picture!!!

Our server, Jennifer, set the tone for our wonderful evening. She was knowledgeable about the menu and her recommendations were spot-on. We were seated by the lovely fireplace feature but it didn't produce any heat. We shared Arroncini as an appetizer, and it was crispy outside and wonderfully creamy inside, with a perfectly-cooked bite of fish in the center. The scallops were the best I've ever had, sweet and meltingly tender. The cioppino was perfect, with an array of tender seafood in an amazing sauce and crisp bread to dip. Save room for the Berries Jubilee, flambéed tableside.

My sister’s coworker recommended Brendon’s Catch 23 to us, and I am glad we gave it a try. The atmosphere, food and service were all amazing. The seared sea scallops with risotto ranked as the best meal I have eaten at a restaurant all year. My husband had the shrimp and grits, which he said was good but had too much pepper. Overall, we enjoyed our dining experience here as we fellowshipped with friends.

Great seafood cocktails and atmosphere...a great high end bar in a lively area of downtown Louisville. We enjoyed apps and cocktails at the bar with Alyza doing a fantastic job behind the bar.

Over the top amazing. Food was beyond delicious. Our waiter, Nicko was perfect. Arancini delicious. Atmosphere lovrly3 with great music. Weird that they had tv monitos with sports. Took away a bit from a fabulously elegant restaurant.

Spent our 25th Anniversary dinner here. What an amazing selection of food! Everything we ordered was fantastic! Our server, Sam, was excellent. Explained our choices and chose recommendations carefully. It was a wonderful experience.

My wife and I celebrated our anniversary at this restaurant. Food was great and the service was excellent. The biggest issue that I had was with the valet staff when we pulled up to the front of the restaurant we have to hit our horn in order to get the v valet attention to come to our car. When she came to our car, she told my wife “you can get out” in a rude way. She also did not attempt to open the door for my as normal valet do. It cost $25 to park for two hours. That’s the least they can do. We also waited 20 minutes to get our car. I recommend parking on the street saving your money because valet there is terrible.

Even with our 8pm reservation, we still waited 30 minutes for our table. Tha host was aware this was a birthday celebration but failed to tell our server who was otherwise magnificent. He was knowledgeable, polite and attentive. Food was good, portions did not equate to the price but the atmosphere was also nice. Butter cake was amazing for dessert

The dining experience here is great. The service was pleasant and the staff very welcoming. I was pleased with the flavors, the menu is full of various options. Went with the Tuna Tar Tar as an appetizer and it did not disappoint. The preparation of Chilean Sea Bass (as the main course) was spot on. My wife had the Scallop plate, I thought the risotto was a great compliment to the plate. Presentation was excellent!

We had such a great experience, from the King Crab in a warm jar and the Caesar salad to the scallops with pea risotto and yellowfin Tuna, everything was amazing and prepared perfectly.

I am from Indianapolis, IN & was in town for a concert at the Yum Center. This place was recommended by a friend & was simply amazing. My wife & I as well as the other couple shared several of the appetizers. The fried mushrooms were the BEST I have ever had, literally, the BEST I have ever had! The lobster Mac and Cheese was equally AMAZING. Everything was beyond expectations. This is a SOLID five of five. To add to one of the best meals I have ever had, our server Jaime was well-versed in the menu & had outstanding advice. Our drinks never got below half full. The table was kept immaculate. We never had to ask for anything, other than recommendations because he was already on it. FIVE out of FIVE Jaime! WELL done! This is a MUST dine of you are in town!

Brendons Catch has a piqued my interest with its upscale atmosphere that's still welcoming of business casual attire. The decor it put together well and there are plenty of TV for viewing that aren't so loud that you can't hold a conversation at the table. I couldn't give the restaurant 5 stars because I'm a nit picker when it comes to service, promptness, and convenience. The physical menus were a classic touch that allows diners to get a full view of the extensive bourbon and wine lists but I would have preferred a QR code for contact less access. I came out by myself so I was seated at the bar. My waitress had to cover the bar and a small portion of the dining area so they were stretched a little thin. She was very friendly and knowledgeable about the menu but she took forever to get my order and to deliver the check (which another server had to do because she was too busy cleaning up). For a Wednesday evening I thought this was rather slow and it perturbed me a little. The food was quite delicious though. The charcoal flavor from the grill was a little heavy on the shrimp skewers but the sauces that accompanied it made up for it. The grilled salmon was cooked to perfection and the Yukon gold potatoes were scrumptious. All in all it was a pleasurable experience but a little lackluster for my birthday dinner. Give it a try but expect this place to be packed on weekends.