After moving to Locust Valley couple of months ago, I started eating from this place more than any other place!
I JUST ATE HERE. HAD THE CHICKEN CORDON BLUE SLICE
Buffalo Chicken slice covered in chicken, great ratio of chicken per bite, buffalo sauce great flavor crust was just ok.
Amy Angel Germano Daum
+4
The best ceaser salad slice in the world!! My family has been coming here for 15+ years. Food is delicious, would love to see a revamp in decor... <3
First time here, very impressed! Spaghetti bolognese was great, and a large portion, fried zucchini spears were very good, and meatball side was one of the best I've had!
Wings were good too!
First time ordering food from here...My husband and I were happily surprised. The food is very tasty...the portions are large and the price is very reasonable. Will definitely be ordering again.
When evaluating a good slice of pizza, there are so many factors to consider: the thickness of the bread, the cheese to crust ratio, the texture, etc. While I think Locust Valley Pizza makes some of the best pies in this area, they are frankly on the bread heavy side. This is how a pizza should be.
Their pizza dough is definitely different, good different. Very tasty and well made pizza … especially their plain slice, perfect amount of cheese and crust thickness in my opinion. Highly recommend.
Very good pizza at a reasonable price. Very clean store with polite and efficient staff.
I love eat pizza here is
delicious and ppl are so nice
Pizza, chicken parm, sausage and meatball 🤌🏼
All amazing.
OK, a nice neighborhood pizza spot... nothing dramatic about the pizza, but it is consistently tasty and nicely textured with a crisp crust... Sicilian style very reasonable and delicious
some of the competition down the road serve sweet sauce, not my choice
mozzarella sticks and chicken wings are fine and a hit with the little ones, pepperoni pinwheels are terrific, especially for the price
if fried calamari is your thing, go somewhere else
employees are helpful and polite to the point of friendly
I ordered the grandma pizza and it was delicious.The place was clean. And the staff was attentive. Really enjoyed my lunch.
Omg, had eggplant parm dinner from the soup , salad n main dish, everything was delicious!
This is affordable, good food, and the attention the best, this kind people in the right business, they treat excellent their customer, clean and good coffee come to try your self!!! Thanks!!! Stop by!!!
Got a Sicilian Pie one of the bigger and better Sicilian pies I've had in awhile.
Good food, good price, and lovely people!
Really good pizza, highly recommend if you're looking for a good slice.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes