Pizza cuisine: the best places to taste it in Lancaster

"I picked up the Tuesday special pizza for my husband on my way home from work and he said it was the best pizza he has had in years! It’s good that..."

Jake Tregonning

Cal Arden

Fox's Pizza Den

"Food was amazing, hot and fresh, I only gave 4 stars because I forgot to ask for my wings to be twice cooked in the..."

Nicole Blakeney

"Great lunch menu and lunch prices! Can't be beat. Whatever the price though, the taste and quality is worth it. Love love love this place. I've..."

K K

"While the pizza is pretty good, the salads are really great here! They freshly prepare their salads and they are always delicious. Definitely one of..."

Tabitha Geiger

"Is that the same Bobby Mcinvaille I worked with @Foxs a few months back? Thought you just left....anyway =D Was a great place for my first job to..."

Torri Stillner

"Love this place. Best pizza and wedgies in town. I go every week. Sometimes more than..."

Beverly Lanier

Nick's Restaurant And Pizza

Wheelchair Accessible

"Great place to eat. The service is great. And delivery doesn't make you wait forever. Which is great if you get a bit hangry like I do..."

Michael May

"Great place to get food. We order here all the time and always get fast service. The staff is very friendly and always happy to..."

Daniel Burge

"So far I have been quite impressed with Nicks. I just recently moved to the area from a large city where you could order almost anything to your..."

Erin Conner

"Great place to eat breakfast. Service was..."

Steven Hunt

"Great pizza for a great price simple as that😎 The staff is always super..."

Gavin Gillum

"Great staff, great food. I eat there every..."

Kevin Slone

"Really good food. Employees are all very friendly people. Can't wait to go..."

Don Casto

"Great pizza for my sons bday party at Tag-M family lazer tag arena. Delivered on time and everyone loved..."

Jennifer Lynn

"When go to Nick's you are family. Can't say that about any other place in..."

Kitty Mccoy

"My son and i was hungry, He suggested Nicks for dinner !!! Knowing that hes only 12 and has great taste !!! Thank you Nicks for being so..."

Joe Hartman

"Nicks is by far our favorite pizza in town!! The dough is perfect, the sauce is delicious , and the toppings are fresh! The subs and sandwiches are..."

Ashley Booth

"Visiting from Cincinnati. Enjoyed the..."

Dianne Hoffman Byerly

"pizza and subs good. delivery reliable. Price reasonable. no..."

Adrian Burns

"We love Nick's! Wonderful service. We haven't tried their pizza yet because they have other menu items we found mode enticing. I recommend the pork..."

Devonna Jean Obert

"I ordered Nick's on a Saturday. Had to wait over an hour for my super Sub to be delivered to me. But was to be expected considering how popular nicks..."

James Buttninski

"We were looking for something local for pizza in Lancaster. This place did not disappoint by any means. Server was awesomely friendly, and they made..."

Adam R

"Amazing food, fast service and the owners are absolutely amazing ppl!! One of my favorite pizza and salad places I'm town!!!..."

Brandi Tirado

"This was my first visit here. When I walked in I ask if I could eat inside.I was told yes & to pick a seat. I ordered a pizza sub & sweet tea.I had a..."

Thunders Girl

"Always great food. If you like hot wings. They are hot. Great patty melt. Desserts are wonderful! Homemade, ..."

Chip Payne

"Hands down one of our favorite Mom and Pop pizza shops. Original and always up to par. Keep Killin it Ya'll. We'll be back..."

Chanler Grensted

Pink Cricket Restaurant

"This is a classic mom and pop restaurant-bar, and has been part of the community a long time. Personally I like their pizza the most, but I have..."

Matthew Riggle

"It's been over a decade since I was in Lancaster to do anything like shopping or what have you, but one thing ALWAYS is on my mind whenever I knew..."

Kim Pratt

"It is a jewel of a restaurant out on Main Street in Lancaster. The waitresses are all friendly and the food is awesome! I got a 12 inch sausage and..."

Colleen Olds

"Excellent food if you have never tried it or have been a while you should try it again or go the first time it's..."

Keith Murphy

"Very good pizza!!!! Salads were amazing also! Server was super nice! Great place to eat, very..."

Lindsey

"Great local pizza shop! Consistently fresh & delicious every..."

Stacy Wildermuth

"It has been a long time since eating Pink Cricket and it was great!! Think they have the best subs! Probably my favorite is the Reese’s pie…..."

Jayson Waits

Pizza Crossing

"First time I've ever had this pizza - on July 3, 2018 - it was delicious! Best pizza I've eaten in a long time. Will be my go to place for pizza in..."

Tim Moore

"We live in Logan and love pizza crossing. We were in Lancaster and decided to get pizza crossing. I have to say Lancaster has quality!! They are not..."

Sabrina Stivison

"My new favorite pizza place!. Perfect! Delivery was prompt and the pie was..."

Rose Mast McKay

"Love the food and the staff. My boyfriend and I love this place. Best..."

Brooke Meadows-Woods

"Thank You to Pizza Crossing and to their Customers for Helping Us Raise $20.98 for Dog Cancer and Sarcoma Research. We Love and Appreciate You! Love,..."

Amy Carpenter

"Best pizza around and love the fact that the staff is..."

April Thornton

"Damn good food, and a friendly atmosphere!!!!! Recommend for a great night..."

Jeremy Parsons

Pasquale's Italian Garden And Pizzeria

86/100 (1766 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

Dinner

Lunch

Mid-range

"This was one of our best finds on our trip! From the atmosphere, set up, food, and staff, everything was top notch. I would give this place three..."

Julie

"Best tiramisu here! My kids love the meatball spaghetti, while my husband and I always go for the bruschetta. Once seated, you place your order at..."

Elvira Ku

"Always have good food here! Be your own waitress is a creative way to deal with employee shortages. Pleasant workers behind the counter. Enjoyed..."

Joyce Sensenig

"We ordered their $20.23 special, a large cheese pizza, meatballs, and a large salad. Everything was so good. I'm definitely going to make the trip..."

Sarah Sanyasi

"Excellent! If you are looking for delicious, authentic Italian food, this is it! The staff was very gracious and welcoming. I also loved the..."

Maria G

"Good food, good price. However they pressure you for a tip on the screen when you order and pay. Even though you literally fill your own drinks, and..."

Shelly Gardner

"Love the intimate individual booths... really like the "seat yourself" design of the restaurant.... used to work locally 20 years ago and got..."

Suesan Sonder

"This place is fantastic. The food is wonderful, but the best part is the service. Frank is the owner and is always there. He hires friendly, smiling..."

John Hillard

"Where do I start?! Me and my family travel the country for various reasons, we eat all over from fancy to quick and easy. Frank and his team brought..."

Thomas Caro

"Solid food especially for a really good price. I honestly think the garlic knots are some of the best in the area and they are only $4 for a full..."

Austin Boley

"Really good pizza, really friendly staff, we are definitely going..."

Kyle

"We live close by and I was simply having one of those "I don't feel like cooking" nights. I ordered online but found out we could eat in. Great! No..."

Shelley Snow

"Just moved near them and eat there like every week now. Absolutely love this place. I've been helped by at least 5 or 6 different staff members and..."

R T

"First time eating there, cashier/order taker was very helpful. Got the #2 lunch special. It’s a NY style pizza and the slice is very large with a..."

Patrick Gomez

"The staff is super nice and the food is..."

Maria Diaz

"Great pasta and pizza. The side of garlic broccoli and Italian Wedding Soups are also amazing. The restaurant is beautiful but dark. You order in..."

Brian Geber

"A gem in the neighborhood. Excellent food and generous portion. The pasta was cooked perfectly, the sauce was flavorful, and the meatballs were..."

Jason Lin

Rigatony's Pizza & Pasta

Wheelchair Accessible

Barone's Pizza

Wheelchair Accessible

"I absolutely love love love Barone's Pizza! Their 'Everything ' on it pizza is to die for! Nice peaceful atmosphere. The waitresses r very polite..."

Joann Coon

"The garlic bread was to die for, the meatballs were amazing, and the chicken parm was delicious!! Thank you, Barone's, for the amazing experience and..."

Ashley Elizabeth Testor

"Great place to enjoy Italian Cuisine. Love to eat at a Family run restaurant very friendly and great..."

John Sagray

"Been going here since 3-68. Anti pasta salad and black olive medium pizza..."

Michael LaRosa

"Great pizza, old school, music, full menu and full..."

Sonia Just

"I love Barone's. Customer service was fantastic, food is always great and I've missed..."

Jodi Becker

"Great food. Great price. Great service. I love that there is also a casual choice for the family (Ave I) out just a bit fancier place for date..."

Debbie Van Sickle

"My favorite restaurant, I go back every time I’m in the antelope..."

Melissa Bobbitt

"Pizza was great. The garlic bread was excellent. The service was AWESOME. I will be..."

Cassandra Kyman

"Barone's is THE BEST Italian restaurant in the AV. The Tiramisu is the best in the..."

John Magar

"Best Garlic Cheese Bread and Pizza! Clean, quiet casual dining..."

Danielle Marie Madrigal

"Been going there for about 40 years. Best pizza in..."

Ida Shea Offerding

"Admittedly I’ve never gone here because of the location. Today mom insisted she wanted to try it! I’m pleased to say the food is good. The food..."

Lisa Whitney

"Really good food, everything was super tasty came out quick location doesn't do it..."

Victoria Hernandez

"Batman Favorite place...Why? Come down here, Taste the delicious Barone's Best pizza in Town. I Dare..."

Donald A. Perez

"Walked up. Ordered takeout. They were polite professional. Everyone should make this their favorite pizza pasta stop in Lancaster..."

carl schweers

"The service was amazing!!! They treated me and my little family with so much love and kindness. We felt so at home at Barone's. The food was so good..."

Carlos Tapia

"Delicious food and great service! I especially loved the..."

John Bruno

"Everything is made in house excellently. Service is friendly and low..."

Suzanne Stokes

"Good pizza but prices are a bit on the expensive side. Other than that food is good..."

Miss Nattycakes

Luca On James

85/100 (1791 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

"Food was delicious! My bolognese was perfectly portioned. We made a reservation and we’re seated on arrival. This is a big space and they use it..."

Rachaelann Yoder Klink

"My favorite restaurant in Lancaster. I dine here a few times a month and love it. They specialize in seasonal wood fired cooking. Everything is..."

Brian Tak

"100% recommend dinning here! The food is like a party for your taste buds. Fresh ingredients and definitely every singer flavor belongs in every..."

April King

"Luca doesn't miss! Been here a handful of times - reservations definitely required - and the food is always top notch. Drinks are incredibly tasty,..."

Karen R.

"Great Italian restaurant in the city with wonderful cocktails, small plates and entrees. They used to have a sizable pizza menu made in their wood..."

Erin Kelly

"We went on a Sunday evening it was very busy. The tables are jammed into this place to maximize space so you are surrounded by lots of ongoing..."

Adam Kotzman

"I had the most amazing dining experience of my life at Luca! My son took me out for Mother’s Day and what a special gift this restaurant is to..."

Jen Lo

"Came here on a weekday to find the place packed for dinner. Everything was AWESOME! We had the focaccia and bursts appetizer which was incredibly..."

EJ Hom

"Luca is absolutely incredible, for sure the best food in the area! We were lucky enough to be able to have our rehearsal dinner at Luca and we could..."

Victoria Pesaturo

"Delicious food and drinks. Definitely try the beef carpaccio. I also like the amaro flight but it's not for everyone. The food and drinks are fairly..."

Austin Gwiazdowski

"The best pizza and flavors to come out of a wood fired oven. Dough/ crust was incredible. Every wait staff was friendly, welcoming and accommodating...."

Sherry Smith

"Fav restaurant in Lancaster. Food never disappoints! I love their coffee..."

Genesis E

"Perfect date night spot, but be sure to make your reservations well in advance. No visible TVs, cool atmosphere, excellent food and service, and..."

Penelope Bellamy

"Absolutely wonderfully delicious food and service and atmosphere. The food quality is phenomenal and pretty much everything is locally sourced. The..."

Melanie Dodson

"Very good food & excellent service! It was my first time, though I’d always heard great things about the restaurant. It lives up to the positive..."

Maurielle C

"Incredible experience. The staff are all wonderful and the service is top notch. We each got pasta dishes based on the recommendation of our waitress..."

Hannah Miller

"Best restaurant in Lancaster! Warm, welcoming staff 100% of the time! Get a seat at the bar - wonderful hospitality! The food is like being in..."

Joseph Duggan

"We sat at the chefs table and I honestly loved watching the staff work in the kitchen! It was a really cool experience and the food was out of this..."

Alexandra Suseland

Rosa's Pizza

"Best pizza and wonderful owner Rosa!!! Love it! Would recommend this place to..."

Jason Brody

"I love this place! I haven't found better wings and they are so affordable! Pizza is awesome as well. Rosa and her staff are down to earth, good..."

Michael Gross

"Great service and quality food. They have this pizza lover wondering whether or not they have the best pizza in..."

James Murray

"The best! Pizza is always well done and super flavorful. Order the Buffalo cheesesteak..."

Salina M. Almanzar

"best cheese steaks ever thanks and will be going..."

Sass Harrigle

"Love there pizza reminds me of New York pizza the owners are..."

Lynnette Rosa Rivera

"Extremely satisfied,quick delivery and great..."

Eliud Lambert

"And I thought they were new! WOW ! What a great find. Pizza is perfect. Cheese steak is..."

Martha Carlson Lefever

"Todo delicioso y buen serbicio me encanta rosa's pizza el personal muy..."

Glendy Buezo

"I will put Rosa's Deluxe and Supreme Pizza up against ANYONE! I have had everyone's pizza around town and am always looking for the best... I..."

Justin Rule

"The food was really good and the restaurant was very clean and..."

Daniel Kamanu

"I love pizza, could eat it 5 days a week. I was in the area and feeling hungry so I turned into the shopping plaza and boom a pizza joint over in the..."

Kulinary Mafia

"I just ordered 50 wings for a last minute family moving party. 30 minutes they'll be ready for pick up. That's pretty good service. I've had their..."

Woods Carpet Cleaning

"We wanted to try this place since it was new in the area and after reading the reviews we picked up some food to take home and it was out of this..."

Irena Vresk

"Love this place. Their food is fresh, their ingredients are high quality - and Rosa is a gem! Definitely a go-to place for great pizza, salads, and..."

Linda Kosich

"Very friendly staff, quick service and the food is great! With so many options for Pizza takeout, these folks stand out and definitely worth a try..."

James Cosentino

"Just tried Rosa's for the first time last month. Only ordered pizza so far (3 times) and the pizza is so yummy! Can't wait to try other menu..."

Joelle Garman

"Gluten free pizza was amazing. Rosa and Eric are so genuine. The Rosa Chicken Pasta was awesome...can't wait to come back. Kids loved..."

Whitney Rule

"Just stopped byou on my way home for 2 slices of pizza and I was blown away how good it was. The staff were very friendly and engaging. I will..."

Nate Schmidt

"Rosa is the best! Everything I have tried has been great,...try the chicken Texas sandwich. The chicken corn soup can’t be beat! And the pizza is..."

Andrew McGinty

"Everything tasted fresh. Italian Hoagie with beautiful cappicola meat that you don't usually see in these parts. Great service, excellent..."

Karen P

"Great food. Rosa is a lovely woman to talk to and pleasant. Best food all around. Everyone is very pleasant. Good..."

Teena Leed

"Excellent pizza! I've had several of their pizzas and they are always great! Excellent service..."

Tim Achuff

"First time there but not the last. Food was very good, clean, friendly environment and price just right. Look forward to going..."

scott britcher

"Best pizza in town and Rosa is as sweet as they come. Highly..."

Mark Fischer

A Slice Of Brooklyn Pizza

85/100 (1178 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

Accepts American Express

"My husband brought me a grandmas pie pizza and a regular cheese pie to have ready after I gave birth at the nearby birthing hospital and pizza was..."

Laura

"What a great find! We needed to drive over an hour to pick up an automotive part near here and since it was time for dinner I googled restaurants..."

Jody Beck

"This is a pizzaria where you will enjoy dining in. The esthetics of this place are incredible. I am from Brooklyn, and i have never seen anything..."

Nick Dangerous

"1st time. Owner, staff friendly. Guided us through process of ordering. Food came quickly. Made with fresh ingredients. In my top 5 best pizza. Tried..."

Mark Peterson

"The staff were friendly, great prices and the grandma pizza was absolutely delicious. We will 100% be recommending and..."

Lex C

"The Grandma Pizza was incredible. First timer, but this has to be among the best pies in Lancaster. Note: this did not come Pac-Man..."

Kyle Ziegler

"Authenticate NY pizza experience start to finish. Amazing slices. The best in the..."

Al Tielebein

"Stopped here on the way back from the Wolf Sanctuary because I heard they had good Gluten Free pizza. What I heard was not wrong. Their Gluten free..."

Kevin Brower

"Great and fresh food everytime. We have been coming for a few years and everything is always good. Friendly staff that treats you like family. ..."

Daniel Steech

"Cute little pizza shop. Honestly the best pizza I’ve ever had, I would 100 percent come back. Friendly workers and super fast..."

Katie Zdunski

"I have lived in Lancaster for about 8 months now and I have finally found a good pizza joint. My only regret was that I did not order a large. Great..."

Sean

"My wife and I are new to the area and have been trying different restaurants. Trying to find our every day staples. This pizza place has quality..."

Phillip Hearne

"All the pizzas made fresh & are phenomenal. Favorite would be the tomato pie, stays good days after as well! Have it hot or room temperature, both..."

Sky Society

"Food was delicious! Fast service and friendly..."

Lisa Ann

"My husband and I visited the restaurant after a play. We were looking for a fairly quiet place to get a good meal before making the 45 minute drive..."

Londa Peterson

"First time eating pizza in the northeast. my expectations were extremely high and still I was blown away. It’s that greasy goodness we all love...."

Abraham Castillo

"Hands down. The most close to NY that you will be on every bite! Really fresh with the NY style that represents the NY pizza. Great attention, the..."

Hector Arias (Flair Bartender)

"If I could give more than 5 stars I would. When I walked in the atmosphere was what I would hope it would be if this place was in New York City. The..."

Jeff

Cristy's Pizza

Wheelchair Accessible

Accepts American Express

"We have been Christy's fans for years! Always great and friendly service and we always end up devouring our food. We have our go-to favorites but in..."

Reset

There are 113 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Pizza cuisine: the best places to taste it in Lancaster

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters

Carolyn Brubaker Preis

Lisa L Smith

Herb Landis

Jennifer Woggon Wolownik

Jessica Keeney

Cynthia Swank Hynes

Abbi Jo Ferree

Vitaly Borisenko

Mercè Garcia Marsà

Lou Rivera

Katie Oxee

Pat Fossler

Austin Boley

Zach Klinedinst

Lucia Parry

Daniel Joseph

D N

George Vekios

Lyndsy Barry

Carey Postell

Noah Andrews

Elizabeth P

Aiden Dierwechter

Sher90n2

dan shearer

Jania Ivelisse

Cameron Shaffner

Daniel Call

deerie holland

Regina Runk

phoebe koppenheffer

Jeffrey Latterell

Marty Loose

conni biscayart

Trevor Burke

Hector Noriega

Kyeshia Shodunke

Kee Thirteen

Wonder Woman

Ryan

Doze Reviews

Samantha Staggs

Jeff Talbutt

Kimiko (Hi)

All Love Cali Gold

Reg Dyer

DrThomas

James Eye

Gwen Maris

James Azzariti

Joseph Martinez

Audriana Reavis

Teresa Wright Seaman

Tadreed

Aaron Bennett

Lukey Luke

L S

Melissa Mackey

Traci W

Shannon Conrad

Jim Hirschhorn

Lore T

Chelsea Snook

Mia

Sarah Plummer

Don Pierce

Jamie Hornberger

Kavan Elliott