Sluurpy > Restaurants in Lancaster > Castaways

Review Castaways - Lancaster

Julie Rock
My husband and I were the first customers of the evening. We were seated at a table and ordered drinks. When our waitress came in back to take our dinner order, we asked if the blaring music could be turned down. She checked with the owner who said they could not. We asked if they could turn it off and I once again were told no. We moved to another table. We are a retired couple who were expecting a nice evening. Restrooms are filthy. Foodstraight from freezer to deep fryer. Won't be back.
Natalie Altemose
My mom grew up here in the 70s. I didn't have high hopes when she brought me. I was a jabroni. The pizza was delicious!! It was very calm and peaceful inside and everyone was nice to me. If you like homestyle Americana, you will not be disappointed. Very tasty, very relaxed, can't wait to come back to OH!
Kourtney Turner
Great food and service! We ordered the steak for 3 my goodness was it a mound of steak and delicious too! Our first time there and we all said we would definitely come back.
Tabitha Knight-Bailey
We had 2 waitresses. One was very nice the other who took our order was very short with us and rude. Yes they were busy but no reason to be rude. My husband and I both ordered steaks. Neither was cooked right and had no flavor, he ordered a side of mushrooms, they were literally a CAN of sliced mushrooms dumped in a cup. Ew. We spent $75 and we both left still hungry. Very disappointed to say the least.
chris swain
Amazing food, attentive staff!!! Very quick service!!!!! Will return every time in town!!!!
Kimberly Hamilton
Never disappointed. Food tastes great. Atmosphere wonderful. Service always friendly. Support Local and you'll never be let down. One of my favorite restaurants to visit when home to see family.
Colleen Olds
I have been going there since I was about 12 years old and I am now 60! They have the best pizza, but all of their food is amazing. A few of my friends and I ate on their patio and everyone made sure our experience was wonderful. I had the steak, salad and baked potato. It was all yummy and I had plenty to take home.
Lee Tipple
The atmosphere is very appealing which is why we chose this place for our Saturday get together. A little overpriced for the quality and quantity of food. Salad and potatoes are cheap and plentiful in central ohio especially in the summer. When I order potato skins I expect half a potato per skin, not a quarter. A full salad plate would have been nice. The dinner for 2 Is served with sirloin steak which is fine but for the price I would expect better marbling
Jessica Logsdon
Best locally owned restaurant we have EVER had the pleasure of eating at! Freshest meat I've ever put in my mouth� Best pizza ever & great steaks! I loved the atmosphere & the smell of food cooking throughout the entire place.
Denise McCoy
First time in 20 some years and just as I remember , awesome food , awesome service !!! We won’t wait so long to return ! Love this place !!
Renie Brown
This is a great place to dine! We had a party of 23 and all the staff did an amazing job getting all our orders along with their regular customers out in a timely manner! Everyone had delicious meals and the best desserts I've ever tasted!! Thank you Micole for taking on our large party and to our great waitress that served us!!
Melissa LeFever Hopper
The pizza was excellent! Definitely will return for pizza but steak, not so much!
Misty Lane Thorp
Family all had steaks there tonight didn’t care for it at all will never go back
Randy Bussart
Had dinner tonight food and staff was top notch. Best steak In town. Thanks guys
Alfredo Arancini Bagels Baguette Bangers And Mash Bass Beef Beef Bourguignon Beef on Weck Biscuits and gravy BLT Bolognese Bouillabaisse Bread Pudding Breakfast Burrito Breakfast Sandwich Burger Burrito Cakes Calamares Calamari Cannelloni Cannoli Catfish Ceviche Cheeseburger Cheesecake Cheesecakes Cheesesteak Chicken Alfredo Chicken And Waffles Chicken Croquettes Chicken Parmesan Chicken Sandwich Chicken Wings Chili Chowder Clams Club Sandwich Cod Corned Beef Crab Crab Cake Crab Legs Crab Rangoon Crab Soup Crawfish Creme Brulee Crepes Croque Monsieur Croquettes Cupcakes Curry Donuts Duck Dumplings Eggplant Eggs Benedict Escargot Fajitas Falafel Filet Mignon Fish Fish & Chips Fish Sandwich Fish Soup Fish Taco Focaccia French Fries French onion soup French Toast Fried pickles Frozen Yogurt Gazpacho Gelato Green Curry Grilled cheese Gyros Halibut Hamburgers Hanger steak Hoagie Hot Dog Hummus Ice Cream Juice & Smoothies Kabobs Kale Salad Lamb chops Lasagne Lemon tart Lettuce Wraps Lobster Lobster Roll Lyonnaise salad Mac and cheese Macarons Macaroons Meatballs Meatloaf Minestrone Mussels Nachos Noodle Octopus Omelette Oyster Pad Thai Paella Pancakes Pasta Perogies Pho Polenta Poutine Pretzel Profiteroles Prosciutto Quenelle Quiche Ramen Red Curry Reuben sandwich Ribs Rice pudding Risotto Roast Beef Salad Salmon Sandwiches Scallops Schnitzel Scrapple Seafood Platters Shawarma Shellfish Shrimp Shrimp and Grits Shrimp Salad Sirloin Steak Souvlaki Steak Frites Steak Tartare Surf And Turf Swordfish Tacos Tagliatelle Tandoori Chicken Tapas Tater tots Tempura Tikka Masala Tilapia Tiramisu Toasts Torte Tortillas Tostones Tuna Turkey Burger Waffle Fries Waffles Waffles & Crepes Wings
Share on WhastApp
Share on Facebook
Browse the menu
Add review