Their pizza sauce is sweet and there is plenty of it. They are also very generous with the cheese. This is the only pizza I eat. Their alfredo is also good.
The very best stromboli around. If you have ever had stromboli from a chain, you are probably not a very big fan. It is usually very doughy and tough with a small amount of toppings, served with a boring marinara or pizza sauce. Try one at Tiberio's and you can be sure to change your outlook on strombolis. Perfectly cooked in their amazing crispy, sweet dough is a generous helping of pepperoni, ham, mushrooms and cheese. Served with a large bowl of their incredible pizza sauce, this is the best stromboli you will ever find. I always get the small and end up taking half of it home because there is too much there to eat.
If you ever get tired of the stromboli (not possible in my opinion), the pizza is equally incredible.
Love the Stromboli here, best ever. The salads and pizza are really good too. The only downside is the hours of operation, hence 4 instead of 5.stars.
Literally the best.
Don't think this is some "gas station pizza " because of the location
The recipes and the family that owns them go long ways back.
You're doing yourself a disservice if you haven't been here yet
This is a Lancaster Legend!! The pizzaria has had a few different locations over the years but the quality has never deviated. We love the stromboli from here! It's all hand made fresh packed with meat and cheese. The sauce is sweet, they give you plenty of it. So if you're like me who likes a lot of sauce for the stromboli you'll be satisfied. I recommend there side salad with the in house Italian. Its creamy and delicious. This is by far the best pizzeria in town. Go get a slice or a stromboli you wont be sorry!
Best Stromboli ever. Sauce is the cat’s pajamas. Breadsticks and chef salad are great too. We go here every May 7 to celebrate my husband’s birthday and anytime we pass through Lancaster.
In one side of a Shell gas station. Don’t let that fool you. Delicious food!
I loved Tiberio's when it was downtown, and I miss their full menu their fried zucchini was the best in town. They're still the best their pizza sauce is undeniable the best in town, like their pizza. My favorite dish is Chicken Parmesan, oh my goodness I could eat it everyday. not kidding!! The bread sticks are awesome (but not good the next day I've not figured out how to keep them great like they come) I always get a whole order not just 1 that comes with the meal that's not enough. They have more then Italian foods they also have the hamburger, fried bologna I think even fries and I've had their hamburgers and fries they're all really good.
This place will be greatly missed.
It's been my favorite pizza ever since I discovered it out back behind the Doghouse.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Lancaster
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes