Reviews Old City Public House

Facebook
Bobby Pfeifer
+5
Jim the owner is very welcoming Large list of tap IPA beers Food is really good I recommend the southern fried chicken & the Long Ireland Celtic Ale.
Facebook
Anne Marie
+5
First time back for food since changing hands...after reading some comments...was expecting to be disappointed....but just the opposite!!!! Everything was delicious...we had the onion rings....the French Dip (with Mozzarella and mushrooms) ...the grilled chicken wrap.....chicken/shrimp fajitas....filled my wine glass to the brim....great service...wish i could remember our server's name...attentive and friendly...and the new owner...very nice and welcoming...can't wait to go back!
Facebook
Karen Johnson Bullock
+5
We had been going religiously for Karaoke but then it was cancelled. SO HAPPY they brought it back! It’s always a good time with Sal! Since coming back we haven’t been disappointed. The staff is really friendly and the food is really good and a great selection of beer. The owner greeted us and was very attentive.
Facebook
Rae-Ann Rodriguez
+5
Had a delicious French Dip sandwich here last night.. melts in your mouth.. nice crispy fries and yummy pickles too... definitely worth a visit.. �
Facebook
Dawn Remsen
+5
Food is fabulous, fresh made, diverse menu and daily lunch specials are terrific! Best chicken soup and burgers ever!. Salads and wraps great too..crispy onion rings and fries! We Go often..so good! Staff is warm and friendly..very attentive. Manager is terrific... Cheers!
Facebook
Dan Meade
+5
Food is great the beer is stinging cold. Friendly staff and great decor.
Facebook
Claire McGuckin Leface
+5
🍔 burgers are great! French dip yummy great service and great desserts 🍨 they have a separate room for parties and do off site catering
Facebook
Maddie Speth
+5
Went there tonight. Excellent service, food, drinks. I had the Coconut Shrimp perfect. Highly recommended
Facebook
Carol Riccio Faram
+5
French dip was excellent! Will be returning soon.
4
Darryl Brooks
+4
Tried a French Dip sandwich. Good size portion, fries were good, the beef was tender. Overall, good portion, but nothing special in flavor.
5
Mike G
+5
This restaurant truly makes one of the best French dip sandwiches. I have to say it was perfect and tasted amazing. The service was great and so were the appetizers and drinks. I highly recommend this place and you have to try their French dip sandwiches.
4
Pat B
+4
Great place for burger and fries! Had an awesome chocolate martini or two🤦🏻‍♀️. Our waiter waitress was awesome. Ambiance was warm and cozy. We started with the nachos and wings and they were perfect. Also had the grilled cheese, and it was perfect. Ended with cheese cake that was amazing!!!!
5
TJ Sirani
+5
I was intrigued by the sign outside that boasted about the french dip. Who doesnt love a good french dip? Well, I just left and the whole place totally lived up to the hype. The french dip was fantastic! Coming in to establishment I was surprised by how open and roomy it is. Plenty of room for large parties, networking groups or just someone looking for a drink or two. The tap beer selection is plentiful, the people are nice and welcoming and the atmosphere is perfect. I will definitely be back.... and I will probably bring a few friends. Thanks to Joanne for making me feel like a regular. :)
4
Sue Staltare
+4
Food was very good. I had the chicken dinner (chicken, balsamic glaze, mozzarella and tomato), which was great. Husband had a rare hamburger which he said was cooked perfect.
5
Renee Russo
+5
Came here for a pumpkin beer and stayed for the great food and awesome bartender!
5
Rey Ech
+5
This place is so good!!!! 🤤 first time here no regrets !!! Great staff great food !!!
4
Marian Sheridan
+4
They have some very good food here, especially their Mexican Pizza. Their French Dip sandwiches are also highly recommended. The staff is friendly. It can get pretty noisy sometimes but it's a good place for a reasonably priced meal.
5
Sue Rizzo
+5
I really enjoyed the french dip sandwich and crazy big hot pretzel appetizer. The service was excellent...overall an enjoyable experience!
5
Tatiana Panova
+5
I stop by for drinks 🍸. Very quiet place,comparing to others bars. Just surprised me it's close early ( 10 pm) . Food was normal, i can't say something extravagantly. And a lot of choices of meat. If you want just take a bite and talk ,this place for you.