First I’ll say this is my first and probably only review I’ve ever anyone left so it really impressed me.This is the best pizza I’ve had in Oklahoma by far, the crust was great and crispy on the bottom, zero flop as Pres would say, and is the closest to a New York slice I’ve had anywhere except for
Excellent pizza. One of the best in the state. I wish I had pizza is this good close to me but unfortunately I live an hour and a half away.Throw in some traditional buffalo wings and you’d have a winning combination. Update: They changed their hours to the point that they’re barely open. Why bother
The greatest pizza I have ever had in Oklahoma so far. They just arrived in Kingfisher, and I'm glad they did. They have pizzas ready to sell by the slice, in house made cheese cakes and a simple yet enjoyable atmosphere. If you haven't tried them yet, you SHOULD! You won't be disappointed.
Cindy's Pizza, how yummy this place is. I have lived in Stillwater 34 years. This is the best pizza I have had in this town. This pizza reminds me of Lombardi’s Pizza in Manhattan NY America’s first pizzeria. It’s perfect with good flavor and excellently cooked. The staff is great and friendly. I wi
I am truly sad to see this place leave Stillwater and move to Kingfisher. Their pizza was top notch, their garlic knots were heavenly, and Cindy herself was one of the most genuinely lovely people/restaurant owners I've ever met. To those willing to make the the trip to their new location (which I w
The pizza was wonderful! We each had a slice, that was hot and ready, warmed in a brick oven. Husband had the supreme, and I had the chicken, spinach Alfredo which was the special for the week. Topped off those slices, with homemade cheesecake we took to go. Awsome Cindy! Can't wait to return.
We got Cindy's pizza for the first time this evening and it was amazing! Hands down best pizza we've eaten in forever! We will be recommending this place to all our friends and family,and we'll be back soon!!! So glad you decided to open up a place in Kingfisher.
Drove from Stillwater to give it a shot, and despite the signs on the door and online saying they closed at 9pm, (and later we found a Facebook post saying 8:30pm due to the virus) we were told at 8:05ish that they do not accept any orders after 8pm as they like to close up shop by 8:15.
Definitely
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes