🔍 Key Lime Pie ✕

Best Key Lime Pie in Key West

The 5 best places to eat key lime pie in Key West: verified reviews, photos and ratings. Updated September 2026.

5 of 5 restaurants

Sort: ⭐ Top Rated 💬 Popular 💰 ↑ 💰 ↓

Kaya Island Eats

Kaya Island Eats

$$ - $$$ 💬 1330 reviews

📍 618 Duval St

Southernmost Key Lime Shop

$$ - $$$ 💬 164 reviews

📍 910 Duval St

Red Shoe Island Bistro

Red Shoe Island Bistro

$$ - $$$ 💬 1320 reviews

📍 411 Petronia St

Lola's Bistro

Lola's Bistro

$$$$ 💬 650 reviews

📍 728 Simonton St

Key West Key Lime Pie Company

📍 511 Greene St

Why Trust Sluurpy

Aggregated and verified data from multiple sources

📊

0 Reviews Analyzed

🏆

0 Top Restaurants

📋

0 Browsable Menus

📅

Sep 2026 Last Updated