🔍 Ice Cream ✕

Best Ice Cream in Key West

The 8 best places to eat ice cream in Key West: verified reviews, photos and ratings. Updated October 2026.

8 of 8 restaurants

Sort: ⭐ Top Rated 💬 Popular 💰 ↑ 💰 ↓

Flamingo Crossing Ice Cream

Flamingo Crossing Ice Cream

📍 1105 Duval St

Rooster Treats Ice Cream And Mini Donuts

Rooster Treats Ice Cream And Mini Donuts

📍 1327 Simonton Street

Key Best Pizza

$ 💬 268 reviews

📍 1104 Key Plaza

La Michoacana Key West

La Michoacana Key West

💬 72 reviews

📍 813 Peacock Plaza

Mattheessen's

Mattheessen's

$ 💬 186 reviews

📍 614 Greene St

Southernmost Key Lime Shop

$$ - $$$ 💬 164 reviews

📍 910 Duval St

Gladiators Ice Cream

📍 407 Front St

Key West Polar Bear Ice Cream Parlor

📍 291 Front Street Suite 105

Why Trust Sluurpy

Aggregated and verified data from multiple sources

📊

0 Reviews Analyzed

🏆

0 Top Restaurants

📋

0 Browsable Menus

📅

Oct 2026 Last Updated